Starfleet Judicial Courtroom
Detailed Involvements
Events with rich location context
The Starfleet Judicial Courtroom is referenced as the intended formal venue for adjudication; though the improvised hearing takes place in the JAG office, the courtroom looms as the canonical site where the legal battle will be publicly argued.
Formally grave in implication—an amphitheater of judgment that heightens the stakes even when not physically occupied.
Planned battleground for the forthcoming public adjudication over Data's personhood.
Embodies institutional weight and the public dimension of the legal question.
The Starfleet Judicial Courtroom is evoked as the future, formal battleground where Picard will defend Data; although not the scene's physical location, it represents the procedural destination and the institutional formality Phillipa invokes.
Implied formality and antiseptic gravity — a place where personal testimony is transformed into legal evidence.
Projected site for the hearing and adversarial contest Phillipa demands.
Embodies Starfleet's institutional authority and the cold conversion of moral questions into procedural disputes.
Restricted to appointed counsel, officers, and official witnesses; formal rules of procedure will apply.
The high-tech Starfleet courtroom functions as the formal arena where scientific fact, legal procedure and personal loyalty collide; its amphitheater layout gathers a gallery and institutional witnesses, converting private moral questions into public precedent-setting spectacle.
Oppressively formal and tension-filled; clinical lights and hush magnify the shock of the demonstration and the silence after Data collapses.
Stage for public confrontation and legal adjudication where institutional power is exercised and contested.
Embodies institutional authority and the sterilizing force of law that can dehumanize intimate relationships.
Open to a monitored gallery and authorized counsel; proceedings are formal and recorded under judicial constraints.
The Starfleet Judicial Courtroom provides the amphitheater-like public forum where technical definitions become public moral argument. Its formality and procedural apparatus convert private friendship into public precedent as the demonstration unfolds under official scrutiny.
Oppressively formal, tension-filled, and then stunned into shocked silence after the shutdown.
Stage for public confrontation and legal determination about personhood; a neutral institutional battlefield.
Embodies institutional power and the depersonalizing mechanics of law — where evidence can override empathy.
Open to authorized attendees and the public gallery but tightly governed by courtroom protocol and jurisdictional clearance.
The Starfleet judicial courtroom is the arena where the moral and legal struggle is concentrated; its formal architecture, recording consoles and raised bench frame Picard's theatrical shift from technicalities to ethics and channel the public weight of the decision.
Formally tense, then electric — sterile legalism gives way to an emotionally charged moral revelation.
Stage for public confrontation and legal determination.
Embodies institutional authority and the Federation's capacity to make precedent-setting moral decisions.
Courtroom protocol: restricted to authorized participants and observers, proceedings recorded and controlled.
The Starfleet judicial courtroom functions as the formal arena where private attachments are made public, expert authority is contested, and the Federation's moral character is legally tested; its architecture concentrates scrutiny and forces personal artifacts into evidentiary roles.
Oppressively formal shifting to electric moral intensity; silence punctuated by sharp rhetorical beats and a sudden eruption of courtroom emotion at Phillipa's ruling.
Stage for public confrontation and legal determination; crucible where ethical and institutional questions are forged into precedent.
Embodies institutional power and the risk that legal abstraction will strip humanity from persons; becomes the place where the Federation's values are articulated.
Official court proceeding: restricted to parties, counsel, witnesses, and authorized observers; recorded and formal.
The Starfleet courtroom functions as the formal arena where private life is translated into evidence and legal categories; its amphitheater layout concentrates attention and transforms Picard's rhetorical moves into institutional consequence, making the verdict a public precedent.
Tightly controlled, formally solemn until Picard's emotional strategy erupts the room into joy at the verdict — tense, then cathartic.
Stage for public adjudication and moral reckoning; battleground where law and ethics are argued.
Embodies institutional authority and the Federation's legal conscience; the site where society's treatment of artificial life is decided.
Formal courtroom procedures restrict participation to counsel, witnesses, and authorized observers; proceedings are controlled and recorded.
The Starfleet courtroom becomes the setting for the post-judgment coda: the institutional noise subsides and the space tightens into an intimate arena where private reconciliation occurs and moral meaning is made tangible beyond legal text.
From celebratory elation to hushed, intimate aftermath — the room contracts into a quieter moral temperature.
Stage for public adjudication and the immediate private fallout; it frames the verdict and then contains the human reconciliation that follows.
Embodies institutional authority turned humane — the place where law touches life and language begins to change.
Formal courtroom restrictions apply (officials present, proceedings recorded), though social proximity now overrides strict separation as Data approaches Maddox.
Events at This Location
Everything that happens here
In the JAG office Phillipa Louvois coldly rules Data the property of Starfleet under the Acts of Gould, converting a personnel dispute into a legal mandate. Picard instantly challenges her, …
In the JAG office Admiral Phillipa invokes the Acts of Gould and declares Data Starfleet property, triggering Picard to demand a hearing. Phillipa, pressed by logistics, orders the hearing be …
In open court Riker methodically reduces Data to machinery: he elicits that Data was built by Dr. Noonien Soong, has massive storage and processing capacity, then stages a public demonstration …
In open court Riker stages a clinical, devastating demonstration to prove Data is property: after extracting technical testimony and bending a plasteel bar, he removes Data's hand for inspection and, …
Picard abandons technical argument and transforms the hearing into an ethical test: he summons Data, produces the android's travel case—medals, a book of sonnets, a single holocube of Tasha Yar—and …
In the courtroom's emotional crucible Picard calls Data and then Maddox as a hostile witness, producing Data's medals, a book of sonnets and a holocube to humanize the android. Picard …
In the courtroom climax Picard reframes the hearing from technical taxonomy to moral precedent, humanizing Data with medals, sonnets and intimate testimony and forcing Commander Maddox into a corner. Picard's …
Immediately after Judge Phillipa's ruling, the courtroom's jubilation subsides into a quiet, intimate coda. Data approaches Commander Maddox and, with calm generosity, offers him permission to continue his research when …