Toby's Plain Oak Tag

Toby suggests plain oak tag—a sturdy, neutral paperboard—as a practical material to cover windows in the Outer Oval Office, sidestepping campaign posters. Will, Charlie, Bartlet, and Bonnie hear the recommendation during Toby's return from the Hill, underscoring his push for subdued decor amid Will's flustered Oval debut.

2 appearances

Appearances in the Narrative

When this object appears and how it's used

2 moments

S4E11 · Holy Night

Will's Awkward Oval Debut and Toby's Soft Landing

Toby jokingly suggests 'plain oak tag' as the appropriate material for covering campaign posters in federal buildings, using the object as a rhetorical prop to scold staff and restore professional decorum in his old office.

Before: Purely hypothetical; referenced as a suggested material, not actually present or used.

After: Remains a rhetorical suggestion; no physical change or deployment occurs in this scene.

View full event

S4E11 · Holy Night

Toby's Family Secret: Murder, Incorporated

Toby half-jokes that if campaign material must cover Will’s office windows, staff should use plain oak tag — the object functions as a rhetorical device to enforce rules and to mock the visual intrusion of campaign posters into a federal workspace.

Before: An abstracted suggested prop (not physically used), invoked as a lawful, low-key alternative to campaign posters.

After: Remains a suggested, unused option — a conversational tool rather than a physical change to the office.

View full event