Fabula
S4E2 · 20 Hours in America Part II

Nancy Pushes to Strike; Fitzwallace Stops the Room

In the Situation Room Nancy McNally bursts in, furious and blunt: “Let's attack.” Her impatience—born of repeated provocations—collides with Admiral Fitzwallace's grim, almost black-humored realism, as he graphically warns of wholesale destruction. The sparring forces Leo to ask questions and the team to confront hard facts: Qumar claims to have a tape, but Fitzwallace reveals there was no phone signal and no tape. The moment pivots the administration from reflexive retaliation to a cautious posture, exposing deep strategic and moral divisions and introducing the crucial realization that Qumar may fabricate evidence and even falsely blame a third party.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

2

Nancy McNally enters the Situation Room and provocatively suggests attacking Qumar, expressing her frustration with their provocations.

professional greeting to frustration ['Situation Room']

Fitzwallace questions Nancy's suggestion, highlighting the catastrophic consequences of an attack on Qumar.

frustration to bewilderment ['Situation Room']

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

5

Not present physically in the scene; emotionally implied as exposed and a catalyst for international tension.

Referenced repeatedly as the alleged caller from the downed plane; the team explains Shareef's phone was monitored and altered, making the claim of his call the focal point of the forensic rebuttal.

Goals in this moment
  • (Inferred) Conceal involvement in illicit activities tied to the downed plane.
  • (Inferred) Avoid political and criminal exposure resulting from U.S. intelligence links.
Active beliefs
  • (Inferred) Operational secrecy is critical; exposure would be dangerous.
  • (Inferred) Foreign actions may be deniable if plausible evidence is manufactured.
Character traits
implicated covertly monitored instrumental absent
Follow Abdul Lebin …'s journey

Darkly pragmatic and quietly horrified; uses grim humor to underscore the stakes and to shock the room into caution.

Sits at the table and methodically rebuts Nancy's call to arms with grim, technical reality — explaining the phone was disabled, communications monitored, and a dummy battery used — and warns of catastrophic consequences of a strike.

Goals in this moment
  • Prevent an impulsive military response that would cause massive civilian and friendly casualties.
  • Establish factual, technical evidence to correct the record about the alleged tape.
  • Re-center the discussion on operational reality and risk assessment.
Active beliefs
  • Military action without full forensic confirmation would be catastrophic.
  • Intelligence and technical facts must govern any recommendation to the President.
  • Adversaries are capable of fabricating evidence to manipulate responses.
Character traits
grim sardonic pragmatic precise morally weighty
Follow Percy Fitzwallace's journey

Righteously indignant with threaded exhaustion—angry at repeated provocations and impatient for decisive action.

Bursts into the Situation Room, sits beside Leo, and bluntly pushes for recommending an attack on Qumar, citing intel about a tape; her impatience drives the initial escalation of the room's debate.

Goals in this moment
  • Force the administration to recommend a military strike against Qumar.
  • Protect American credibility by demonstrating resolve.
  • Short-circuit bureaucratic delay and compel immediate executive action.
Active beliefs
  • Qumar is a repeat provocateur who must be stopped by force.
  • A decisive military response will deter future attacks and restore deterrence.
  • Intelligence claiming a tape is actionable and justifies escalation.
Character traits
furious blunt impatient decisive provocative
Follow Nancy McNally's journey

Not present in the room; implied position: weighty responsibility and expectation of measured counsel from advisors.

Mentioned as the recipient of any formal recommendation to strike; he is the ultimate decision-maker whose judgment the advisors seek to influence through this debate.

Goals in this moment
  • (Institutional) Receive clear, fact-based recommendations before authorizing military action.
  • (Political) Preserve national security while avoiding unnecessary escalation.
Active beliefs
  • (Inferred) Military action must be morally and strategically justified.
  • (Inferred) Presidential approval should be based on vetted intelligence.
Character traits
authoritative responsible moral
Follow Josiah Bartlet's journey

Concerned and puzzled; urgently seeks facts to prevent a policy mistake while balancing political and military pressures.

Sits at the conference table, asks clarifying questions, and attempts to mediate between Nancy's fury and Fitzwallace's technical cautions, steering the room from reflex toward inquiry.

Goals in this moment
  • Clarify the factual basis for any recommendation to the President.
  • Prevent a hasty, politically damaging military response.
  • Preserve institutional credibility while protecting national security.
Active beliefs
  • Decisions of war require unambiguous evidence and careful counsel.
  • Qumar may be trying to bait the U.S. into a mistake.
  • Leadership must be steered away from emotionally driven actions.
Character traits
mediating concerned inquiring steady authoritative
Follow Leo McGarry's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

2
Situation Room Conference Table

The Situation Room conference table is where Leo, Fitzwallace, and Nancy sit and verbally spar; it acts as the physical anchor for the exchange, focusing the group's body language and the cadence of interrogation and rebuttal.

Before: Set in the Situation Room with senior staff …
After: Remains in place as the team shifts from …
Before: Set in the Situation Room with senior staff seated; documents and monitors nearby (in active use).
After: Remains in place as the team shifts from immediate anger to investigative posture; continues to serve as the locus for follow-up briefing.
Danny Concannon's Proof Linking U.S. to Shareef's Plane

The downed plane (treated as an evidentiary object) is invoked as the origin point for the alleged phone call and tape; Fitzwallace uses the plane's monitored/bugged status to refute the existence of any transmitted call or tape, turning the wreckage into a forensic pivot in the conversation.

Before: A downed, monitored aircraft whose communications were disabled …
After: Remains the focal point of investigation; its monitored …
Before: A downed, monitored aircraft whose communications were disabled and which had been subject to U.S. surveillance measures.
After: Remains the focal point of investigation; its monitored status is cited to discredit Qumar's claim and to suggest possible fabrication of evidence.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

2
Northwest Lobby

The White House Situation Room functions as the formal decision forum where military, intelligence and political advice collide; its institutional gravity forces the characters to translate emotion into policy language and to confront operational facts under pressure.

Atmosphere Tension-filled and clipped — immediate, serious, and electric with contained anger and urgent questioning.
Function Meeting place for senior advisors to evaluate intelligence and craft recommendations to the President.
Symbolism Embodies institutional power and the moral weight of decisions about force and consequence.
Access Restricted to senior staff and cleared personnel; closed, high-security environment.
Overhead lights and a conference table centralize the action. Concise, rapid-fire dialogue and quiet hum of monitors underscore urgency.
Shareef's Plane

Shareef's plane (the physical crash site/flight) is the forensic locus invoked for the alleged phone call; its technical status (jammed communications, bugged, and altered battery) is the factual basis Fitzwallace uses to disprove Qumar's tape claim.

Atmosphere Implied as silent, controlled and instrumented — an isolated site that was under U.S. technical …
Function Site of alleged transmission and the evidence chain's origin story — central to the credibility …
Symbolism Symbolizes the slipperiness of truth in covert operations and the danger of manufactured narratives.
Access Not publicly accessible; under military/intelligence control and subject to operational secrecy.
Communications were jammed/disabled aboard the plane. The phone was monitored and its battery replaced with a dummy as counterintelligence measures.

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

1
Sultanate of Qumar

The Sultanate of Qumar functions as the provocative foreign actor whose alleged broadcast of a tape is the immediate cause of the crisis; Qumar's claim threatens to manipulate international opinion and to bait the U.S. into a hasty military response.

Representation Manifested through the reported claim of possessing a tape and the diplomatic noise that forces …
Power Dynamics Qumar is cast as an instigator challenging U.S. credibility; while militarily weaker, it uses narrative …
Impact Qumar's action stresses institutional restraints and forces the White House to choose between reactive force …
Internal Dynamics Implied tactical willingness to fabricate evidence and manipulate international lawfare; potentially factionalized approach relying on …
Manufacture a plausible narrative that shifts blame away from itself or onto a third party. Provoke a U.S. response that could be politically or militarily exploitable. Undermine U.S. credibility by fabricating forensic evidence (the alleged tape). Propaganda and media — broadcasting an alleged tape to shape perceptions. Diplomatic pressure — using claims to force U.S. public and governmental reaction. Deceptive evidence — fabricating or planting forensic material to alter the narrative.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What this causes 4
Escalation medium

"Nancy McNally's initial suggestion to attack Qumar escalates into a broader debate about how to respond to their fabricated evidence, reflecting the growing tension and stakes."

Oval Office — Credibility, Loyalty, and the Coming Provocation
S4E2 · 20 Hours in America Part …
Escalation medium

"Nancy McNally's initial suggestion to attack Qumar escalates into a broader debate about how to respond to their fabricated evidence, reflecting the growing tension and stakes."

Owning the Ship: Bartlet Refuses to Disown Shareef
S4E2 · 20 Hours in America Part …
NARRATIVELY_FOLLOWS

"The revelation of Qumar's fabricated tape sets up the later discussion about how to respond to their claims, maintaining narrative continuity on the international crisis."

Oval Office — Credibility, Loyalty, and the Coming Provocation
S4E2 · 20 Hours in America Part …
NARRATIVELY_FOLLOWS

"The revelation of Qumar's fabricated tape sets up the later discussion about how to respond to their claims, maintaining narrative continuity on the international crisis."

Owning the Ship: Bartlet Refuses to Disown Shareef
S4E2 · 20 Hours in America Part …

Key Dialogue

"NANCY: "Let's attack.""
"FITZWALLACE: "Well, 98% of all living organisms within a seven mile radius would die instantly in a torrent of fire.""
"FITZWALLACE: "There isn't. We disabled the phone. We monitered communication from the plane, we bugged Shareef and we replaced his cell phone battery with a dummy. There's no tape, there was no phone call.""