Fabula
S2E18 · 17 People
S2E18
· 17 People

Leo Breaks Through: Bartlet Agrees to Reveal MS to Toby

In the Oval Office, amid discussions of embassy closures and looming domestic threats, Leo urgently presses President Bartlet to disclose his secret MS diagnosis to Toby, whose suspicions about Hoynes' succession maneuvering have reached a fever pitch. Bartlet resists fiercely, slamming his notebook and challenging Leo to predict the staff's shock, betrayal, and confusion. Ultimately yielding with a heavy sigh—'Now it starts'—Bartlet authorizes Leo to tell Toby everything, marking a pivotal turning point that shatters the administration's fragile secrecy and cascades toward explosive confrontations.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

4

Bartlet reveals he's closed embassies in Tanzania and Brussels while deflecting Leo's concern about domestic threats.

urgency to evasion ['Oval Office']

Leo urgently insists they must tell Toby about the MS diagnosis as he's piecing together Hoynes' political moves.

concern to insistence

Bartlet slams his notebook while challenging Leo to predict staff reactions to the MS revelation.

frustration to foreboding

Leo finally convinces Bartlet to reveal everything to Toby, who sighs knowing this begins their reckoning.

resolve to resignation

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

4

Maneuvering confidence inferred through actions

Hoynes is invoked repeatedly as the instigator whose substitution for Trotter, secret poll, and Vermont-New Hampshire itinerary fuel Toby's suspicions, framing him as the shadowy catalyst forcing the MS revelation.

Goals in this moment
  • Position himself for 2002 ticket via polling and visibility
  • Exploit perceived Bartlet weaknesses without direct confrontation
Active beliefs
  • Bartlet's vulnerabilities create an opening for his ascent
  • Subtle public moves mask aggressive succession strategy
Character traits
calculating ambitious subtle
Follow John Hoynes's journey

Intensely curious and probing, verging on confrontation

Toby waits off-screen in his office, his fevered suspicions—sparked by Hoynes' maneuvers—directly catalyzing Leo's push for MS disclosure, positioning him as the imminent recipient of shattering truth.

Goals in this moment
  • Uncover the truth behind Hoynes' anomalous political moves
  • Protect the administration from internal betrayal
Active beliefs
  • Hoynes' actions signal a direct threat to Bartlet's re-election
  • Persistent digging will expose hidden vulnerabilities
Character traits
perceptive tenacious suspicious
Follow Toby Ziegler's journey

Neutral bystander, uninvolved directly

Bill Trotter is referenced solely as the sidelined figure whose energy speech slot Hoynes commandeered, igniting Toby's initial curiosity and snowballing into the demand for MS disclosure.

Goals in this moment
  • Deliver prepared policy address unhindered
  • Support administration messaging
Active beliefs
  • Technical expertise trumps political showmanship
  • Substitution disrupts planned diplomacy
Character traits
deferential policy-focused
Follow Bill Trotter's journey

frustrated, resistant, resigned

sits at the desk, announces closure of embassies in Tanzania and Brussels, resists Leo's urging to disclose MS diagnosis to Toby, slams notebook on desk, rises and challenges Leo to predict staff reactions, ultimately agrees to tell Toby everything, sighs heavily

Goals in this moment
  • handle immediate crisis of embassy closures and domestic threats
  • resist and challenge the idea of revealing MS diagnosis
  • assess potential staff shock, betrayal, confusion before agreeing
Character traits
protective resolute self-aware principled
Follow Josiah Bartlet's journey

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 3
Thematic Parallel

"Toby's realization about Hoynes' political moves parallels Bartlet's grappling with immediate crisis and terror threats."

Toby's Ball-Smashing Obsession with Hoynes' Polls
S2E18 · 17 People
Thematic Parallel

"Toby's realization about Hoynes' political moves parallels Bartlet's grappling with immediate crisis and terror threats."

Toby Corners Leo on Hoynes Ticket Rumors
S2E18 · 17 People
Thematic Parallel

"Toby's realization about Hoynes' political moves parallels Bartlet's grappling with immediate crisis and terror threats."

Toby Ambush-Decodes Hoynes' Succession Maneuver
S2E18 · 17 People
What this causes 3
Causal

"Leo convincing Bartlet to reveal everything to Toby leads to Bartlet's revelation of his MS diagnosis."

Leo Cautions Agitated Toby Before Charged Oval Entry
S2E18 · 17 People
Causal

"Leo convincing Bartlet to reveal everything to Toby leads to Bartlet's revelation of his MS diagnosis."

Bartlet Deflects with Nitroglycerin Terror Threat
S2E18 · 17 People
Causal

"Leo convincing Bartlet to reveal everything to Toby leads to Bartlet's revelation of his MS diagnosis."

Bartlet Confesses MS Diagnosis to Stunned Toby
S2E18 · 17 People

Key Dialogue

"LEO: "Mr. President, I've got Toby waiting in his office right now. We've got to tell him." BARTLET: "Tell him what?""
"BARTLET: "([rising]) The staff's reaction will be what?" LEO: "I don't know! Shock, betrayal, confusion, concern about our future?""
"BARTLET: "What do I tell him?" LEO: "Everything." BARTLET: "Go tell him.""