Abbey Forces Leo to Know: Bartlet Has MS

In Leo McGarry's office a domestic, joking moment with Mallory collapses into a private crisis: Abbey, finally unable to contain herself, tells Leo that the President has long concealed a diagnosis of multiple sclerosis. Their guarded small talk about fevers and postponed plans gives way to a devastating admission — Abbey's eye filling with tears — reframing Bartlet's recent collapse as a potentially life‑threatening medical catastrophe and a political time bomb. The revelation is a turning point: Leo must now carry the burden of a secret that changes the Stakes of the State of the Union and every decision that follows.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

4

Abbey praises Leo's recent actions, subtly transitioning into a discussion about the President's health.

supportive to concerned

Leo confronts Abbey about her evasiveness regarding the President's condition, pressing for the truth.

concern to urgency

Abbey reveals the President's multiple sclerosis diagnosis to Leo, marking a pivotal moment of truth and vulnerability.

urgency to shock

Abbey explains the life-threatening implications of the President's fever, underscoring the gravity of the situation.

shock to sorrow

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

3

Playful and slightly embarrassed during the teasing; brisk and withdrawn as she exits, preferring to stay out of adult matters.

Mallory participates in the opening, playful exchange — resists Abbey's teasing, kisses Leo goodbye, leaves the office and closes the door, removing herself before the confession — she is present for the domestic preface but not the private revelation.

Goals in this moment
  • Avoid embarrassment and deflect romantic teasing.
  • Leave her parents to have their private conversation without interference.
Active beliefs
  • Family matters can and should be kept private between adults.
  • Her role in the moment is to be supportive but not to mediate complex adult decisions.
Character traits
sardonic affectionate protective of privacy blunt
Follow Mallory McGarry …'s journey

Surface calm and authoritative, shifting quickly to contained alarm and betrayal as he registers the magnitude of the secret.

Leo enters, greets them with casual paternal warmth, immediately notices tension, sits to interrogate gently but insistently, presses Abbey for specifics, and reacts with stunned shock when told the President has multiple sclerosis.

Goals in this moment
  • Ascertain the truth about the President's condition and its immediacy.
  • Protect the President's health and the institutional stability of the White House.
Active beliefs
  • The President's health is both a private and an institutional concern requiring honest triage.
  • Covering medical issues creates greater risk than facing them; he believes urgency and clarity are needed now.
Character traits
procedural protective perceptive controlled under pressure
Follow Leo Thomas …'s journey
Josiah Edward 'Jed' Bartlet (President of the United States)

Although not physically present, President Bartlet is the subject of the revelation: Abbey names him as the patient, and his …

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

2
Upholstered Couch (Leo McGarry's Office)

The upholstered couch functions as the informal confidant chair: Abbey shifts to it after Mallory leaves, using its physical separation from Leo's desk to create a private, domestic frame for her confession. The couch's sagging cushions and lived‑in quality underscore the intimacy of the exchange and the contrast between personal care and institutional duties.

Before: Unoccupied, cushions yielding and faintly indented from regular …
After: Occupied by Abbey during the confession; cushions bear …
Before: Unoccupied, cushions yielding and faintly indented from regular use; positioned in Leo's office as usual.
After: Occupied by Abbey during the confession; cushions bear the temporary impression of her weight and emotional collapse (a visible tear), then return to repose when the scene fades.
C.J. Cregg's Office Doorway (with narrow eye‑level windowpane)

The corridor doorway serves as the threshold that turns a semi‑public office into a private confessional: Mallory crosses the threshold, plants a kiss, exits, and deliberately closes the door, creating the necessary privacy for Abbey's revelation and symbolically isolating the adult world of secrets from the adolescent sphere.

Before: Open or ajar while Mallory and others mill …
After: Closed by Mallory after she departs, establishing a …
Before: Open or ajar while Mallory and others mill around; acting as a porous boundary between corridor and Leo's office.
After: Closed by Mallory after she departs, establishing a guarded, private space for Abbey and Leo's difficult exchange.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Leo McGarry's Office (Chief of Staff's Office)

Leo's office is the crucible for the scene: a compact, domestic‑feeling executive room that concentrates personal photographs, a couch, and a desk into a pressure chamber where political management and private truth collide. It provides the necessary privacy and institutional gravitas for Abbey's medical confession to land with immediate operational consequence.

Atmosphere Intimate and tension‑laden: playful banter gives way to hushed, urgent seriousness; the room feels claustrophobic …
Function Sanctuary for private revelation and immediate decision‑making about the President's health and consequent political actions.
Symbolism Embodies the intersection of family intimacy and institutional responsibility — the office becomes where personal …
Access Effectively restricted to senior staff and family in this moment; Mallory leaves and closes the …
Narrow corridor light slicing into the room, focusing attention The soft, worn couch that invites confessions The audible click/closure of the door marking the shift to privacy The sensory background of office clutter and personal photographs suggesting private life inside public work

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 2
NARRATIVELY_FOLLOWS medium

"C.J.'s arrival to discuss Leo's press crisis transitions into Abbey praising Leo's actions, showing the shifting focus of the narrative."

Excluded and Instructed: Leo's Quiet Contingency
S1E12 · He Shall, From Time To …
NARRATIVELY_FOLLOWS medium

"C.J.'s arrival to discuss Leo's press crisis transitions into Abbey praising Leo's actions, showing the shifting focus of the narrative."

Preemptive Damage Control: C.J. Reveals the Leak
S1E12 · He Shall, From Time To …

Key Dialogue

"LEO: What does he have he can't tell people?"
"ABBEY: He has multiple sclerosis, Leo."
"ABBEY: A fever could be life threatening."