Fabula
S2E19 · Bad Moon Rising

Babish Erupts Over Staff's Legal Blunders, Defies Vacation Push

In his office, Oliver Babish unleashes sarcastic fury at his team's flawed HR 437 analysis, fixating on ignored Fourth Amendment issues while staff pleadingly urges him toward a 'forced vacation'—an international law summit in Borneo. He demands briefs, defends his Brandeis gavel, and rants about a Dictaphone jammed on record, symbolizing uncontainable secrets. Interrupted by news of Leo and the President arriving, this beat cements Babish's workaholic zeal, rejecting respite to plunge deeper into the MS conspiracy crisis, heightening stakes.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

3

Oliver Babish vents frustration over flawed legal analysis, revealing his meticulous attention to constitutional details.

frustration to exasperation

Oliver's team attempts to usher him toward vacation preparations, highlighting his resistance to stepping away from work.

reluctance to resignation

Oliver reveals disdain for the forced vacation, masking exhaustion with sarcasm about the international law summit.

sarcasm to weariness

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

5

Sarcastic fury veiling bone-deep fatigue and fierce determination to confront the MS crisis head-on.

Dominates the desk area, unleashing rapid-fire sarcastic critiques of staff's HR 437 flaws, demanding specific briefs, fiercely defending his gavel's heritage, ranting about the Dictaphone's malfunction, and reluctantly acknowledging the incoming President and Leo while resisting vacation.

Goals in this moment
  • Correct staff's legal oversights on HR 437 immediately
  • Resist vacation to remain available for escalating White House crises
Active beliefs
  • Legal precision, especially Fourth Amendment, is non-negotiable
  • Duty to the presidency trumps personal rest amid conspiracy threats
Character traits
sarcastic workaholic defiant detail-oriented exhausted yet resolute
Follow Abigail Bartlet's journey

Pleading concern laced with frustrated protectiveness for her overworked boss.

Hovers supportively near Babish's desk, repeatedly pleading for him to sleep and depart for vacation, confirming amicus brief's readiness, offering to pack the gavel, and advising tie adjustment amid the President's approach.

Goals in this moment
  • Convince Babish to rest before his flight
  • Streamline his departure logistics including packing heirlooms
Active beliefs
  • Exhaustion undermines effective counsel during crises
  • Staff must enforce boundaries for leader's sustainability
Character traits
persistent concerned efficient loyal
Follow White House …'s journey

sarcastic and furious

erupting in sarcastic criticism of his staff's flawed HR 437 analysis ignoring Fourth Amendment, resisting vacation push, demanding legal briefs, defending his gavel, and complaining about malfunctioning Dictaphone

Goals in this moment
  • reject forced vacation to continue legal work on MS conspiracy
  • obtain amicus brief on Sovereign Immunity and Federal Land Use
Character traits
methodical relentless incisive professional unflappable
Follow Oliver Babish's journey

Calm professionalism underscoring mounting urgency from incoming leadership.

Positions himself professionally in the office, specifies the Borneo destination, confirms Federal Land Use document availability, and relays urgent call from Leo McGarry's office about the President en route.

Goals in this moment
  • Reinforce the vacation push to Borneo
  • Alert Babish to the immediate arrival of McGarry and President
Active beliefs
  • Chain of command demands instant prioritization of senior summons
  • Logistical precision supports crisis management
Character traits
professional concise alert dutiful
Follow Counsel Man's journey

arriving at the office with Mr. McGarry

Goals in this moment
  • consult with Babish on ongoing crisis
Character traits
protective resolute self-aware principled
Follow Josiah Bartlet's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

3
Oliver Babish's Brandeis Gavel

Perched prominently in the desk's center, the oversized Brandeis gavel becomes a flashpoint when staff offers to pack it ('big hammer') for Borneo's trip; Babish passionately defends its heritage from Justice Louis Brandeis via his grandfather, symbolizing unyielding legal tradition amid his resistance to leave the MS maelstrom.

Before: Positioned in the middle of Oliver Babish's desk, …
After: Remains on the desk, unpacked and emblematic of …
Before: Positioned in the middle of Oliver Babish's desk, untouched.
After: Remains on the desk, unpacked and emblematic of Babish's anchored duty.
Babish's Amicus Brief on Sovereign Immunity

Demanded urgently by Babish amid his HR 437 critique as essential for Sovereign Immunity arguments; Woman confirms its presence on or near the desk, underscoring staff's prep efforts while highlighting Babish's fixation on legal arsenal during vacation resistance and crisis interruption.

Before: Prepared and located on or near Babish's desk.
After: Still available on desk, ready but unaddressed due …
Before: Prepared and located on or near Babish's desk.
After: Still available on desk, ready but unaddressed due to incoming visitors.
Federal Land Use

Promptly requested by Babish following the amicus brief, tied to HR 437's Fourth Amendment scrutiny; Man verifies its readiness, positioning it as a critical document in the office frenzy, amplifying themes of overlooked constitutional pitfalls amid pleas for Babish's exodus.

Before: Assembled and placed on or near the desk …
After: Unaltered on desk, primed for potential review before …
Before: Assembled and placed on or near the desk by staff.
After: Unaltered on desk, primed for potential review before presidential arrival.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

2
White House Counsel's Office

Serves as the pressure-cooker arena for Babish's tirade, staff interventions, and document checks, cluttered with desk artifacts like gavel and Dictaphone; the space crackles with interrupted reckonings as news of Leo and President pivots the mood from departure to confrontation.

Atmosphere Tense and chaotic, humming with sarcasm, pleas, and sudden hierarchical urgency.
Function Staging ground for internal legal team clash and crisis pivot point.
Symbolism Fortress of unraveling secrets where workaholic duty collides with rest's impossibility.
Access Restricted to Counsel staff, with principals like President incoming.
Cluttered desk bearing gavel, briefs, and jammed Dictaphone Daylight filtering into a high-stakes bunker vibe
Borneo

Looms as the exotic, resisted endpoint of Babish's 'forced vacation'—an international law summit invoked by Man and woven into staff's desperate push for reprieve, contrasting DC's frenzy with distant irrelevance amid MS stakes.

Atmosphere Evoked as humid, obligatory escape mocking the office's grinding pulse.
Function Symbolic foil representing unattainable respite.
Symbolism Distant horizon of surrender Babish rejects for conspiracy's frontline.
Access International venue for jurists, targeted for Babish's supportive role.
Implied steamy halls and vine-choked isolation Contrasts sharply with White House immediacy

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

1
White House Counsel's Office

Manifests through Babish's leadership and staff's frantic document handling in dissecting HR 437 flaws, embodying the legal bulwark against MS perjury exposures; the office grind rejects vacation protocols as presidential summons reinforce its crisis centrality.

Representation Via Counsel Oliver Babish and direct aides executing prep and relays.
Power Dynamics Internal hierarchy strained by Babish's resistance, overridden by White House principals' approach.
Impact Highlights fragility of legal firewalls in presidential scandals, amplifying perjury risks.
Internal Dynamics Tension between workaholic counsel and protective staff pushing boundaries.
Bolster legal analyses like HR 437 to avert constitutional pitfalls Retain key personnel amid looming MS conspiracy interrogations Provision of critical briefs and artifacts like gavel Staff pressure and communication relays enforcing operational continuity

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What this causes 1
Symbolic Parallel medium

"The malfunctioning Dictaphone symbolizes uncontrollable recording and compromised secrets, mirroring Oliver Babish's confrontation with President Bartlet about his MS concealment, which is also about uncontrolled truth and secrecy."

Babish Probes Bartlet's MS Knowledge
S2E19 · Bad Moon Rising

Key Dialogue

"OLIVER BABISH: "Do you know why?" WOMAN: "Oliver..." OLIVER BABISH: "Because my staff's work on the analysis of HR 437 ignored the Fourth Amendment implications and instead... became fascinated with the Third, Seventh and Eleventh.""
"OLIVER BABISH: "It's not a vacation." WOMAN: "You'll have a..." OLIVER BABISH: "It's a forced vacation." MAN: "In Borneo.""
"OLIVER BABISH: "It's stuck on record. It won't stop recording things; so it's just what you want lying around the White House Counsel's Office because there's never been a problem with that before." MAN: "That was Mr. McGarry's office. He's on his way down with the President.""