Portico Decision: Bartlet Commits to Hiring Ainsley Hayes

After a terse correction about AIDS and HIV with Leo, Bartlet watches President Nimbala's desperate plea and then fixates on a televised takedown in which conservative pundit Ainsley Hayes utterly dismantles Sam. Moved by her intellect and what he perceives as civic duty, Bartlet decides — over Leo's pragmatic skepticism — to recruit her into the White House. The moment converts moral frustration over global health failures into a deliberate political outreach that will unsettle staff loyalties and set up future conflict.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

4

Bartlet and Leo debate the connection between AIDS and poverty, with Bartlet dismissing the Health Minister's ignorance about HIV/AIDS.

frustration to debate ['Portico']

Bartlet abruptly shifts the conversation to Ainsley Hayes's televised takedown of Sam, revealing his fascination with her intelligence and sense of duty.

seriousness to intrigue ['Oval Office']

Bartlet announces his decision to hire Ainsley Hayes, sparking resistance from Leo who questions both the necessity and practicality.

enthusiasm to confrontation ['Oval Office']

Bartlet reaffirms his directive to hire Ainsley despite Leo's continued skepticism, framing it as a strategic inclusion of Republican voices.

jocular resistance to firm insistence ['Oval Office']

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

13

Insistently analytical

Questions Bartlet on debt forgiveness consideration amid health crisis, representing press corps' policy thrusts.

Goals in this moment
  • Gauge fiscal commitments
  • Force broad policy admissions
Active beliefs
  • Crises demand all options
  • Press exposes hidden agendas
Character traits
probing assertive
Follow Unnamed White …'s journey
Arthur
primary

Professionally incisive

Called by C.J., directs question to Nimbala via translator on 'home run' summit outcome, amplifying stakes in press scrum.

Goals in this moment
  • Elicit candid foreign perspective
  • Define success metrics publicly
Active beliefs
  • Leaders reveal truths under scrutiny
  • Questions pierce diplomacy
Character traits
probing persistent direct
Follow Arthur's journey

Inquisitively pointed

Rises in Mural Room to question Bartlet sharply on summit photo op excluding pharma leaders versus Nimbala, probing political calculus.

Goals in this moment
  • Expose political motivations
  • Tighten administration on optics
Active beliefs
  • Absences reveal strategy
  • Press holds power accountable
Character traits
inquisitive relentless sarcasm-edged
Follow Katie (Reporter)'s journey
C.J. Cregg
primary

Poised command veiling policy strain

Manages Mural Room press Q&A, introduces presidents, points to questioners like Arthur, thanks everyone to disperse crowd after Borlaug miracle anecdote.

Goals in this moment
  • Control press interaction flow
  • Facilitate summit photo op smoothly
Active beliefs
  • Structured briefings contain chaos
  • Optics shape public narrative
Character traits
professional controlled efficient
Follow C.J. Cregg's journey

Dutiful with slight amused detachment

Greets Bartlet routinely in Portico, enters Oval to hand steaming mug, delivers deadpan joke on Republican inclusion when consulted on hiring Ainsley, absorbs playful rebuke with poise.

Goals in this moment
  • Support presidential routine seamlessly
  • Engage lightly in hiring banter
Active beliefs
  • Humor diffuses tension
  • Duty overrides partisan quips
Character traits
dutiful witty composed loyal
Follow Charlie Young's journey

Warmly routine amid underlying urgency

Greets Bartlet cordially with 'Good morning, Mr. President' upon Oval entry, providing brief routine anchor amid hiring pivot and global crisis echoes.

Goals in this moment
  • Maintain Oval Office decorum
  • Welcome president seamlessly
Active beliefs
  • Ritual greetings fortify daily cadence
  • Presence steadies leadership
Character traits
cordial steady professional
Follow Dolores Landingham's journey

Functionally composed

Whispers translations during press Q&A, relays Nimbala's 'miracle' response and detailed Borlaug wheat anecdote elevating U.S. as miracle-maker.

Goals in this moment
  • Convey Nimbala's pleas accurately
  • Preserve dignity in vulnerability
Active beliefs
  • Translation bridges desperation to power
  • Stories like Borlaug inspire action
Character traits
precise neutral facilitative
Follow Nimbala Translator's journey
Crowd
primary

Respectfully attentive

Gathers in Mural Room chorusing 'Good morning, Mr. President' greetings, disperses on C.J.'s cue post-Q&A.

Goals in this moment
  • Observe summit optics
  • Participate in ritual pageantry
Active beliefs
  • Protocol amplifies authority
  • Collective presence validates events
Character traits
respectful disciplined neutral
Follow Crowd's journey

decisive, morally engaged, intrigued

Walking with Leo, correcting misconceptions about AIDS/HIV, watching/recalling Sam's televised takedown, decides to hire Ainsley Hayes, puts on glasses, addresses press and President Nimbala, instructs Charlie and Leo about recruiting Ainsley.

Goals in this moment
  • assert factual clarity about AIDS and HIV
  • respond to the international health crisis
  • recruit Ainsley Hayes into the White House
Character traits
protective resolute self-aware principled
Follow Josiah Bartlet's journey

Humiliated (implied via reference)

Referenced by Bartlet as 'purEed' on Capital Beat by Ainsley, her takedown catalyzing the hiring impulse.

Character traits
fiercely loyal emotionally perceptive decisive principled resolute amid grief
Follow Sam Seaborn's journey

Admired from afar

Praised by Bartlet for intellect and civic duty after dismantling Sam; Leo notes her columns and Dreifort clerkship; target of decisive hire order.

Character traits
intelligent duty-driven (perceived)
Follow Ainsley Hayes's journey
Dreifort
primary

Referenced as the person for whom Ainsley was clerking.

Character traits
conservative intolerant ideologically rigid controversial
Follow Dreifort's journey

Mentioned by Bartlet/translator as the Nobel laureate responsible for dwarf wheat; used as an example of a 'miracle'.

Character traits
visionary pragmatic transformative revered
Follow Norman Borlaug's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

4
Portico Office Mug

Charlie enters Oval bearing steaming mug, handing it to seated Bartlet during hiring consultation with Leo—serves as tactile routine anchor amid impulsive decree, steam curling as decision solidifies against skepticism.

Before: Held by Charlie entering Oval
After: In Bartlet's possession at Resolute Desk
Before: Held by Charlie entering Oval
After: In Bartlet's possession at Resolute Desk
Dwarf Wheat (Illustrative Varietal Reference)

Invoked rhetorically by translator's Borlaug anecdote and Bartlet's 'dwarf wheat' elaboration during/after press Q&A, paralleling miracle pleas to AIDS drugs—metaphorically fuels moral urgency blending into Ainsley hire pivot.

Before: Abstract historical reference
After: Lingering in conversation as Portico walk motif
Before: Abstract historical reference
After: Lingering in conversation as Portico walk motif
West Wing Portico Capital Beat Monitor

Implicitly recalled via Bartlet's vivid recount of Ainsley's live Capital Beat demolition of Sam—Portico monitor's prior glow haunts decision, catalyzing recruitment as intellectual beacon amid Nimbala's despair.

Before: Off-air from previous night
After: Evocative memory propelling action
Before: Off-air from previous night
After: Evocative memory propelling action
Bartlet's Oval Office Radio Microphone

Bartlet dons glasses at desk upon recalling Sam's Capital Beat rout by Ainsley, sharpening focus symbolically as hiring epiphany strikes amid Leo's amusement—lenses frame the intellectual spark igniting partisan outreach.

Before: In pocket or on desk, unused
After: Worn on face during initial discussion
Before: In pocket or on desk, unused
After: Worn on face during initial discussion

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

2
East Colonnade

Pillared walkway hosts initial AIDS correction, Sam/Ainsley recall with glasses donning, post-Mural return where Bartlet waggles finger insisting on hire over Leo's doubts—transitional nexus fusing crisis echo to Oval decree.

Atmosphere Tense daylight hush laced with wry banter
Function Transition/entry point for deliberations
Symbolism Threshold between public duty and private resolve
Access Senior staff and president only
Flagstone footsteps echoing Filtered pillar shadows
Mural Room

Mural Room packs press for summit photo op and Q&A; Nimbala's handshake, Katie/Arthur/Reporter probes, translator's miracle/Borlaug tale heighten desperation priming Bartlet's outreach pivot.

Atmosphere Flashbulb tension with desperate pleas
Function Public diplomatic forum
Symbolism Clash of humanitarian anguish and optics
Access Press and principals; controlled dispersal
Podium forest glare Mural shadows over interrogations

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

5
Capital Beat

Capital Beat invoked as platform where Ainsley demolished Sam, Bartlet's fascination with her performance sparking hire—media ambush retrospectively fuels White House ideological gamble.

Representation Via recounted broadcast takedown
Power Dynamics External media exposes vulnerabilities, prompts recruitment
Impact Catalyzes cross-aisle hire disrupting loyalty
Amplify partisan clashes Elevate sharp analysts Live debate format Viral humiliation clips
Republican Party

Republican Party framed as enduring force ('not going anywhere') by Bartlet against Leo's mandate logic; Ainsley's affiliation central to risky hire debate.

Representation Through prospective hiree's pedigree
Power Dynamics Challenged as 'losers' yet courted for dissent
Impact Forces inclusion amid Democratic dominance
Maintain opposition relevance Infiltrate via talent Ideological columns Partisan family ties
Press Corps

Press Corps masses in Mural Room hurling debt/pharma/home run queries, amplifying Nimbala's desperation and Borlaug miracle—accountability chorus frames moral urgency.

Representation Through on-site questioners
Power Dynamics Probes power without yielding
Impact Forces transparency on crises
Extract policy truths Define summit stakes Targeted interrogations Optics dissection
American Pharmaceutical Companies

American Pharmaceutical Companies spotlighted in Katie's photo op query as absent antagonists to Nimbala's pleas, underscoring pricing/access fault lines priming Bartlet's duty-driven pivot.

Representation Via pointed press absence
Power Dynamics Resisted by summit optics
Impact Exposes humanitarian vs. corporate clash
Protect patents/profits Avoid public villainy Pricing leverage Lobbying shadows
Senior White House Staff

White House Staff looms as unsettled stakeholder; Leo warns of fractures, Bartlet orders smoothing over, Charlie jokes on inclusion—hire threatens cohesion.

Representation Via Leo/Charlie reactions
Power Dynamics Subordinate to presidential whim
Impact Tests loyalty amid partisan import
Internal Dynamics Emerging ideological tensions
Preserve unity Adapt to bold directives Internal pushback Pragmatic counseling

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 2
Causal

"Ainsley's televised takedown of Sam directly leads to President Bartlet's fascination with her and his decision to hire her."

Backstage Warning — Ainsley Meets Sam
S2E4 · In This White House
Causal

"Ainsley's televised takedown of Sam directly leads to President Bartlet's fascination with her and his decision to hire her."

Ainsley Publicly Unravels Sam's Textbook Claim
S2E4 · In This White House
What this causes 4
Causal

"Bartlet's announcement to hire Ainsley Hayes triggers Leo to inform Sam and C.J., leading to their furious reaction."

Leo's Gamble: Offering Ainsley Sparks Outrage
S2E4 · In This White House
Thematic Parallel medium

"President Nimbala's plea for a 'miracle' to save his dying country from AIDS parallels the later negotiation where he must beg for his nation's survival under harsh terms."

Ultimatum in the Mural Room
S2E4 · In This White House
Thematic Parallel medium

"President Nimbala's plea for a 'miracle' to save his dying country from AIDS parallels the later negotiation where he must beg for his nation's survival under harsh terms."

Ultimatum: Aid Tied to Security Commitments
S2E4 · In This White House
Thematic Parallel medium

"President Nimbala's plea for a 'miracle' to save his dying country from AIDS parallels the later negotiation where he must beg for his nation's survival under harsh terms."

Nimbala's Shame Breaks the Negotiation
S2E4 · In This White House

Key Dialogue

"BARTLET: "Leo, AIDS is caused by HIV. You just named a group of people that have a higher mortality rate across the board.""
"BARTLET: "We should hire her.""
"LEO: "She's a Republican." BARTLET: "So are half the people in this country.""