S2E18
· 17 People

Toby Grills Leo on Hoynes' Veiled Primary Challenge

In a dimly lit Leo's office at night, Toby paces relentlessly, directly confronting Leo with evidence of Vice President Hoynes' suspicious itinerary: a Nashua, New Hampshire speech on 'Clean air industry in the high-tech Corridor' sandwiched in a Killington camping trip. Toby accuses Leo of knowing Hoynes anticipates Bartlet not running again. Leo removes his glasses, falters in dismissal, exuding visible discomfort. Tension peaks unanswered as Toby's rubber ball slams the wall, escalating Toby's probe into administration betrayal and foreshadowing the shattering MS revelation.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

6

Toby confronts Leo with a direct accusation about Vice President Hoynes challenging President Bartlet, setting the tense tone of the scene.

confrontation to denial

Toby probes Leo about Hoynes's itinerary, specifically mentioning a speech in Nashua, New Hampshire, hinting at political maneuvering.

suspicion to evasion ['Nashua, New Hampshire']

Leo reacts visibly by removing his glasses, a physical cue of discomfort, as Toby details Hoynes's suspicious activities.

evasion to discomfort

Leo attempts to dismiss Toby's concerns logically but falters, revealing his own unease about Hoynes's actions.

discomfort to unease

Toby presses further, linking Hoynes's 'camping trip' to Killington with his Nashua speech, exposing the thinly veiled political campaign.

unease to confrontation ['Killington']

The scene ends with Toby's unanswered question hanging in the air, the sound of his rubber ball against the wall underscoring the unresolved tension.

confrontation to suspense

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

3

Calculated confidence in his veiled maneuvers (inferred from itinerary)

Hoynes is not physically present but invoked through Toby's dissection of his itinerary, positioning him as the scheming VP whose Nashua speech and Killington trip signal anticipation of Bartlet's non-re-election.

Goals in this moment
  • Test waters for 2002 presidential run
  • Exploit perceived Bartlet vulnerability
Active beliefs
  • Bartlet will not seek re-election due to hidden issues
  • Subtle New Hampshire forays position him advantageously
Character traits
Ambitious Cunning Opportunistic
Follow John Hoynes's journey

Insistent frustration bordering on righteous anger, fueled by suspicion of betrayal

Toby paces relentlessly across the office, staring intently at Leo while methodically presenting evidence of Hoynes' suspicious Nashua speech amid a Killington camping trip, culminating in a direct accusation and rhythmic ball slams against the wall to heighten pressure.

Goals in this moment
  • Extract truth from Leo about Hoynes' motives
  • Expose potential administration cover-up of VP disloyalty
Active beliefs
  • Hoynes is covertly challenging Bartlet via masked campaigning
  • Leo knows and is withholding critical information
Character traits
Relentless Analytical Confrontational Intuitive
Follow Toby Ziegler's journey

referenced as sitting President whom Hoynes suspects will not run again

Character traits
protective resolute self-aware principled
Follow Josiah Bartlet's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

1
Leo's Glasses

Leo removes his glasses upon hearing 'Nashua, New Hampshire,' a telling gesture signaling faltering composure and raw vulnerability amid Toby's accusations; it functions as a narrative tell of discomfort, stripping his authoritative facade and underscoring the personal toll of guarded secrets.

Before: Worn on Leo's face while seated at his …
After: Removed and held aside or placed on desk …
Before: Worn on Leo's face while seated at his desk in the office
After: Removed and held aside or placed on desk as Leo sits back in chair

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

2
Nashua, New Hampshire

Nashua, New Hampshire is referenced as the site of Hoynes' semiconductor plant speech titled 'Clean air industry in the high-tech Corridor,' framed by Toby as suspiciously overt for a masked political maneuver, heightening paranoia over VP ambitions in this pivotal primary state.

Atmosphere Evoked as a hub of veiled intrigue and high-tech ambition
Function Invoked battleground for suspected early campaigning
Symbolism Nexus of betrayal, representing New Hampshire's kingmaker status in nominations
Humming assembly lines and conference halls (inferred) Polished industrial facade masking political intent
Killington

Killington is cited as the cover for Hoynes' three-day camping trip enveloping the Nashua speech, dissected by Toby as a 'benign excuse' for New Hampshire scouting, amplifying the interrogation's tension by exposing the itinerary's duplicitous structure.

Atmosphere Remote wilderness isolation evoking evasion and hidden agendas
Function Alibi location masking political reconnaissance
Symbolism Represents fabricated innocence cloaking presidential hunger
Pine-choked trails and jagged peaks Frost-hardened earth and howling winds

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 14
Causal medium

"Toby's initial confrontation with Leo about Hoynes' actions leads to his more direct accusation about Hoynes challenging Bartlet."

Toby Presses Leo on Rumors of Dropping Hoynes
S2E18 · 17 People
Causal medium

"Toby's initial confrontation with Leo about Hoynes' actions leads to his more direct accusation about Hoynes challenging Bartlet."

Toby's Obsessive Nights Propel Suspicion Toward Leo
S2E18 · 17 People
Causal medium

"Toby's initial confrontation with Leo about Hoynes' actions leads to his more direct accusation about Hoynes challenging Bartlet."

Toby's Obsessive Ball Ritual and Leo Confrontation
S2E18 · 17 People
Causal medium

"Toby's initial questioning about Hoynes' polling leads to his deeper investigation into Hoynes' itinerary and political maneuvering."

Toby Ambushes Leo Over Hoynes' Suspicious Polling
S2E18 · 17 People
Causal medium

"Toby's initial questioning about Hoynes' polling leads to his deeper investigation into Hoynes' itinerary and political maneuvering."

Toby's VO Questions Historic VP Challenge Precedent
S2E18 · 17 People
Character Continuity medium

"Leo's discomfort and deflection in both scenes indicate his unease about Toby's probing into Hoynes' actions."

Toby's Obsessive Ball Ritual and Leo Confrontation
S2E18 · 17 People
Character Continuity medium

"Leo's discomfort and deflection in both scenes indicate his unease about Toby's probing into Hoynes' actions."

Toby's Obsessive Nights Propel Suspicion Toward Leo
S2E18 · 17 People
Character Continuity medium

"Leo's discomfort and deflection in both scenes indicate his unease about Toby's probing into Hoynes' actions."

Toby Presses Leo on Rumors of Dropping Hoynes
S2E18 · 17 People
Character Continuity medium

"Leo's consistent deflection and discomfort when questioned about Hoynes' actions."

Toby Ambushes Leo Over Hoynes' Suspicious Polling
S2E18 · 17 People
Character Continuity medium

"Leo's consistent deflection and discomfort when questioned about Hoynes' actions."

Toby's VO Questions Historic VP Challenge Precedent
S2E18 · 17 People
Escalation

"Toby's challenge to Leo's explanation escalates to his direct linking of Hoynes' 'camping trip' to political campaigning."

Toby's VO Questions Historic VP Challenge Precedent
S2E18 · 17 People
Escalation

"Toby's challenge to Leo's explanation escalates to his direct linking of Hoynes' 'camping trip' to political campaigning."

Toby Ambushes Leo Over Hoynes' Suspicious Polling
S2E18 · 17 People
NARRATIVELY_FOLLOWS medium

"Toby's ambush of Leo in the dark office follows his earlier confrontation about Hoynes' polling activity."

Toby Ambushes Leo Over Hoynes' Suspicious Polling
S2E18 · 17 People
NARRATIVELY_FOLLOWS medium

"Toby's ambush of Leo in the dark office follows his earlier confrontation about Hoynes' polling activity."

Toby's VO Questions Historic VP Challenge Precedent
S2E18 · 17 People
What this causes 3
Emotional Echo medium

"The unresolved tension in both scenes is echoed by the sound of Toby's rubber ball hitting the wall."

Toby's Obsessive Nights Propel Suspicion Toward Leo
S2E18 · 17 People
Emotional Echo medium

"The unresolved tension in both scenes is echoed by the sound of Toby's rubber ball hitting the wall."

Toby Presses Leo on Rumors of Dropping Hoynes
S2E18 · 17 People
Emotional Echo medium

"The unresolved tension in both scenes is echoed by the sound of Toby's rubber ball hitting the wall."

Toby's Obsessive Ball Ritual and Leo Confrontation
S2E18 · 17 People

Key Dialogue

"TOBY: "He's giving a speech at a semiconductor plant. The title of the speech is, Clean air industry in the high-tech Corridor of the Industrial Northeast." LEO: "Where?" TOBY: "Nashua, New Hampshire.""
"LEO: "Toby, nobody, and particularly not Hoynes would be naOve enough... what I mean to say is if he's going to New Hampshire for the reason you're thinking he would mask it with something.""
"TOBY: "Because it comes in the middle of a three-day camping trip to Killington. [beat] Why does Hoynes think the President isn't going to run again? [beat, while the sound of Toby's ball, slamming into the wall, is heard] What's going on, Leo?""