Fabula
S1E4 · Five Votes Down

Hoynes Delivers the Vote — and a Quiet Lifeline

Leo arrives at Vice President Hoynes' office emotionally unmoored after the gun‑control bill falls five votes short. Hoynes immediately neutralizes the political crisis—promising to see Congressman Tillinghouse and deliver the final vote—while also piercing Leo's stoicism by offering a secret personal lifeline: an anonymous, powerful men's AA meeting hosted in the West Wing. The scene is a turning point: the legislative emergency is solved, but Leo's private life is exposed and his capacity to keep fighting is suddenly in doubt.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

3

Leo arrives at Hoynes' office, visibly distressed, and begins discussing the lost votes on bill 802.

neutral to tension ["Vice President's Office"]

Hoynes offers immediate political relief by promising to secure Tillinghouse's vote.

vulnerability to cautious relief

The scene ends with Leo leaving, his political crisis resolved but personal pain lingering.

revelation to bittersweet resolution

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

3

Confident and steady; pragmatic about the legislative fix while quietly frank in exposing a personal option for Leo's support.

Hoynes receives Leo warmly, absorbs the briefing, immediately commits to seeing Tillinghouse the next morning, reassures Leo, and then offers an unexpected personal resource: the existence of his confidential weekly AA meeting among senior officials.

Goals in this moment
  • Deliver the swing vote by personally meeting Tillinghouse
  • Stabilize Leo emotionally and offer a private support mechanism that preserves both help and secrecy
Active beliefs
  • Private, trust-based networks among senior officials can resolve political and personal crises
  • Maintaining confidentiality about sensitive personal matters is crucial to protecting reputations and power
Character traits
calm politically resourceful compassionate discreet
Follow John Hoynes's journey

Professional and quietly sympathetic; present as a stabilizing, background figure.

Janeane acts as the practical intermediary: she announces Leo, waits for direction, fetches and delivers a glass of ice water to Leo on Hoynes' instruction, then remains polite and unobtrusive at the doorway.

Goals in this moment
  • Support the Vice President's office operations unobtrusively
  • Provide small comforts (the glass of water) that aid the emotional exchange
Active beliefs
  • Staff should facilitate senior-official interactions without drawing attention
  • Practical gestures (like bringing water) contribute to de-escalation
Character traits
efficient discreet attentive
Follow Janeane (Laurie's …'s journey

Frayed and unmoored on the surface — professional composure cracking into private grief and fatigue beneath.

Leo arrives shaken, confesses the bill is five votes short, briefly discloses his separation from Jenny, accepts water to steady himself, expresses gratitude when Hoynes promises to deliver the final vote, then leaves.

Goals in this moment
  • Secure the missing vote for bill 802 by enlisting Hoynes' help
  • Contain the political damage and keep the President's legislative priority on track
Active beliefs
  • The administration must secure this vote or political capital will be lost
  • Personal problems should be kept private and not interfere with duty
Character traits
dutiful vulnerable self-effacing procedurally focused
Follow Leo Thomas …'s journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

2
Folded broadsheet newspaper (Roosevelt Room table; handled by President Bartlet)

Hoynes is introduced reading a broadsheet newspaper at the start of the scene; it establishes a late‑night political routine and gives the office a lived, worklate texture, anchoring the ordinary against which Leo’s personal crisis intrudes.

Before: In Hoynes' hands in his office; being read …
After: Left aside once the conversation begins; remains a …
Before: In Hoynes' hands in his office; being read and used as a prop to convey late‑night work.
After: Left aside once the conversation begins; remains a background prop underscoring the office's workwise atmosphere.
Glass of Ice Water (Hoynes Office — Comfort for Leo)

Janeane brings a clear tumbler of ice water to Leo at Hoynes' request; Leo drinks deeply from it to steady himself. The glass functions narratively as a small, humanizing comfort and a ritualized means for Leo to regain composure between confession and task focus.

Before: In Hoynes' office supply area; waiting to be …
After: Returned to the desk or left in the …
Before: In Hoynes' office supply area; waiting to be fetched by Janeane.
After: Returned to the desk or left in the office after Leo drinks; remains a quiet trace of the comfort exchange.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 6
Causal

"Richardson's refusal to support the bill forces Leo to seek help from Vice President Hoynes to secure the final vote."

The Cost of Compromise at the Lincoln Memorial
S1E4 · Five Votes Down
Character Continuity

"Leo's declaration that the gun-control bill is more important than his marriage directly leads to his admission to Hoynes about his marital collapse."

Ultimatum at the Door: Job vs. Marriage
S1E4 · Five Votes Down
Character Continuity

"Leo's declaration that the gun-control bill is more important than his marriage directly leads to his admission to Hoynes about his marital collapse."

The Most Important Thing — Leo Chooses the Job
S1E4 · Five Votes Down
Character Continuity

"Hoynes' concern for Leo's distress leads to his offer of support through the secret AA meeting, showing the personal bonds beneath the political surface."

Leo's Breakdown, Hoynes' Quiet Salvage
S1E4 · Five Votes Down
Thematic Parallel medium

"Jenny wearing the choker as she leaves parallels Hoynes offering Leo support in AA, both highlighting the personal costs of political life."

Ultimatum at the Door: Job vs. Marriage
S1E4 · Five Votes Down
Thematic Parallel medium

"Jenny wearing the choker as she leaves parallels Hoynes offering Leo support in AA, both highlighting the personal costs of political life."

The Most Important Thing — Leo Chooses the Job
S1E4 · Five Votes Down
What this causes 1
Character Continuity

"Hoynes' concern for Leo's distress leads to his offer of support through the secret AA meeting, showing the personal bonds beneath the political surface."

Leo's Breakdown, Hoynes' Quiet Salvage
S1E4 · Five Votes Down

Key Dialogue

"LEO: "Um... I came in to talk to you about 802. We lost five votes.""
"HOYNES: "I'll see Tillinghouse." LEO: "You'll deliver him?" HOYNES: "It's a done deal.""
"HOYNES: "When was the last time you went to a meeting?" LEO: "A.A.? What meeting could I possibly go to?" HOYNES: "Mine.""