Fabula
S3E21 · Posse Comitatus

Bartlet's Visceral Rejection of the Recorder Pen

In a tense culmination of the Situation Room briefing, an aide hands President Bartlet a pen concealing a recording device to plant on Shareef as a 'gift.' Bartlet quips darkly about poison before staring at it in mounting discomfort, dropping it on the table in a physical manifestation of his moral revulsion toward the assassination plot. He abruptly exits after instructing it be boxed, crystallizing his internal torment and foreshadowing the operation's callback evidence while underscoring the personal cost of his impending authorization.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

1

Bartlet is handed a pen with a hidden recorder, symbolizing the covert nature of the operation, which he drops in discomfort before exiting.

curiosity to revulsion ['Situation Room']

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

8

Stoically neutral, focused on task execution

Responds instantly to Man 3rd's nod, approaches Bartlet while unzipping jacket pocket, extracts and hands over the recorder pen directly, standing as silent executor of the covert handoff amid rising room tension.

Goals in this moment
  • Facilitate seamless transfer of operational hardware
  • Minimize visibility of covert tool deployment
Active beliefs
  • Anonymity amplifies effectiveness in sensitive ops
  • Precision in small actions safeguards larger missions
Character traits
dutifully efficient discreetly mechanical protocol-bound
Follow Situation Room …'s journey

Matter-of-fact composure underscoring tactical patience

Stands attentively with assembled brass as Bartlet rises, positioned near the computer display, silently observing the pen handoff, president's quip, drop, and exit without verbal contribution.

Goals in this moment
  • Monitor presidential reaction to finalize op readiness
  • Uphold briefing cohesion through presence
Active beliefs
  • Moral hesitations resolve under operational momentum
  • Secrecy demands unflinching continuity
Character traits
operationally steely observantly poised militarily disciplined
Follow Percy Fitzwallace's journey

Bitter humor veiling profound moral revulsion and internal torment

Rises first amid rising tension, receives the disguised recorder pen from the aide, delivers dark quip about poison, stares at it in visible discomfort, glances at Leo for shared understanding, drops it forcefully on the table, and exits abruptly after dictating it be boxed, embodying presidential torment.

Goals in this moment
  • Humanize the target through imagined voice to heighten ethical stakes
  • Reassert minimal control over the dehumanizing mechanics of the op
Active beliefs
  • Covert tools like bugged gifts erode moral boundaries
  • Assassination demands personal reckoning beyond legalities
Character traits
wryly sardonic morally conflicted decisively commanding
Follow Abigail Bartlet's journey

Concerned empathy shadowed by pragmatic resolve

Rises with the room as Bartlet stands, locks eyes in a fraught glance from the president just before the pen drops, bearing silent witness to the moral tipping point without intervening.

Goals in this moment
  • Gauge Bartlet's resolve threshold for impending authorization
  • Provide unspoken solidarity amid ethical strain
Active beliefs
  • Personal revulsion must yield to command imperatives
  • Shared glances convey deeper strategic alignments
Character traits
steadfastly loyal gravely observant restrainedly supportive
Follow Leo McGarry's journey
Man 3rd
primary

Professionally detached amid ethical undercurrents

Prompts the gift exchange upon Bartlet's rise, nods to aide to deliver the recorder pen, explains its function calmly amid president's recoil, calls 'Sir?' as he departs, pressing operational details through protocol.

Goals in this moment
  • Secure presidential buy-in for intel-gathering adjunct to kill op
  • Ensure gift protocol integrates seamlessly into assassination timeline
Active beliefs
  • Small risks like recorders yield outsized intel payoffs
  • Presidential discomfort is collateral to national security imperatives
Character traits
procedurally insistent tactically pragmatic unfazed by tension
Follow Man 3rd's journey

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

1
Joint Chiefs of Staff

Joint Chiefs rise in unison with the room as Bartlet stands, flanking the briefing principals silently during the pen handoff and president's visceral rejection, their uniformed presence reinforcing the military calculus behind the civilian-disguised op.

Representation Through assembled generals and admirals standing in disciplined attention
Power Dynamics Subordinate to presidential authority yet underpinning operational expertise
Impact Highlights military's pivot to covert shadows, straining Posse Comitatus boundaries
Validate feasibility of non-military kill mechanics Witness and contextualize president's ethical processing Institutional presence exerting disciplined gravity Collective expertise implied in silent endorsement

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What this causes 4
Callback

"The pen recorder Bartlet drops in discomfort is later retrieved as evidence after Shareef's assassination."

Shareef Assassinated: Silent Confirmation Seals Bartlet's Fate
S3E21 · Posse Comitatus
Callback

"The pen recorder Bartlet drops in discomfort is later retrieved as evidence after Shareef's assassination."

Pen Recorder Retrieved: Assassination Confirmed
S3E21 · Posse Comitatus
Callback

"The pen recorder Bartlet drops in discomfort is later retrieved as evidence after Shareef's assassination."

Shareef's Assassination Confirmed; Bartlet's Isolated Revelation
S3E21 · Posse Comitatus
Character Continuity

"Bartlet's initial discomfort with Fitzwallace's assassination plan contrasts with his eventual decision to authorize it, showcasing his moral conflict."

Bartlet's Moral Capitulation: Authorizes Shareef Assassination
S3E21 · Posse Comitatus

Key Dialogue

"BARTLET: "What does the pen do? Squirts poison?""
"MAN 3RD: "It's got a small recording device in there. He'll probably throw it in the trash, but you never know. You might get lucky. He sticks it in his pocket on the flight home.""
"BARTLET: "We give him it boxed. Tell them to put it in a box.""