Donna's Vote‑Swap Gambit
Plot Beats
The narrative micro-steps within this event
Donna announces her plan to offset her invalid ballot by recruiting a Ritchie supporter to vote for Bartlet.
Who Was There
Characters present in this moment
Neutral, task-focused — intent on maintaining clear lines of communication.
Bonnie interjects to tell Sam that Will Bailey is on the phone, acting as the logistical communications link that keeps field updates flowing into the West Wing hub.
- • Ensure Sam receives the call from Will Bailey
- • Keep communications avenues open and responsive
- • Facilitate rapid information flow between field and White House
- • Timely information saves decisions from being made in a vacuum
- • Logistics are critical in crisis moments
- • Small administrative acts enable strategic action
Defensive optimism — trying to sell Orlando as redeemable and worthy of a break.
Anthony pleads Orlando's case, supplies colorful background (Buckeyes, goat anecdote), asks Charlie to intervene and 'write a note', and negotiates leniency using loyalty and future promise as leverage.
- • Obtain Charlie's informal intervention to avoid formal sanction for Orlando
- • Protect Orlando's football prospects
- • De-escalate the security situation
- • Personal connections and notes can bend rules
- • Charismatic advocacy can avert institutional punishments
- • Orlando's talent justifies exceptions
Irritated amusement — annoyed by the interruption but quick to recover with a joke and focus on operational matters.
Josh, eyes on his briefing memo, walks into Orlando, is helped up, tries to make small talk about football, then pushes toward the Senior Staff meeting — confronting Debbie about punctuality rules — before witnessing Donna's sudden exit to fix her absentee mistake.
- • Get into the Senior Staff meeting with his briefing memo
- • Keep operations moving despite interruptions
- • Support colleagues (light banter with Andy/Toby)
- • Information (the briefing memo) is essential to doing his job
- • Meetings should be efficient but flexible
- • Small actions (like helping someone up) are still worth polite attention
Apprehensive but wry — nervous about the sonogram yet buoyed by private joy and humor.
Andy interjects that Toby can't talk because they're late for the sonogram, exchanges light banter about medical procedures and timing, and exits to the appointment, marking the personal stakes threading the night's political chaos.
- • Get to the sonogram on time
- • Support Toby through the appointment
- • Keep personal matters from derailing the campaign staff's flow
- • Personal life must still be attended to even on big nights
- • Small jokes ease tension
- • Medical appointments require punctuality
Concise concern — focused on triage rather than panic, weighing media choices for a tight race.
Sam exits the Oval, exchanges a quick line with Josh about meeting timing, takes a call from Will Bailey relaying California 47th tracking and exit-poll ambiguity, and moves into the Communications Office to triage the race and satellite request.
- • Assess and protect the California 47th situation
- • Decide whether to allocate presidential satellite time
- • Coordinate communications strategy with the field
- • Exit polls and late tracking are volatile and must be treated cautiously
- • Media exposure (satellite time) can help but carries risk
- • Campaign resources are limited and must be prioritized
Nervous optimism — tenderly anxious about the pregnancy while keeping dark humor to manage fear.
Toby participates in the sonogram banter, contemplates tipping the nurse for a smooth second trimester, and briefly disengages from campaign talk to focus on Andy and the appointment before walking off.
- • Make Andy comfortable for the sonogram
- • Ensure the medical visit goes smoothly
- • Momentarily put aside campaign worries
- • Personal stakes deserve small gestures (a tip) to smooth outcomes
- • Humor masks deeper anxiety
- • Timing for personal appointments must be prioritized
Exasperated professionalism — irritated by the breach but determined to contain embarrassment and do the right administrative thing.
Charlie arrives, identifies the detained visitors, vouches for one, pulls Anthony aside to interrogate meaning and priors, asserts White House decorum, and decides to keep Orlando occupied and registered for Election Day.
- • Prevent embarrassment and security incident in the White House
- • Secure Orlando's cooperation and keep him from causing further trouble
- • Ensure visitors comply with registration and White House rules for the day
- • The White House must be protected from petty chaos and spectacle
- • Personal favors (notes, exceptions) undermine institutional integrity
- • Young people can be redirected through firm oversight
Determined embarrassment — mortified by her mistake but resolved to perform quick, improvised repair work.
Donna announces she'll leave for about twenty minutes to go three blocks to a polling place and find a Ritchie supporter willing to swap votes to offset her absentee ballot mistake; she immediately walks off to fix her error in practical, slightly panicked fashion.
- • Correct/offset her mistaken absentee vote by finding a swap
- • Avoid public humiliation and patch the error quickly
- • Return before the meeting resumes
- • Practical improvisation can fix small mistakes
- • Personal mistakes should be privately corrected, not ignored
- • Quick action reduces long-term embarrassment
Awkward contrition — embarrassed but sincere and willing to comply with authority.
Orlando stands large and earnest, insists he wasn't driving drunk, accepts that an open Pabst caused trouble, helps Josh up after Josh trips into him, and agrees to spend Election Day with Charlie instead of practice.
- • Avoid formal punishment or expulsion from team opportunities
- • Comply with Charlie to stay out of further trouble
- • Keep his football prospects intact
- • Cooperating will prevent worse consequences
- • Respecting an authority figure will smooth outcomes
- • He can be disciplined but still succeed athletically
Professional detachment — committed to protocol and not easily swayed by charisma.
Michelle stands with security holding Anthony and Orlando, asks Charlie to identify which man he vouches for, and enforces procedural checks and custody while signaling that this is a rules-based interaction.
- • Verify identities and clearances of the visitors
- • Maintain building security and follow protocol
- • Prevent unauthorized entry or escalation
- • Security rules exist for good reason and must be followed
- • No exceptions should be made without proper authorization
- • Public safety trumps personal pleas
Objects Involved
Significant items in this scene
An open can of Pabst Blue Ribbon functions as the concrete cause for Orlando's detention; it's the evidentiary trigger that converts youthful misbehavior into a security problem. Anthony cites it as the reason Coach might bench Orlando and as the story's comic kernel.
Donna's ballot photocopy is the latent cause of her panic and decision to sprint to a nearby polling place to 'swap' votes. While the copy itself isn't produced in this moment in the lobby, it motivates her abrupt exit and reframes private error as immediate action.
Location Details
Places and their significance in this event
The West Wing hallway is the transitional corridor that carries characters from containment to governance — Charlie escorts Orlando down it, Josh uses it to approach the Outer Oval, and staff conversations spill into it, linking the lobby disruption to internal meetings.
The Communications Office is where Sam takes Will Bailey's call about California's 47th, converting lobby disturbances into campaign triage. It functions as the nerve center that receives field data and shapes media response, even as the lobby's human dramas continue elsewhere.
The Northwest Lobby is the physical stage where security protocols meet raw human stories: detained visitors, armed guards, and hurried staff intersect. It concentrates the West Wing's public-facing friction — a place where personal misbehavior becomes an institutional problem that requires containment.
Organizations Involved
Institutional presence and influence
The U.S. Secret Service is invoked as the higher-level protective presence whose standards and preparedness define the lobby's stakes—Charlie references the 'guns' and the need to wait for Secret Service clearance, folding national security atmosphere into a local brawl.
White House Security is operationally active: its officer Michelle holds the visitors, enforces identification and custody, and triggers the procedural response that compels Charlie to intervene. The organization enacts institutional safeguards against disruption and embarrassment on Election Night.
Senior Staff functions as the procedural authority behind Debbie's enforcement—its meeting rules shape access and timing. The organization's norms (captured in email/memo) directly influence who is allowed into sensitive discussions during a crucial night.
Horton Wilde's Campaign is present indirectly through Will Bailey's call into the Communications Office; its precarious status in California's 47th provides a backdrop of real electoral stakes that contrasts the lobby's smaller dramas.
Narrative Connections
How this event relates to others in the story
No narrative connections mapped yet
This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph
Key Dialogue
"DONNA: I'm going to find a Ritchie supporter who'll vote for the President to offset my absentee ballot."
"JOSH: I'm sorry?"
"DEBBIE: The meeting starts on time and if you're not there when it starts, you don't go in."