Erickson's Succession Smugness Ignites Leo's Fierce MS Defense

Congressman Erickson feigns bipartisanship by complimenting Chairman Bruno, then smugly quizzes Leo on constitutional succession protocols amid Bartlet's MS crisis. Leo whispers aside with Jordan, mocking Erickson's snotty tone while dodging her demand for full disclosure on his secrets. Correcting Erickson's VP duties misinterpretation, Leo erupts when Erickson implies MS heightens mortality risk, passionately defending Bartlet's choice of Hoynes on merit alone, decrying the slur on MS patients, and demanding an apology. This partisan clash exposes loyalties, escalates hearing tensions, and parallels VP Hoynes' own health revelation anxieties.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

2

Congressman Erickson compliments Chairman Bruno and smugly questions Leo about Constitutional succession, setting a confrontational tone.

neutral to tension

Erickson challenges succession procedures, implying Bartlet's MS increases mortality risk, provoking Leo's fiery defense of Bartlet and Hoynes.

seriousness to outrage

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

5

Visibly annoyed restraint amid partisan posturing

Cliff Calley, seated among committee members, sighs deeply and visibly tries to suppress annoyance during Erickson's smug questioning and Leo's aside with Jordan.

Goals in this moment
  • Maintain composure as counsel despite escalating tensions
  • Observe testimony without intervening prematurely
Active beliefs
  • Erickson's tactics undermine the hearing's integrity
  • Leo's responses could reveal key truths if pressed
Character traits
methodical frustrated professional
Follow Cliff Calley's journey

Annoyed frustration laced with professional urgency and underlying concern

Jordan leans in closely to Leo, turns her microphone away for private whisper, demands full disclosure of his secrets in exchange for her high fee, rejects his dinner flirtation with annoyance, then watches as he returns to testify.

Goals in this moment
  • Extract complete truth from Leo to prepare his testimony effectively
  • Reject flirtation to enforce boundaries amid high stakes
Active beliefs
  • Full disclosure is essential for her role as effective counsel
  • Leo's evasiveness risks their defense in the hearing
Character traits
assertive professional no-nonsense loyal
Follow Jordan Kendall's journey
Shanahan
primary

Annoyed by partisan snark masking righteous indignation and fierce protectiveness

Leo stares blankly at Erickson, whispers mockingly about his snotty tone while flirtatiously dodging Jordan's demand for full disclosure, then publicly corrects constitutional misinterpretation, erupts in passionate defense of MS patients and Bartlet's VP choice, demanding an apology with emphatic resolve at the witness table.

Goals in this moment
  • Deflect personal secrets from Jordan while maintaining composure
  • Shut down Erickson's attack on Bartlet and MS patients
  • Uphold constitutional accuracy and administration integrity
Active beliefs
  • MS is not fatal and implying otherwise is a criminal slur
  • Hoynes was chosen purely on merit to serve as President if needed
  • Loyalty to Bartlet demands unyielding defense against political exploitation
Character traits
strategic defiant loyal witty passionate
Follow Shanahan's journey

Smug confidence veiling aggressive probing intent

Erickson compliments Chairman Bruno with clasped hands and smug tone, quizzes Leo on constitutional succession, questions VP selection process, implies Bartlet's MS increases mortality risk, and begins to respond to Leo's demand before being cut off.

Goals in this moment
  • Pressure Leo on succession to expose administration flaws
  • Imply Bartlet's health disqualifies him to score political points
Active beliefs
  • Bartlet's MS heightens succession risks warranting scrutiny
  • VP selection was influenced by undisclosed health issues
Character traits
smug calculating partisan bipartisan facade
Follow Congressman Erickson's journey
Character traits
stoic assertive resolute loyal compassionate
Follow Leo McGarry's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

1
Microphone

The microphone enables discreet whispering between Leo and Jordan by being covered and turned away, allowing private banter and evasion amid public testimony, heightening tension as it contrasts amplified public responses with hushed intimacy, underscoring Leo's tactical multitasking under scrutiny.

Before: Positioned actively at witness table, facing committee
After: Uncovered and leaned into by Leo for public …
Before: Positioned actively at witness table, facing committee
After: Uncovered and leaned into by Leo for public testimony

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Capitol Hill

The Capitol Hill Hearing Room hosts the partisan showdown as Erickson's smug probe draws Leo's whispered aside and explosive rebuttal, its formal setup amplifying every word and gesture, transforming routine questioning into a battleground for loyalties and truths amid buzzing tension.

Atmosphere Charged with smug partisanship, whispered intimacy, and erupting defiance
Function Public stage for congressional interrogation and defense
Symbolism Embodies institutional power clashing with personal conviction
Access Restricted to committee members, witnesses, counsel, and select observers
Daylight through tall windows Rows of seated committee members Gavel-ready authoritative podium

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

1
Judiciary Committee

The Judiciary Committee oversees the hearing through Chairman Bruno recognizing Erickson, whose smug constitutional quizzing provokes Leo's defense, manifesting as a collective probe into executive health disclosures and succession, escalating political stakes in the room.

Representation Via Chairman Bruno's recognition and members like Erickson and counsel Cliff Calley
Power Dynamics Exercising investigative authority over White House witness Leo
Impact Highlights congressional leverage over executive secrecy in health crises
Internal Dynamics Subtle tensions between smug partisans like Erickson and restrained counsel like Cliff
Uncover details on Bartlet's MS handling and VP selection Apply political pressure through constitutional scrutiny Rigorous questioning by members Formal protocol of recognition and testimony

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What this causes 2
Thematic Parallel medium

"Erickson's challenge about succession parallels Hoynes' reaction to Bartlet's MS revelation, both questioning the implications of Bartlet's health."

Bartlet’s Rallying Roll Call to Senior Staff
S3E9 · Bartlet for America (Restructured)
Thematic Parallel medium

"Erickson's challenge about succession parallels Hoynes' reaction to Bartlet's MS revelation, both questioning the implications of Bartlet's health."

Bartlet Reveals MS Secret to Hoynes, Demands Instant VP Loyalty—Furious Rejection
S3E9 · Bartlet for America (Restructured)

Key Dialogue

"ERICKSON: "Well, with the possibility that the President might die in office..." LEO: "Hold it." ERICKSON: "...a greater possibility with this President...""
"LEO: "([emphatically]) No, sir. That isn't true. MS isn't fatal. And while on national television, it is criminal to imply otherwise in an effort to score some cheap points. [pause] You owe an apology to fathers of children who are suffering from this disease.""
"LEO: "Finally, the President chose his running mate using the only yardstick that means anything: ability to assume the duties of the Presidency. And with John Hoynes, we got our man. And the Vice President was immediately told of the President's condition.""