Fabula
S2E2 · In the Shadow of Two Gunmen Part 2

Poolside Pitch: Toby Recruits Skeptical C.J.

Fresh from her comedic pool plunge, C.J.—still dripping and vulnerable post-firing—faces Toby's earnest recruitment pitch for Bartlet's campaign as Press Secretary. Toby touts Bartlet's admiration for her Emily's List work, sent by Leo McGarry, despite her statewide-only experience and drastic pay cut from $550K/year to $600/week. C.J. probes her qualifications and Bartlet's character; Toby's affirmations ease her doubts enough to invite him inside for further talk, forging a pivotal setup for her principled career pivot amid personal upheaval.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

4

Toby reveals his purpose: recruiting C.J. for the Bartlet campaign, shifting the conversation to a serious and pivotal proposition.

embarrassment to intrigue

C.J. questions her qualifications and the drastic pay cut, revealing her doubts and the stakes of the offer.

intrigue to hesitation

Toby reassures C.J. of her capabilities and Bartlet's integrity, leading her to consider the offer seriously.

hesitation to contemplation

C.J. agrees to discuss the offer further, signaling her openness to a life-changing decision.

contemplation to resolve

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

4

Initial annoyance and vulnerability shifting to startled intrigue and cautious optimism

Dripping wet from pool plunge, C.J. explains her firing due to Roger Becker's status drop, probes Toby on Bartlet's impression of her Emily's List work, questions pay cut, inexperience, and Bartlet's character, then decisively invites him inside to discuss further while wringing her hair.

Goals in this moment
  • Assess legitimacy and viability of the Press Secretary offer
  • Probe Bartlet's character and her qualifications to protect her integrity
Active beliefs
  • Hollywood power games are petty and destructive
  • True opportunity aligns with principled leaders like a 'good man'
Character traits
vulnerable skeptical direct principled decisive
Follow C.J. Cregg's journey

Amused confidence masking urgent determination to recruit top talent

Seated poolside, Toby banters lightly about her firing, pitches her recruitment as Press Secretary citing Bartlet's Emily's List admiration and Leo's instructions, chuckles at mishap but turns away respectfully, reassures on pay, experience, and Bartlet's goodness to secure her interest.

Goals in this moment
  • Convince C.J. to join Bartlet campaign despite her doubts
  • Leverage her credentials to build campaign's press operation
Active beliefs
  • C.J.'s skills transcend Hollywood to national politics
  • Bartlet campaign offers meaningful purpose over financial gain
Character traits
earnest amused persistent reassuring wry
Follow Toby Ziegler's journey

mentioned as having instructed Toby to recruit C.J. for the campaign

Character traits
partisan reserved creative sardonic dismissive decisive pragmatic resolute optimistic engaged informed impatient bewildered controversial disputed authoritative professional incisive loyal blunt attentive protective inquisitive skeptical historical
Follow Leo Thomas …'s journey

mentioned as C.J.'s former Hollywood client whose drop from third to ninth most powerful person led to her firing

Character traits
volatile status-obsessed aggressive vindictive
Follow Roger Becker's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

1
C.J.'s Backyard Pool

The Mexican-tiled pool, site of C.J.'s immediate prior plunge, lingers as a symbol of her raw vulnerability—clothes clinging wetly as she climbs out and engages Toby. It heightens comedic tension and underscores her disheveled state during the high-stakes recruitment pitch, contrasting domestic oasis with career pivot.

Before: Calm, sunlit pool with Toby seated opposite
After: Unchanged, water rippling from C.J.'s exit; scene shifts …
Before: Calm, sunlit pool with Toby seated opposite
After: Unchanged, water rippling from C.J.'s exit; scene shifts toward house

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
C.J.'s Backyard

C.J.'s sunlit backyard serves as intimate stage for Toby's ambush recruitment, poolside slick concrete amplifying post-plunge awkwardness and banter. From vulnerable emergence to invitation inside, it cradles barbed negotiation—salary slashes, integrity probes—transforming private haven into launchpad for her Bartlet allegiance.

Atmosphere Awkwardly comedic with underlying tension, sun-drenched intimacy laced with career seismic shifts
Function Site of unexpected recruitment confrontation and tentative commitment
Symbolism Embodies transition from Hollywood isolation to team camaraderie
Access Private residential space, intruded only by Toby's bold arrival
Mexican tile pool edges Slick wet concrete Stairs to house Towel inside house door

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What this causes 4
Thematic Parallel medium

"C.J.'s recruitment by Toby, emphasizing Bartlet's integrity, mirrors her reclaiming her public voice in the crisis, both highlighting her resilience and commitment."

Toby's Tormented Demand for Memo Accountability
S2E2 · In the Shadow of Two …
Thematic Parallel medium

"C.J.'s recruitment by Toby, emphasizing Bartlet's integrity, mirrors her reclaiming her public voice in the crisis, both highlighting her resilience and commitment."

Leo Enlists Danny for Hospital Ride
S2E2 · In the Shadow of Two …
Thematic Parallel medium

"C.J.'s recruitment by Toby, emphasizing Bartlet's integrity, mirrors her reclaiming her public voice in the crisis, both highlighting her resilience and commitment."

Bartlet's Vigil: Trauma Forged into 'What's Next?' Resolve
S2E2 · In the Shadow of Two …
Thematic Parallel medium

"C.J.'s recruitment by Toby, emphasizing Bartlet's integrity, mirrors her reclaiming her public voice in the crisis, both highlighting her resilience and commitment."

C.J. Reclaims Her Voice
S2E2 · In the Shadow of Two …

Part of Larger Arcs

Key Dialogue

"C.J.: How much does it pay? TOBY: How much were you making before? C.J.: $550,000 a year. TOBY: This pays $600 a week."
"C.J.: Does he know I've only ever worked statewide? Does he know I've never worked on a national campaign before? TOBY: Yes. It's Graduation Day."
"C.J.: Is Jed Bartlet a good man? TOBY: Yeah. C.J.: Then, let's go into the house so I can change my clothes and we can talk about it."