Fabula
S2E8 · Shibboleth
S2E8
· Shibboleth

C.J. Desperately Negotiates to Save Troy the Turkey

Entering her office post-Toby flirtation, C.J. catches farmhand Morton attempting to reclaim Troy, the unpardoned turkey, for Jasper Farms. Revealing her unexpected attachment to the 'less photogenic' bird, she insists both go to a Delaware petting zoo, offers to buy Troy (aghast at the $275 price), and proposes substitutions. When Morton stands firm on protocol and prior sales, C.J. escalates by marching him off to higher authority, blending comic resourcefulness with White House absurdity to provide levity amid refugee crisis tensions and foreshadowing Bartlet's turkey ceremony.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

3

C.J. encounters Morton, who insists on taking one of the turkeys back, leading to a heated debate about the turkeys' fate.

confusion to determination ["C.J.'s office"]

C.J. attempts to negotiate with Morton to keep both turkeys, revealing her protective stance over the less photogenic bird, Troy.

determination to frustration ["C.J.'s office"]

C.J. decides to take the matter to a higher authority, leading Morton away to resolve the turkey dispute.

frustration to resolve ["C.J.'s office"]

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

7
C.J. Cregg
primary

Exasperated determination laced with impulsive tenderness for the underdog bird

Bursts into office post-flirtation, halts Morton's turkey grab, pitches petting zoo for both birds, grabs wallet to offer cash despite sticker shock at $275, defends Troy's quirks, and marches Morton toward higher authority with determined resolve.

Goals in this moment
  • Secure petting zoo sanctuary for both turkeys
  • Override Jasper Farms protocol via purchase or escalation
Active beliefs
  • Protocol shouldn't doom touchy turkeys to slaughter
  • White House clout can improvise merciful outcomes
Character traits
resourceful impulsive compassionate defiant
Follow C.J. Cregg's journey

Teasing hopefulness edged with vulnerability at her feigned reluctance

Intercepts C.J. in hallway with teasing 'Toscanini' moniker and song lyric probe, extends dinner invite with Josh and Sam, accepts her playful acceptance before she pivots to office crisis.

Goals in this moment
  • Secure C.J.'s dinner commitment
  • Lighten her pre-briefing tension with banter
Active beliefs
  • Shared staff camaraderie trumps work frenzy
  • Humor disarms even the busiest Press Secretary
Character traits
flirtatious wry persistent
Follow Toby Ziegler's journey
Carol
primary

Calmly focused amid brewing chaos

Encounters C.J. in hallway, receives crisp order to relocate press corps to Rose Garden in five minutes, nods affirmatively and parts ways to execute.

Goals in this moment
  • Promptly herd press to Rose Garden
  • Support C.J.'s briefing logistics seamlessly
Active beliefs
  • Press Secretary's directives demand instant compliance
  • Routine efficiency anchors White House press operations
Character traits
efficient loyal unflappable
Follow Carol's journey

Resigned firmness under bureaucratic pressure

Attempts to reclaim Troy from desk in C.J.'s office, firmly cites $275 price, prior sales, and farm protocol despite her buyout and zoo pitches, sighs resignedly, grabs the flapping bird, and trails her out.

Goals in this moment
  • Reclaim and return sold turkey per farm orders
  • Uphold Jasper Farms' commercial commitments
Active beliefs
  • Farm economics trump White House whims
  • Protocol protects rural livelihoods
Character traits
stoic dutiful unyielding
Follow Morton Horn's journey
Donna Moss
primary

informative

introduces Morton to C.J. and explains situation with turkeys, attempts to interject during negotiation

Goals in this moment
  • inform C.J. about Morton's purpose
Character traits
diligent observant resilient exasperated
Follow Donna Moss's journey
Eric
primary

Implied serene reprieve

Referenced by C.J. as the unflappable pardoned turkey chosen over Troy's touchiness, absent but pivotal in justifying her dual-rescue push.

Goals in this moment
  • Maintain composure for pardon
  • Secure ceremonial survival
Active beliefs
  • Stillness wins White House favor
  • Photogenic calm spares the axe
Character traits
docile poised
Follow Eric's journey
Troy
primary

Agitated panic from handling threats

Flaps wings defiantly behind C.J. on her office desk as focal point of dispute, ultimately snatched by Morton amid failed negotiations, symbolizing chaotic barnyard intrusion.

Goals in this moment
  • Evade capture and removal
  • Resist human interference
Active beliefs
  • Flight equals survival
  • Desk is temporary perch
Character traits
feisty uncooperative instinct-driven
Follow Troy's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

3
C.J.'s Wallet

C.J. snatches her leather wallet from her side pocket in frantic bid to buy Troy outright, thrusting it forward with desperate $275 offer that underscores her impulsive resolve and clashes with Morton's protocol, heightening comedic haggling tension.

Before: Pocketed on C.J.'s person, intact
After: Returned to pocket, unused amid failed negotiation
Before: Pocketed on C.J.'s person, intact
After: Returned to pocket, unused amid failed negotiation
Eric (Pardoned Presidential Turkey)

Invoked by C.J. as the victorious pardoned turkey whose docility edged out Troy, its offstage status fuels her argument against executing the runner-up, weaving ceremonial protocol into the negotiation's ironic mercy plea.

Before: Pardoned and secured elsewhere in White House
After: Unchanged, but symbolically contrasted with Troy's peril
Before: Pardoned and secured elsewhere in White House
After: Unchanged, but symbolically contrasted with Troy's peril
C.J. Cregg's Press Office Desk

Serves as absurd perch for flapping Troy behind C.J., central to the standoff as Morton strides to snatch the bird mid-negotiation, transforming briefing-cluttered workspace into poultry battleground amplifying White House farce.

Before: Cluttered office surface holding disputed turkey
After: Cleared of Troy post-grab, tension lingering
Before: Cluttered office surface holding disputed turkey
After: Cleared of Troy post-grab, tension lingering

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

2
West Wing Corridor (Exterior Hallway Outside Leo McGarry's Office)

Bustling West Wing hallway frames prelude with C.J.'s terse press-relocation order to Carol and Toby's flirtatious intercept-invite, propelling her momentum into office chaos, its hectic pulse underscoring transition from banter to barnyard crisis.

Atmosphere Hectic and charged with overlapping urgencies
Function Transit hub for instructions and flirtation
Symbolism Embodiment of White Wing frenzy blending personal and professional
Access Restricted to staff and cleared personnel
Echoing footsteps on linoleum Rapid staff intercepts
Petting Zoo in Delaware

C.J. pitches idyllic Delaware petting zoo as merciful haven for both turkeys, invoking its hay-scented, kid-friendly chaos to counter slaughter protocol, injecting pastoral fantasy into D.C. haggling.

Atmosphere Evoked joyful rural respite
Function Proposed sanctuary destination
Symbolism Symbol of improvised compassion beyond politics
Access Open public farm attraction
Barnyard clamor and petting pens Floppy-eared goats and peeping chicks

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

2
Press Corps

Press Corps mobilized by C.J.'s hallway directive to Carol for Rose Garden shift, underscoring briefing urgency that amplifies her turkey distraction as comedic counterpoint to refugee diplomacy.

Representation Through relocation command to shadow aide Carol
Power Dynamics Subordinate to Press Secretary's logistical control
Impact Press readiness shapes White House narrative tempo
Assemble for timely Rose Garden briefing Pursue crisis narratives post-relocation Ravenous demand for access and intel Mobility under staff orchestration
Jasper Farms

Jasper Farms manifests through Morton Horn's insistent reclamation of sold turkey Troy, enforcing donation-sale protocol that one bird pardons while the other returns for profit, clashing rural commerce against C.J.'s whimsy.

Representation Via farmhand enforcer Morton Horn
Power Dynamics Institutional protocol challenging White House improvisation
Impact Highlights tension between rural suppliers and federal ceremonial traditions
Internal Dynamics Lean inventories demanding strict inventory control
Reclaim asset to fulfill prior sales Uphold donation-return farm standards Contractual prior sales commitments 派遣 dutiful farmhand representative

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 3
Emotional Echo medium

"C.J.'s private vulnerability about her musical incompetence is contrasted with her later playful exchange with Toby about singing."

C.J. Explains INS Credible Fear Process Amid Tense Meetings
S2E8 · Shibboleth
Emotional Echo medium

"C.J.'s private vulnerability about her musical incompetence is contrasted with her later playful exchange with Toby about singing."

C.J.'s Playful Deflection: Refugees to Turkey Songs
S2E8 · Shibboleth
Emotional Echo medium

"C.J.'s private vulnerability about her musical incompetence is contrasted with her later playful exchange with Toby about singing."

C.J.'s Poised Facade Cracks in Private Confession
S2E8 · Shibboleth

Key Dialogue

"C.J.: "I'm gonna buy them from you. What's he, 30 bucks?""
"MORTON: "These turkeys are 275 dollars.""
"C.J.: "For a turkey!?""
"C.J.: "Yeah, and I chose Eric because Troy doesn't like to be touched, which, surely we're not gonna execute him for.""
"C.J.: "Come with me, please.""