Fabula
S3E21 · Posse Comitatus

Leo Faces Gang of Eight Grill on Shareef Assassination Finding

Leo McGarry and Admiral Fitzwallace enter a charged conference room to notify the 'gang of eight' lawmakers of President Bartlet's signed presidential finding authorizing action against Abdul Shareef, backed by top intelligence and cabinet approvals. Lawmakers probe legal hurdles—Executive Order 11905, FBI limits, Posse Comitatus—culminating in Lobell's blunt accusation of murder. Leo's evasive pause, non-denial, and sarcastic exit on 'theater tickets' underscore the administration's moral tightrope, advancing the plot toward the assassination while excavating the ethical cost of pragmatic power.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

5

Leo and Fitzwallace enter a tense conference room where politicians await with intel files spread before them, signaling the gravity of the impending revelation.

anticipation to gravity ['round table', 'empty seats']

Leo delivers a presidential intelligence finding, detailing the chain of approvals from NSA to Joint Chiefs, escalating bureaucratic stakes.

formality to urgency

Fitzwallace corroborates the intelligence legitimacy, layering institutional weight as the notification reaches the 'gang of eight'.

authority to unease

Lobell bluntly confirms the assassination intent, shattering procedural pretense with 'You're killing Shareef?'—forcing Leo's evasive pause.

suspicion to confrontation

Leo exits with theater ticket sarcasm, leaving lawmakers reeling as the scene fades on the unresolved moral chasm of extrajudicial action.

tension to unresolved dread

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

8

Unyielding professionalism veiling operational certainty

Fitzwallace enters alongside Leo, sits formally, and delivers a precise rundown of the finding's review chain through National Security Advisor, cabinet secretaries, Attorney General, White House Counsel, and himself, submitting it stone-faced for notification without engaging challenges.

Goals in this moment
  • Authenticate the finding's legitimacy and approvals
  • Reinforce executive authority in notification process
Active beliefs
  • Shareef's elimination is legally and strategically justified
  • Military precision overrides congressional second-guessing
Character traits
formal stoic procedural resolute
Follow Percy Fitzwallace's journey

Determined resolve implied through actions

President Bartlet is referenced extensively as having requested, received, and signed the finding, planning to rescind EO 11905, and authorize at the last minute, central to the briefing's legitimacy without physical presence.

Goals in this moment
  • Authorize lethal action against Shareef
  • Navigate legal barriers strategically
Active beliefs
  • National security trumps assassination bans
  • Last-minute orders minimize exposure
Character traits
decisive pragmatic
Follow Abigail Bartlet's journey

Steel resolve masking ethical discomfort with biting sarcasm

Leo enters confidently, greets the group, meticulously explains the President's request and the finding's intel and cabinet approvals, deftly parries legal challenges with minimal responses, pauses heavily before evading Lobell's accusation, then abruptly exits citing theater tickets after declaring notification complete.

Goals in this moment
  • Formally notify Gang of Eight to satisfy legal protocol
  • Deflect probing questions to maintain operational secrecy
Active beliefs
  • Assassination is necessary despite moral qualms
  • Congressional oversight must be minimally acknowledged but not empowered
Character traits
evasive sarcastic authoritative pragmatic
Follow Leo McGarry's journey
Man 3rd
primary

Wary suspicion fueling pointed inquiry

Man 3rd, seated at the table with a copy of the finding, probes Leo skeptically with a curt question on military involvement, contributing to the barrage of legal hurdles raised by the group.

Goals in this moment
  • Clarify military's role in the operation
  • Highlight potential legal violations
Active beliefs
  • Military engagement risks broader infractions
  • Full disclosure is owed to oversight committee
Character traits
skeptical probing tactical pragmatic
Follow Man 3rd's journey

Intensifying doubt demanding precise answers

Unidentified Legislator (Man 1st) questions circumvention of Executive Order 11905 and presses Leo on the timing of the President's green light, driving the legal interrogation forward from his seat at the table.

Goals in this moment
  • Uncover how EO 11905 is bypassed
  • Pinpoint authorization timeline
Active beliefs
  • Executive Orders bind presidential actions
  • Oversight requires transparency on kill orders
Character traits
skeptical persistent analytical challenging
Follow Joshua Lyman's journey
Lobell
primary

Outraged defiance demanding accountability

Lobell sits with lawmakers, interjects bluntly invoking Posse Comitatus and directly accuses Leo of killing Shareef, escalating the interrogation into raw confrontation amid the group's rising scrutiny.

Goals in this moment
  • Expose and challenge the assassination plan
  • Enforce legal and constitutional constraints
Active beliefs
  • Executive overreach equates to murder
  • Posse Comitatus prohibits military action on U.S. soil
Character traits
confrontational unyielding incisive outspoken
Follow Lobell's journey
Supporting 1
Josh Lyman
secondary

skeptical

questions why FBI cannot act since Shareef is on U.S. soil

Goals in this moment
  • question reliance on non-law-enforcement action
Follow Josh Lyman's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

2
Presidential Finding Authorizing Action Against Shareef

Copies of the Presidential Finding slam onto the conference table, clutched by lawmakers as Leo and Fitzwallace detail its origin from overwhelming intel evidence, NSA/CIA sign-offs, and cabinet approvals; it serves as the fulcrum for notification, legal grilling, and accusation, embodying executive intent to unleash lethal action against Shareef.

Before: Prepared, signed by intel directors and approved by …
After: Reviewed and held by Gang of Eight lawmakers …
Before: Prepared, signed by intel directors and approved by cabinet, distributed to empty seats
After: Reviewed and held by Gang of Eight lawmakers post-notification
Leo's Theater Tickets

Leo's 'theater tickets' emerge as a venomous, fabricated excuse to abruptly terminate the briefing after evasion, slicing through tension with sarcasm as he rises and exits, underscoring the administration's disdain for prolonged scrutiny and accelerating the plot toward assassination.

Before: Non-existent (phantom pretext conjured spontaneously)
After: Invoked verbally as departure pretext, room left in …
Before: Non-existent (phantom pretext conjured spontaneously)
After: Invoked verbally as departure pretext, room left in stunned silence

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

4
National Security Agency

NSA directors' signatures on the intelligence finding are cited by Leo as key validation, providing 'overwhelming evidence' from foreign/domestic sources that prompted Bartlet's request, bolstering the briefing's credibility amid lawmakers' legal assaults.

Representation Via directors' formal sign-off on the finding
Power Dynamics Lending authoritative intel backing to executive action, overriding congressional skepticism
Impact Reinforces intelligence community's role in bridging legal gaps for national security
Validate lethal authorization through signed intel consensus Support covert operations against terror threats Signature authority on presidential findings Provision of classified evidence
Federal Bureau of Investigation

FBI's investigatory limits are invoked by Leo to counter Man 2nd's query on acting against Shareef on U.S. soil, ruling out police action and funneling necessity toward the military finding, sharpening Posse Comitatus debate.

Representation Through stated jurisdictional constraints
Power Dynamics Constrained by law, deferring to military/executive alternatives
Impact Underlines FBI's firewall in domestic ops, pushing covert escalation
Maintain investigatory purity Avoid prohibited police actions Legal role limitations cited defensively Jurisdictional boundaries enforced
Central Intelligence Agency

CIA directors' preparation and sign-off on the finding is highlighted by Leo, anchoring the document's legitimacy as it circulates among lawmakers, fueling defenses against EO 11905 and Posse Comitatus challenges.

Representation Through directors' sign-off referenced in briefing
Power Dynamics Empowering White House with vetted intel for assassination greenlight
Impact Exemplifies CIA's pivotal gatekeeping in covert ops approvals
Authorize action via finding endorsement Counter terror financing networks Document preparation and approval Evidence aggregation for executive use
Foreign and Domestic Intelligence Agencies

Foreign and domestic intelligence agencies supply the 'overwhelming evidence' Leo invokes, underpinning the finding's creation and presentation to the Gang of Eight, central to justifying the operation despite U.S. soil complications.

Representation Via aggregated evidence cited in the finding
Power Dynamics Providing foundational intel superiority over lawmakers' objections
Impact Highlights inter-agency fusion in terror threat neutralization
Compile evidence for Shareef targeting Enable presidential notification protocol Evidence provision to intel directors Shaping finding's narrative rationale

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph


Key Dialogue

"LOBELL: Posse Comitatus. You're killing Shareef? LEO: ([pause]) I don't know."
"MAN 1ST: Leo, when does the President give the green light? LEO: At the last possible minute. Consider yourselves notified. Thank you. I have theater tickets."