S2E21
Tumultuous
View Graph

18th and Potomac

President Bartlet faces catastrophic polls exposing voter fury over his concealed MS diagnosis while a Haitian military coup besieges the U.S. embassy, forcing his staff into frenzied crisis management and reelection debates—stakes skyrocket as personal tragedy strikes Mrs. Landingham dead in a drunk-driver crash.

Midnight shadows cloak the White House basement as President Jed Bartlet huddles with his inner circle—Leo McGarry, Josh Lyman, Sam Seaborn, Toby Ziegler, C.J. Cregg—around Joey Lucas's brutal poll numbers. Seventeen percent forgive the lie about his multiple sclerosis; seventy-one percent recoil from voting for a sick leader. Women over 55 bolt en masse, Democrats fracture, and fatal misconceptions doom trust. Bartlet absorbs the gut punch: 'They may be right.' Urgency ignites: a live Dateline special Wednesday night in the Mural Room, President and First Lady Abbey unmasked, followed by C.J.'s press conference cage match. But reelection? Silence hangs like a noose—no firm answer yet.

Dawn cracks open parallel infernos. In Haiti, Colonel Bazan's troops crush president-elect Jean-Pierre Dessalines's victory rally, vanish him into Jake Bratt's car trunk racing for U.S. asylum. Port-au-Prince teeters: army tanks police stations, UN observers hunker. Bartlet orders non-essential embassy evacuations, Marines reinforce—Jake warns of standoff signals. Robbie Mosley urges restraint, but Leo roars: 'We saw to it there was a free election!' Dessalines breaches the gates; Bazan's forces encircle, AR-15s gleam (U.S.-sold), Bradleys loom with 120mm cannons against 37 Marines clutching M-14s. Nancy mobilizes the 8-80th Hostage Task Force. Shots crack: Haitian soldiers board the evac C-9; staff sergeants drop three, plane screams skyward. Bartlet erupts—'That wasn't supposed to happen!'—Leo counters: rules of engagement demand it. Diplomatic whispers via Canada, Dominicans; Bazan craves Dessalines for embezzlement charges. OAS emergency session looms.

Josh battles Capitol Hill: Justice's tobacco lawsuit starves—31 lawyers versus tobacco's 4,676—Kalmbach buries funding, swayed by $460K PACs. Democrats Warren, Rossiter defect, scorning 'politically correct extortion.' Josh vows dynamite: C.J. blasts Congress publicly. Toby shocks Donna Moss with the MS bomb; she absorbs, steels for war. Sam clashes with Abbey over medical jargon—neuropathy, optic neuritis, Betaseron self-prescribed across state lines, ethics boards circling. Oliver Babish grills her: no records, family treatment taboo. Abbey demands to stand by Jed.

Comedy pierces tension: Mrs. Landingham, widowed Delores, haggles her first new car—blue beauty, AC humming, that dashboard freedom scent. Charlie ribs her sticker-price folly, ethics shield her from discounts. Bartlet teases, offers to cover the gap; she beams independence.

Night deepens resolve. Staff converges on Leo's office, demanding reelection clarity—Sam spouts vestibulo-cochlear vertigo, eyes roll. Leo snaps: full steam on all fronts, no detours. C.J. secures networks sans logos. Josh lights fuses on tobacco foes.

Then devastation: Charlie's voice cracks—drunk driver T-bones Mrs. Landingham at 18th and Potomac. She's gone. Leo staggers, aged decades, veranda lights mocking his frailty. French doors part; Bartlet turns. Through warped glass, Leo delivers the blow. Worlds fracture. Haiti simmers, MS looms, but grief eclipses all—stakes eternal, presidency shadowed by irreplaceable loss.


Events in This Episode

The narrative beats that drive the story

29
Act 1

The episode plunges into the White House basement, where President Bartlet and his inner circle confront the brutal reality of Joey Lucas's poll numbers. The data rips through their carefully constructed world: a mere 17% forgive Bartlet's concealed MS diagnosis, while a staggering 71% recoil from voting for a sick leader. Women over 55, a crucial demographic, abandon him en masse, and even loyal Democrats fracture, poisoned by the lie. The most damning revelation: 74% of voters mistakenly believe MS is fatal. Bartlet absorbs the gut punch, his quiet admission, "They may be right," hanging heavy in the air. This act masterfully establishes the central, crushing internal conflict: the political death sentence looming over a presidency built on trust, now shattered by a hidden illness. The urgency is palpable, setting the stage for a desperate fight for survival, immediately raising the stakes for Bartlet's leadership and the integrity of his administration. The initial shock and disbelief among his senior staff underscore the monumental challenge ahead, as the political landscape shifts dramatically under their feet. This opening salvo defines the core mission: somehow navigate this treacherous terrain and reclaim public trust, a task that feels insurmountable from the outset.

Act 2

As dawn breaks, the White House plunges into a dual crisis. In Haiti, Colonel Bazan's forces unleash chaos, crushing a victory rally and making president-elect Dessaline vanish, forcing his desperate flight towards U.S. asylum. Bartlet, haunted by past tragedies, immediately orders a non-essential embassy evacuation and Marine reinforcement, escalating the international stakes despite warnings of a dangerous standoff. Simultaneously, the domestic battle rages as C.J., Josh, Sam, and Toby frantically strategize the public revelation of Bartlet's MS. C.J. champions a high-stakes, live Dateline special with the President and First Lady, followed by a press conference, aiming to control the narrative. Sam, however, pierces the frantic planning with the unanswerable question: will Bartlet seek re-election? This act expertly layers an external geopolitical powder keg atop the internal political implosion, demonstrating the immense pressure on the administration. Amidst this, the mundane charm of Mrs. Landingham's new car purchase offers a brief, humanizing counterpoint, while Josh unearths deep-seated political corruption blocking a critical tobacco lawsuit, hinting at the entrenched battles ahead. The relentless pace and intersecting crises force the team to make immediate, high-consequence decisions, setting the stage for an even more volatile future.

Act 3

The Haitian crisis explodes as Dessaline, hidden in Jake Bratt's car trunk, breaches the U.S. embassy gates. Bartlet, against the counsel of caution, makes the decisive, high-stakes call to grant asylum, transforming a volatile situation into an official standoff with Bazan's encircling, U.S.-armed forces. The threat of a full-scale hostage crisis looms large, forcing Nancy to mobilize the 8-80th Hostage Task Force, signaling a dramatic escalation to military intervention. Back in the White House, the MS revelation strategy intensifies. C.J., Toby, and Sam fiercely debate the political calculus of including Vice President Hoynes in the upcoming press conference, each argument a sharp-edged weapon in the fight for public perception, highlighting the deep divisions within the team. Meanwhile, Josh confronts the entrenched corruption stifling the Justice Department's tobacco lawsuit, discovering powerful PAC money has swayed key Democrats, revealing the depth of the political war they face beyond the immediate crises. In a moment of profound trust and vulnerability, Toby delivers the shocking news of Bartlet's MS diagnosis to Donna Moss, her quiet, steeling resolve a testament to the loyalty this administration commands, even in the face of betrayal. This act masterfully ratchets up the tension on all fronts, transforming abstract threats into immediate, life-or-death confrontations and exposing the personal and political costs of the unfolding crises, pushing the administration to its breaking point.

Act 4

The administration grapples with the escalating consequences of its dual crises. C.J. faces a barrage of press questions regarding the military deployment to Haiti, deflecting inquiries about invasion while fiercely protecting the narrative. Her subsequent, high-stakes negotiation with network head Paul Hackett secures the live, logo-free Dateline special for the President and First Lady, a testament to her strategic prowess and a stark warning against leaks. Simultaneously, Josh confronts the cynical reality of political obstruction, accusing Congressmen Warren and Rossiter of "politically correct extortion" for blocking tobacco lawsuit funding, his impassioned plea highlighting the human cost of their inaction. The most devastating internal front opens as Sam and Oliver Babish rigorously interrogate Abbey Bartlet. Under pressure, she reveals a web of medical ethics violations: self-prescribing Betaseron, treating her husband across state lines, and maintaining no medical records. Babish, recognizing her profound legal exposure, urges her to secure independent counsel and reconsider the broadcast, yet Abbey's unwavering resolve to stand by her husband burns fiercely. The Haitian situation then erupts into tragic violence: three Haitian soldiers are shot and killed on the runway while attempting to board the evacuating C-9. Bartlet's fury clashes with Leo's grim defense of the rules of engagement, as diplomatic whispers reveal Bazan's demand for Dessaline on embezzlement charges. Amidst this maelstrom, Bartlet, shaken by the day's events, finally commits to addressing the critical re-election question with his staff, setting a 9 PM meeting that promises to define their future.

Act 5

Night falls, bringing a deceptive calm before the storm. President Bartlet shares a tender, teasing moment with Mrs. Landingham, playfully debating her new car purchase and offering to cover the price difference. Her joyful anticipation of her "blue beauty" and the "smell of freedom" provides a poignant, human counterpoint to the relentless political pressure. Meanwhile, Abbey Bartlet continues her tense confrontation with Oliver Babish, who relentlessly exposes her medical ethics violations and insists she obtain independent legal counsel before the broadcast. Her defiance, rooted in loyalty to her husband, underscores the immense personal sacrifice she faces. The White House staff, including Josh, Toby, C.J., and Sam, converge on Leo's office, their collective frustration boiling over as they demand immediate clarity on Bartlet's re-election intentions. Leo, weary but resolute, confirms a 9 PM meeting, while simultaneously instructing Josh to unleash a public "dynamite" statement against the tobacco lobby. Just as the stage is set for the administration's most critical strategic discussions, devastation strikes. Charlie, his voice cracking, delivers the crushing news to Leo: Mrs. Landingham, driving her new car, has been killed by a drunk driver at 18th and Potomac. Leo staggers, visibly aged by the blow, before delivering the shattering news to a distant, distorted Bartlet through the warped glass of the French doors. The episode culminates in this profound, irreplaceable personal loss, eclipsing all political and international crises, leaving the presidency shadowed by grief and the future uncertain, a devastating blow that redefines the stakes of everything that came before.