Hearing Convened — Duty Against Friendship
Plot Beats
The narrative micro-steps within this event
PHILLIPA delivers a legal verdict: under the Acts of Gould, Data is Starfleet property and therefore cannot resign or refuse Commander Maddox, converting a personnel dispute into a binding legal claim.
PICARD forcefully challenges the ruling and demands Phillipa convene a hearing, transforming the legal pronouncement into an actionable confrontation.
PHILLIPA objects to logistical constraints—no staff at the new base—while PICARD presses regulations as a fix, forcing Phillipa to accept improvised measures to hold the hearing.
Who Was There
Characters present in this moment
Calmly resolute and deliberately unsentimental; her composure masks a willingness to weaponize procedure to achieve institutional ends.
Phillipa presents her research, cites the Acts of Gould, insists on summary legal authority, improvises a hearing using serving officers, names Riker as prosecutor, and threatens immediate transfer to Commander Maddox.
- • Assert Starfleet's legal ownership of Data under the Acts of Gould
- • Ensure an enforceable, expedient adjudication even without full JAG staff
- • Institutional law supersedes personal loyalty in disputes over property and duty
- • Adversarial procedure, even improvised, is the correct method to resolve contested facts
Assigned and procedural; their presence is implied as functional rather than emotional, representing institutional obligation.
Serving officers are proposed as ad hoc legal counsel to fill JAG staffing gaps; they are named as procedural instruments to make the hearing possible despite the new base's limited resources.
- • Serve as legal counsel as appointed to allow the hearing to proceed
- • Ensure that Starfleet's procedural requirements are met despite staffing shortages
- • Duty requires stepping into roles assigned by higher authority
- • Procedural legitimacy can be achieved even with ad hoc personnel
Resolute and protective; outwardly composed but morally engaged, prepared to marshal procedure in defense of his officer.
Picard immediately challenges Phillipa's ruling, insists upon a hearing to contest the claim, accepts the role of defender as senior officer, and measures Riker's reluctance with a quiet command presence.
- • Prevent a summary decree that would strip Data of autonomy without contest
- • Use Starfleet procedure to defend what he believes is Data's personhood
- • Command responsibility includes defending subordinates from unjust institutional actions
- • Legal process can be used as a shield to test and protect moral claims
Vulnerability is inferred; treated as legal object rather than moral subject, rendering his status precarious.
Data is not physically present in the room but is the subject of Phillipa's ruling and the threatened transfer; his autonomy and agency are debated as if he were property, making him the focal point of procedural coercion.
- • (Implied) Maintain autonomy and remain under Enterprise command
- • Avoid forced transfer and experimental refit
- • (Implied by others' arguments) That his personhood is contested and must be defended
- • (As understood by crew) Data's rights are not self-evident in Starfleet law
Visibly stricken and bitter; torn between duty and friendship, forced into a role that violates his conscience.
Riker refuses to prosecute due to personal affection and respect for Data, argues the moral impossibility of treating Data as 'mere machine', then, under Phillipa's threat of summary ruling and immediate transfer, reluctantly agrees and accepts the prosecutor assignment with bitter resignation.
- • Avoid prosecuting his friend and preserve personal integrity
- • Prevent an unfair institutional outcome for Data
- • Personal loyalty and lived knowledge of someone should inform legal judgment
- • An adversarial system that forces friends to fight undermines moral bonds
Objects Involved
Significant items in this scene
The Acts of Gould are Phillipa's legal foundation: she cites them as conclusive proof that Data is Starfleet property. The Acts transform a personnel dispute into an enforceable legal claim, enabling summary rulings and transfer orders.
The JAG office hearing is the procedural mechanism Phillipa invokes and then improvises: she will preside, use serving officers as counsel, and hold the hearing in order to adjudicate Data's status despite limited staff.
Starfleet regulations are verbally invoked by Picard and implied by Phillipa when discussing hearing logistics; they provide the procedural framework that allows Picard to demand a hearing and Phillipa to improvise counsel from serving officers.
The experimental refit (transfer) functions as the explicit punitive remedy Phillipa threatens: she orders Data to report to Commander Maddox for disassembly/refit, converting legal theory into an immediate, bodily threat to Data's autonomy.
Location Details
Places and their significance in this event
The 'new base' is cited by Phillipa to explain the lack of JAG staff and logistical difficulty; it functions as the pragmatic constraint that forces her to improvise legal procedure using serving officers.
The Starfleet Judicial Courtroom is referenced as the intended formal venue for adjudication; though the improvised hearing takes place in the JAG office, the courtroom looms as the canonical site where the legal battle will be publicly argued.
The defendant's ship is referenced to determine who will serve as prosecutor—the next most senior officer aboard that vessel—linking Riker's assignment to chain-of-command conventions across ships.
Narrative Connections
How this event relates to others in the story
"Phillipa's initial JAG ruling that Data is Starfleet property (Acts of Gould) leads directly to her convening procedures that assign a prosecutor—Riker—escalating the dispute into formal litigation."
"Phillipa's property ruling escalates the conflict from administrative dispute to formal hearing when Picard forcefully challenges her decision and demands adjudication."
"Phillipa's initial JAG ruling that Data is Starfleet property (Acts of Gould) leads directly to her convening procedures that assign a prosecutor—Riker—escalating the dispute into formal litigation."
"Phillipa's property ruling escalates the conflict from administrative dispute to formal hearing when Picard forcefully challenges her decision and demands adjudication."
Themes This Exemplifies
Thematic resonance and meaning
Part of Larger Arcs
Key Dialogue
"PHILLIPA: "I have completed my research, and based on the Acts of Gould passed in the early twenty-first century, Data is the property of Starfleet. He cannot resign and he cannot refuse to cooperate with Commander Maddox.""
"PICARD: "Then I so challenge. Convene your hearing.""
"RIKER: "I can't. I won't. Data's my friend, my comrade. We've served together and I not only respect him, I have affection for him.""