Risking Orbit: Picard Chooses Four Percent
Plot Beats
The narrative micro-steps within this event
Picard orders the Enterprise into a closer orbit to enhance sensor efficiency, showing his determination to locate Palmer.
Who Was There
Characters present in this moment
Physically compromised and unconscious/unstable; emotional state is not articulated but her condition amplifies the urgency in sickbay.
Warren is present as a patient, undergoing burn and anti-radiation treatment; she is incapacitated and receiving life-saving interventions from the medical team.
- • Stabilize and survive the immediate injuries.
- • Receive continued medical care until recovered.
- • Medical intervention can restore her if properly administered.
- • Her survival depends on swift Starfleet medical response.
Panicked and agitated initially, then relieved and mollified by authoritative reassurance.
Barron regains consciousness in a state of agitation, struggles against a medic demanding evacuation and asking about Palmer's whereabouts; he is calmed by Picard's promise and sedated by Beverly's hypospray.
- • Ensure the safety and evacuation of his colleagues (including Palmer and Warren).
- • Receive immediate medical attention and reliable information about the team.
- • His colleagues (especially Palmer) may be in grave danger.
- • Command (Picard) can and will mobilize resources to find them.
Frightened and curious; a fragile mix of recognition and naive awe toward Picard that instantly alarms the medical team.
Liko is lying on a biobed, treated for injuries; he awakens, scans the room, fixates on Picard, tentatively utters the captain's name, and is immediately sedated by Beverly.
- • Understand who aided him and why.
- • Survive and be cared for after his injuries.
- • Those who intervene possess great power (interprets rescuers as special or divine).
- • Naming the rescuer may secure protection or status.
Unknown physically; narratively placed in danger which creates urgency among the crew.
Palmer is not physically present in the scene; he is repeatedly referenced as the missing anthropologist still on Mintaka Three and the motivating focus of Picard's orbit order and rescue promise.
- • Survive and be located by the Enterprise away team.
- • Continue his anthropological work (implied prior to accident).
- • He can be found and rescued if the Enterprise commits resources.
- • His situation is serious enough to justify risky search actions.
Resolute and controlled on the surface; inwardly conflicted between duty to save lives and duty to preserve cultural integrity.
Picard enters sickbay, confronts Beverly over bringing Liko aboard, insists that all memory of the encounter be removed, soothes Barron with a firm promise to find Palmer, taps the sickbay communicator to order a closer orbit, and freezes when Liko calls his name.
- • Prevent cultural contamination by erasing Liko's memory of the away team.
- • Locate and rescue Palmer from Mintaka Three as quickly as possible.
- • Contain the consequences of contact by ordering tactical measures (closer orbit).
- • The Prime Directive is a binding ethical constraint that must be mitigated when possible.
- • Starfleet (and he personally) bears responsibility for harms caused by their presence.
- • Operational sacrifices (e.g., tighter orbit) are justified to both save a life and limit cultural damage.
Professional and mildly cautionary; communicating operational limitations without drama.
Worf speaks over the communicator from the bridge: reports that scans detect no humans on the planet, warns that close orbit will only increase sensor efficiency by four percent, and acknowledges Picard's order to move to close orbit.
- • Provide accurate sensor and tactical information to command.
- • Comply with Captain's orders while noting tactical trade-offs.
- • Sensor manipulation and ship maneuvers directly affect rescue odds.
- • Hierarchy and orders must be observed; he will execute commands despite risk.
Protective and determined; under pressure but prioritizing immediate medical needs over theoretical objections.
Dr. Beverly Crusher moves among stations treating patients, defends her decision to beam Liko aboard as necessary to save his life, administers a hypospray to quiet Barron, and, when Liko utters 'Picard,' immediately sedates him with a hypospray to prevent cultural contamination.
- • Stabilize injured patients and save lives (Barron, Warren, Liko).
- • Minimize cultural harm by preparing or performing memory-erasure procedures.
- • Follow through on necessary, rapid clinical actions even when controversial.
- • Medical duty to save life can supersede strict adherence to doctrine in acute emergencies.
- • Because Starfleet/its personnel caused or precipitated the injury, they have an obligation to remedy it.
- • Short-term memory-erasure is a practicable tool to limit cultural contamination even if imperfect on alien neurochemistry.
Urgent and focused; operating on autopilot to follow medical commands and maintain patient safety.
The medic assists with Liko's treatment, physically restrains or helps restrain Barron until Beverly administers a hypospray, and completes immediate procedures at Liko's biobed as ordered by Dr. Crusher.
- • Execute medical orders quickly and correctly to stabilize patients.
- • Prevent further harm by restraining agitated patients and facilitating sedation.
- • Following the physician's orders is the fastest way to save lives.
- • Rapid, physical intervention (restraint, sedation) is necessary when patients are delirious or dangerous to themselves.
Objects Involved
Significant items in this scene
The sickbay communicator is the conduit by which Picard contacts the bridge and receives Worf's tactical sensor readout; it turns an ethical, bed-side exchange into an immediate ship-wide command decision to change orbit and improve sensor capability.
Beverly's hypospray is used as an immediate clinical instrument: she injects Barron to quiet his delirium and later administers a sedative dose to Liko to prevent the Mintakan from vocalizing 'Picard' to others. The hypospray functions as both a medical stabilizer and a cultural-containment tool.
Sickbay examination biobeds serve as the physical loci of injury and ethical conflict: Liko, Barron, and Warren occupy biobeds during triage, allowing clinicians to assess, calm, sedate, and perform memory-erasure discussions in the clinical space.
Location Details
Places and their significance in this event
The bridge is represented remotely via Worf's communicator messages; it supplies the tactical sensor information that forces Picard to convert his bedside ethical argument into a concrete navigational order to alter orbit for improved scanning.
Close orbit is invoked as a tactical response to increase sensor efficiency by a marginal four percent; it becomes the practical lever Picard chooses to deploy in order to accelerate locating Palmer and to limit further cultural fallout through faster, more informed action.
Sickbay is the scene of cascading decisions where medical triage, ethical debate, and command authority collide: life-saving procedures occur simultaneously with a doctrinal argument about the Prime Directive and plans to erase memory, making the ward both a healing space and an ethical courtroom.
Mintaka Three functions as the unseen but urgent locus of the crisis: Palmer remains missing there, the away team's exposure occurred there, and the planet is the cultural sphere that the crew fears contaminating — the reason for memory-erasure and the motive for the rescue.
Narrative Connections
How this event relates to others in the story
No narrative connections mapped yet
This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph
Themes This Exemplifies
Thematic resonance and meaning
Key Dialogue
"BEVERLY: "Before you start quoting the Prime Directive -- he'd already seen us; the damage was done. It was bring him aboard or let him die.""
"PICARD: "Then why didn't you let him die?""
"WORF'S COM VOICE: "Scans of the planet detect no humans, Captain.""
"PICARD: "Very well. Take us into a close orbit.""
"WORF'S COM VOICE: "Sir, a close orbit will increase sensor efficiency by only four percent.""
"PICARD: "I want that four percent, Lieutenant.""