Fabula
S3E26 · The Best of Both Worlds, Part I

The Weight of the Chair: Riker’s Crucible of Command

In the high-stakes crucible of the Enterprise’s pursuit of the Borg, Commander William Riker—now thrust into the role of acting captain—faces his first existential test of leadership. The bridge hums with tension as the crew races toward Federation space, the Borg cube relentlessly pulling them deeper into the heart of their defenses. Riker’s internal conflict is laid bare: his instinct to lead the away team and rescue Picard battles against his newfound responsibility to command the ship. The moment crystallizes the fragility of authority in crisis, as Riker must delegate the mission to Shelby—a decision that underscores his growth from impulsive first officer to measured leader. His log entry, delivered in a voice heavy with dread, reveals the stakes of failure: the Borg’s path threatens unimaginable devastation, and Riker’s choices may determine whether the Federation survives. The scene is a turning point in his arc, marking the moment he fully embraces the burden of command, even as it forces him to sacrifice personal impulse for the greater good. The bridge’s controlled chaos—Worf’s tactical warnings, Geordi’s technical constraints, Troi’s emotional insight—frames Riker’s solitude in the captain’s chair, a symbol of his isolation in leadership and the weight of the unknown ahead.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

1

Riker records a log entry, emphasizing the dire situation as the Enterprise pursues the Borg toward the heart of the Federation, noting the potential for unimaginable devastation.

somber to determined

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

9

Frustrated by Riker’s initial decision to lead the away team himself, but determined to assert her expertise. Her acceptance of the order is tinged with professionalism, though her competitive spirit remains palpable. She is driven by a desire to prove her worth and contribute meaningfully to the mission.

Shelby stands with her arms crossed, her posture radiating competitive energy. She interrupts Riker’s orders with a sharp protest, leveraging her Borg expertise to argue for her right to lead the away team. Her blink of surprise when Riker reasserts his command is fleeting, replaced by a nod of reluctant acceptance. She is the embodiment of ambition and tactical precision, her dialogue concise and purposeful, reflecting her confidence in her abilities and her frustration at being sidelined.

Goals in this moment
  • To convince Riker to let her lead the away team due to her Borg defense expertise
  • To assert her authority and tactical knowledge as critical to the mission’s success
Active beliefs
  • That her specialized knowledge of the Borg makes her the ideal leader for the away team
  • That Riker’s initial impulse to lead is driven by emotion rather than strategy
Character traits
Assertive and competitive Tactically confident Ambitious for leadership roles Quick to challenge authority when she disagrees Adapts to orders despite initial resistance
Follow Shelby's journey

A storm of conflicted emotions—frustration at being unable to lead the rescue, resignation to the necessity of command, and a dawning sense of the isolation inherent in leadership. His voice-over log betrays a heavy dread, underscoring the weight of the unknown and the potential consequences of failure.

Riker stands at the center of the bridge’s storm, his posture rigid with the weight of command. He initially asserts his intent to lead the away team to rescue Picard, his voice carrying the urgency of personal loyalty. However, when Shelby challenges his authority and Troi intervenes with a reminder of his duty, Riker’s demeanor shifts—his shoulders tense, his frown deepens as he grapples with the conflict between impulse and responsibility. His final order to Shelby is delivered with quiet resolve, and his slow sink into the captain’s chair symbolizes his acceptance of the burden. The voice-over log reveals the gravity of his emotional state: conflicted yet resolute, burdened by the stakes but committed to the greater good.

Goals in this moment
  • To assert command authority and delegate the away team mission to Shelby despite personal reluctance
  • To communicate the dire stakes of the Borg pursuit to the crew and Starfleet through his log entry
Active beliefs
  • That his primary duty is to the *Enterprise* and the Federation, not to personal attachments
  • That Shelby’s expertise makes her the better choice to lead the away team, despite his initial impulse to go himself
Character traits
Decisive under pressure Conflict between personal loyalty and duty Symbolic embrace of leadership Emotionally introspective Strategic delegation
Follow William Riker's journey

Supportive and empathetic, but with an underlying urgency. She senses Riker’s internal conflict and intervenes not to undermine him, but to guide him toward the correct decision. Her tone is authoritative yet compassionate, reflecting her role as both counselor and bridge officer.

Troi steps into the breach left by Shelby’s protest, her voice calm but firm. She addresses Riker directly, her empathy allowing her to articulate the unspoken tension: his place is on the bridge, not leading the away team. Her intervention is timely and precise, filling the silence with the weight of her counsel. She does not raise her voice, but her presence commands attention, reinforcing the necessity of Riker’s role as acting captain.

Goals in this moment
  • To remind Riker of his duty to command the *Enterprise* during the crisis
  • To mediate the tension between Riker and Shelby, ensuring a unified response to the Borg threat
Active beliefs
  • That Riker’s emotional connection to Picard could cloud his judgment in this critical moment
  • That the crew’s cohesion depends on clear leadership and adherence to protocol
Character traits
Diplomatic and measured Empathically attuned to group dynamics Authoritative in her counsel Fills gaps in communication with insight Supports institutional hierarchy
Follow Deanna Troi's journey
Supporting 6

Eager and focused, with a underlying sense of responsibility. Wesley’s emotional state is one of determination, his energy directed toward assisting Geordi and contributing to the deflector’s modification. He is fully engaged in the operational planning, his presence a testament to his growing role within the crew.

Wesley is tasked by Riker to continue assisting Geordi with the deflector modification. His role in this event is supportive, though his dialogue is limited to his earlier warning about the Borg’s warp speed. His presence on the bridge and his inclusion in the engineering efforts reflect his growing integration into the crew’s operational roles, despite his junior status.

Goals in this moment
  • To assist Geordi in completing the deflector modification within the time constraints
  • To contribute to the *Enterprise*’s efforts to counter the Borg threat
Active beliefs
  • That his technical skills are valuable to the mission’s success
  • That his role as an ensign includes participation in critical engineering tasks
Character traits
Eager to contribute Technically capable Supportive of senior officers Focused on the mission Adapting to high-pressure environments
Follow Wesley Crusher's journey

Tense and alert, with a underlying sense of urgency. The supernumeraries’ emotional state is one of professionalism, their focus on their stations reflecting their commitment to the mission. They are fully engaged in the operational planning, their presence a testament to the crew’s cohesion.

The supernumeraries at Conn and Ops stations maintain their positions, contributing to the ship’s operations during the pursuit. Their presence is noted but not individually detailed, their roles focused on maintaining navigation and operations continuity as senior officers address the command responses. They embody the crew’s resilience under pressure, their actions supporting the bridge’s functional integrity.

Goals in this moment
  • To maintain the *Enterprise*’s operational continuity during the pursuit
  • To support the bridge crew in their efforts to counter the Borg threat
Active beliefs
  • That their roles are critical to the ship’s success
  • That the crew’s cohesion depends on their reliability and discipline
Character traits
Disciplined and focused Supportive of senior officers Resilient under pressure Reliable in operational roles Unobtrusive but essential
Follow Conn and …'s journey

Neutral and efficient, with no visible emotional reaction to the tension or urgency. Data’s demeanor is that of a machine executing its function, though his presence as part of the away team plan suggests a willingness to engage in high-risk operations when required.

Data stands beside Riker, his posture erect and his expression neutral. He provides a precise calculation of the Borg’s warp speed and the remaining time before the Enterprise must power down, his voice devoid of emotion but carrying the weight of factual urgency. He is included in Riker’s initial away team plan, though his role in the event is primarily as a source of analytical support. His dialogue is concise and to the point, reinforcing the technical realities of the pursuit.

Goals in this moment
  • To provide accurate and timely technical data to support command decisions
  • To assist in the away team mission if deployed, leveraging his analytical and adaptive capabilities
Active beliefs
  • That the mission’s success depends on precise calculations and logical planning
  • That his role as a Starfleet officer includes participation in high-risk operations when necessary
Character traits
Logically precise and efficient Supportive of command decisions Unemotionally factual Adapts to changing mission parameters Provides critical data without bias
Follow Data's journey

Alert and focused, with an underlying combativeness. Worf’s demeanor is that of a warrior ready for action, his loyalty to the Enterprise and its crew evident in his willingness to follow orders, even into high-risk situations.

Worf is at his tactical station, his voice a low growl as he warns of the Borg’s course into Federation space. He is included in Riker’s initial away team plan, his presence signaling his readiness to engage in direct combat. Though he does not speak during this specific event beyond his initial warning, his posture and the context imply his alertness and combative readiness. He is a silent but imposing figure, reinforcing the bridge’s defensive posture.

Goals in this moment
  • To support Riker’s command decisions and provide tactical analysis as needed
  • To prepare for potential away team deployment and direct engagement with the Borg
Active beliefs
  • That the Borg threat requires a unified and aggressive response
  • That his role as Security Chief includes participation in away missions when ordered
Character traits
Alert and combative Loyal to the chain of command Prepared for direct engagement Tactically focused Disciplined under pressure
Follow Worf's journey

Determined and concerned, with a underlying sense of urgency. Beverly’s emotional state is one of readiness, her focus on the mission’s objectives and the potential medical needs of the away team. She is fully engaged in the operational planning, her presence a reassurance to the crew.

Beverly is included in Riker’s initial away team plan, her medical expertise implied as critical to the mission’s success. Though she does not speak during this event, her presence on the bridge and her inclusion in the plan suggest her readiness to assist in both medical and tactical capacities. Her demeanor is professional and composed, reflecting her dual role as Chief Medical Officer and away team member.

Goals in this moment
  • To support the away team mission with her medical expertise and tactical assistance
  • To ensure the crew’s safety and readiness for potential injuries or emergencies
Active beliefs
  • That her skills are essential to the mission’s success, both in terms of medical care and tactical support
  • That the Borg threat requires a coordinated response from all crew members
Character traits
Professionally composed Dual-role readiness (medical and tactical) Loyal to the crew and mission Adaptable to high-pressure situations Supportive of command decisions
Follow Beverly Crusher's journey

Pressured but determined, with a underlying optimism that the task can be accomplished. He is fully engaged in the problem-solving process, his energy directed toward overcoming the technical hurdles rather than dwelling on the broader stakes. His demeanor is that of a professional absorbed in his craft.

Geordi is already deep in conversation with Riker about the deflector’s status, his hands gesturing as he outlines the technical constraints. He is focused, his voice steady despite the pressure, and he emphasizes the critical need for warp engine power to complete the weapon modification. His dialogue is practical and urgent, reflecting his role as the engineer tasked with turning theory into a functional solution under impossible time constraints.

Goals in this moment
  • To complete the deflector modification within the time constraints imposed by the Borg’s warp speed
  • To secure the necessary power from the warp engines to make the weapon functional
Active beliefs
  • That the deflector can be repurposed as a weapon with sufficient power and time
  • That his team’s efforts are critical to the *Enterprise*’s ability to counter the Borg threat
Character traits
Highly focused under pressure Technically precise and solution-oriented Collaborative with senior officers Optimistic despite challenges Prioritizes mission-critical tasks
Follow Geordi La …'s journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

3
Enterprise Captain's Chair

The captain’s chair serves as a powerful symbolic prop in this event, representing the transfer of command from Picard to Riker. As Riker sinks into the chair after delegating the away team mission to Shelby, the act is laden with significance: it symbolizes his acceptance of the burden of leadership and his commitment to the *Enterprise*’s crew and mission. The chair is not merely a piece of furniture but a throne of responsibility, its elevated position humming with the weight of the ship’s status displays under Riker’s hands. It frames his isolation in command, a physical manifestation of the solitude inherent in leadership during a crisis.

Before: Occupied by Riker as he stands near it, …
After: Now fully occupied by Riker, who sinks into …
Before: Occupied by Riker as he stands near it, delivering orders and grappling with his internal conflict. The chair is a silent witness to the tension on the bridge, its presence a constant reminder of the authority it represents.
After: Now fully occupied by Riker, who sinks into it with a sense of resignation and resolve. The chair becomes a symbol of his new role as acting captain, its functional and symbolic weight now fully his to bear.
Enterprise's Main Deflector Dish (Weaponized)

The deflector is central to the *Enterprise*’s defensive strategy against the Borg, though its modification into a weapon is still underway. Geordi emphasizes the critical need for warp engine power to complete the task, highlighting the object’s dual role as both a navigational tool and a potential game-changer in the pursuit. The deflector’s status as a work-in-progress underscores the urgency and technical challenges facing the crew, as they race against the Borg’s relentless advance. Its successful completion could provide the *Enterprise* with a much-needed advantage, making it a focal point of hope amid the desperation.

Before: Partially modified, with Geordi and Wesley working urgently …
After: Still in the process of being modified, but …
Before: Partially modified, with Geordi and Wesley working urgently to repurpose it into a weapon. It requires significant power from the warp engines to function, a constraint that adds to the crew’s pressure.
After: Still in the process of being modified, but with the crew’s efforts focused on securing the necessary power to complete the task. The deflector remains a critical but unfinished component of the *Enterprise*’s defense strategy.
USS Enterprise Warp Engines (Propulsion System)

The warp engines are the lifeblood of the *Enterprise*’s pursuit, their power divided between maintaining the ship’s speed and fueling the deflector’s modification. Geordi highlights the tension between these competing demands, emphasizing that the engines are already operating at full capacity to keep up with the Borg. The engines’ role is thus both a constraint and a potential solution: their power is essential for the deflector weapon, but their current allocation leaves little room for additional strain. This duality underscores the crew’s precarious position, as they balance the need for speed with the need for firepower.

Before: Operating at full capacity to sustain the *Enterprise*’s …
After: Still operating at full capacity, but now with …
Before: Operating at full capacity to sustain the *Enterprise*’s pursuit of the Borg at high warp. The engines are already stretched thin, with little reserve power available for other tasks.
After: Still operating at full capacity, but now with the added pressure of potentially rerouting power to the deflector. The engines remain a critical but overtaxed resource, their performance directly tied to the ship’s ability to counter the Borg threat.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

2
Bridge of the USS Enterprise-D

The main bridge of the *Enterprise* is the nerve center of the ship’s response to the Borg threat, a space pulsing with tension and urgency. The red alert lights cast a stark glow over the crew, while the blaring klaxons underscore the stakes of their pursuit. The forward viewscreen dominates the scene, displaying the relentless Borg cube as it pulls the *Enterprise* deeper into Federation space. The bridge’s layout—with its tactical, ops, and conn stations—facilitates the crew’s coordinated efforts, even as the space itself becomes a battleground of wills. Riker’s struggle with command plays out against this backdrop, the bridge’s controlled chaos framing his solitude in the captain’s chair.

Atmosphere Tension-filled with whispered conversations, urgent commands, and the hum of machinery. The air is thick …
Function Command center for the *Enterprise*’s pursuit of the Borg, where strategic decisions are made, tactical …
Symbolism Represents the heart of Starfleet’s resistance to the Borg, a microcosm of the Federation’s values—unity, …
Access Restricted to senior officers and essential crew members during Red Alert. The bridge is a …
Pulsing red alert lights casting a stark glow over the crew Blaring klaxons underscoring the urgency of the situation Forward viewscreen displaying the Borg cube, a constant reminder of the threat Tactical, ops, and conn stations facilitating coordinated efforts The captain’s chair, elevated and humming with ship status displays
Borg Cube

The vast expanse of deep space serves as the battleground for the *Enterprise*’s pursuit of the Borg cube, a stark and isolating arena where the fate of the Federation hangs in the balance. The blurred starfields whipping past the ship amplify the urgency of the chase, the Borg’s relentless advance a looming threat to planetary assimilation. This location is not merely a backdrop but an active participant in the narrative, its emptiness a metaphor for the crew’s isolation and the existential stakes of their mission. The pursuit itself is a race against time, with the Borg cube’s path toward Earth symbolizing the encroaching doom that the *Enterprise* must intercept at all costs.

Atmosphere A sense of cosmic isolation and urgency, with the blurred starfields and the Borg cube’s …
Function Battleground and pursuit zone, where the *Enterprise* races to intercept the Borg cube before it …
Symbolism Represents the frontier between order and chaos, civilization and annihilation. The emptiness of space mirrors …
Access Open to the *Enterprise* and the Borg cube, with no physical barriers but bound by …
Blurred starfields whipping past the *Enterprise*’s hull, amplifying the urgency of the chase The Borg cube’s angular, menacing silhouette dominating the viewscreen The vast, empty expanse of deep space, a metaphor for isolation and existential stakes The hum of the *Enterprise*’s engines, a constant reminder of the ship’s pursuit The looming threat of the Borg’s path toward Earth, a visual representation of the crew’s race against time

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

3
Starfleet

Starfleet is the operational arm of the Federation, tasked with defending its citizens and upholding its values. In this event, Starfleet’s role is embodied by the *Enterprise*’s crew, who execute the organization’s directives with precision and urgency. The crew’s actions—from Riker’s command decisions to Geordi’s technical efforts—are a direct extension of Starfleet’s mission to counter the Borg threat. The organization’s protocols and resources are leveraged to their fullest, with the crew acting as the vanguard of Starfleet’s resistance.

Representation Through the *Enterprise*’s crew, who operate as Starfleet officers in the field. Their actions are …
Power Dynamics Starfleet is the primary force arrayed against the Borg, its power derived from the expertise, …
Impact The success or failure of this event will have profound implications for Starfleet’s reputation and …
Internal Dynamics The event highlights the tension between individual initiative and institutional hierarchy, as Riker struggles with …
To intercept and neutralize the Borg cube before it reaches Federation space To rescue Captain Picard and prevent his assimilation into the Borg Collective Through the *Enterprise*’s crew, who act as Starfleet’s proxies in the pursuit Via institutional protocols and strategic directives, which guide the crew’s response to the crisis By leveraging the resources and technology of Starfleet, including the *Enterprise*’s advanced systems and the deflector weapon
United Federation of Planets

The United Federation of Planets is the ultimate stakeholder in this event, its core worlds threatened by the Borg’s relentless advance. The Federation’s values—freedom, self-determination, and the protection of its citizens—are directly challenged by the Borg’s assimilative ideology. The *Enterprise*’s pursuit of the Borg cube is not merely a military operation but a defense of the Federation’s very existence. The crew’s actions on the bridge are a microcosm of the larger struggle, with Riker’s leadership decisions reflecting the Federation’s commitment to unity and resilience in the face of existential threat.

Representation Through the *Enterprise*’s crew, who embody the Federation’s ideals and serve as its first line …
Power Dynamics The Federation is under direct threat from the Borg, its power and authority challenged by …
Impact The Federation’s survival is directly tied to the outcome of this event. A failure to …
Internal Dynamics The event highlights the tension between individual agency and institutional hierarchy, as Riker grapples with …
To intercept and neutralize the Borg threat before it reaches Federation space To uphold the principles of freedom and self-determination, even in the face of overwhelming odds Through the *Enterprise*’s crew, who act as the Federation’s proxies in the pursuit Via institutional protocols and strategic directives, which guide the crew’s response to the crisis By leveraging the resources and technology of Starfleet, the Federation’s military arm
The Borg

The Borg Collective is the antagonistic force in this event, its relentless advance toward Federation space a direct threat to the *Enterprise* and the crew. The Borg’s adaptability, assimilative ideology, and overwhelming power are on full display, as they seek to turn Picard into Locutus and use him to exploit Federation knowledge. The crew’s efforts to counter the Borg are a desperate attempt to halt their expansion, with the stakes of the pursuit reflecting the existential nature of the conflict. The Borg’s presence looms large over the event, a constant reminder of the crew’s vulnerability and the magnitude of the threat they face.

Representation Through the Borg cube, which serves as the physical manifestation of the Collective’s will. The …
Power Dynamics The Borg Collective holds the upper hand in this event, its power derived from its …
Impact The Borg Collective’s actions in this event have far-reaching implications for the Federation and Starfleet. …
Internal Dynamics The Borg Collective operates as a unified, hive-minded entity, with no internal conflicts or hierarchies. …
To assimilate Captain Picard and turn him into Locutus, exploiting his knowledge to facilitate the invasion of Earth To overwhelm the *Enterprise* and its crew, adapting to their countermeasures and neutralizing their resistance Through the Borg cube, which serves as the primary instrument of the Collective’s will Via adaptive technology, which allows the Borg to counter the *Enterprise*’s tactics in real-time By leveraging the assimilated knowledge of captured individuals, such as Picard, to exploit Federation vulnerabilities

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph


Key Dialogue

"WORF: *They're leading us into the heart of our own defenses...* GEORDI: *So far, they haven't had any reason to worry about our defenses...*"
"RIKER: *I'm leading an away team over there to get the captain back.* TROI: *Commander Riker... It is inappropriate for you to lead the away team. Until the return of Captain Picard, you are in command of the Enterprise. We are in a state of war. Your place is on the bridge.* RIKER: *Commander Shelby, you will lead the away team.*"
"RIKER (V.O.): *First officer's log, supplemental. Our pursuit of the Borg continues at high warp on a course that will take us to the very core of the Federation. The devastation they could bring is beyond imagination.*"