S3E14
· A Matter of Perspective Flashback

Krag Freezes the Holodeck—Violence Recast as Evidence

During a holodeck recreation of Apgar's discovery, Apgar bursts in on Riker and Manua in a passionate embrace, attacks Riker and is physically overmatched. As Riker snarls a murderous threat, Investigator Krag abruptly freezes the program and frames the moment as part of a curated evidentiary sequence, then orders the next testimony. The freeze reframes a chaotic, ambiguous struggle into a deliberate chain of holographic ‘facts,’ escalating Picard’s dilemma about manipulated proof and procedural inevitability.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

1

Krag freezes the program and transitions to the next simulation, systematically building his case.

fury to procedural calm

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

4

Coldly authoritative and instrumental — focused on building a legally persuasive record rather than empathizing with the participants.

Krag intervenes off‑screen by commanding the holodeck to freeze, then narrates the frozen tableau as evidence and orders the next reconstruction, treating the human mess as curated proof rather than a private catastrophe.

Goals in this moment
  • Secure and present an incontrovertible evidentiary timeline to support extradition/charge.
  • Control the narrative by freezing and sequencing reconstructions to favor the prosecution's interpretation.
  • Prevent the Enterprise from reframing or undermining the Tanugan case.
Active beliefs
  • He believes holodeck reconstructions can be used as reliable, persuasive evidence in his jurisdiction.
  • He believes procedural control and curated presentation will overcome ambiguity and force a legal outcome.
  • He believes the appearance of impartiality and strict procedure strengthens his case externally, even if it obscures nuance.
Character traits
clinical procedural controlling detached
Follow Krag's journey

Mortified and frightened — sudden exposure of intimacy produces shame and alarm rather than aggression.

Manua is discovered in a passionate embrace with Riker; she is startled and embarrassed by Apgar's entrance and does not physically fight, remaining a focal but largely passive presence during the confrontation.

Goals in this moment
  • End the confrontation quickly and minimize public scandal.
  • Protect herself and Riker from escalation or formal consequences.
  • Restore privacy and cover up the indiscretion.
Active beliefs
  • She believed the moment would remain private and now feels betrayed by its violation.
  • She believes calming or withdrawing will limit harm more than escalating the conflict.
  • She believes her social position and relationships depend on keeping this liaison hidden.
Character traits
sensual vulnerable shocked private
Follow Manua Apgar's journey

Righteously enraged and vindictive — anger over betrayal fused with a need to reassert dignity through action rather than words.

Apgar bursts through the door, confronts Riker and Manua, avoids Riker's wild punch, then retaliates with a fast, focused flurry of punches that floors Riker and declares he will report the affair.

Goals in this moment
  • Expose and stop the affair immediately by confronting the participants.
  • Ensure institutional or formal consequences by threatening to report the incident.
  • Physically protect his self‑respect and prevent further humiliation.
Active beliefs
  • He believes he has been deceived and is entitled to immediate retribution.
  • He believes formal reporting will restore justice or at least punish the offenders.
  • He believes that decisive, physical action will assert his authority and make his claim credible.
Character traits
explosive confrontational physically decisive morally righteous (self‑justifying)
Follow Nel Apgar's journey

Defensive, furious, and possessive — anger that resorts to intimidation when surprised and threatened with exposure.

Caught mid‑embrace, Riker reacts instinctively with a wild, defensive punch, is then overwhelmed and knocked to the floor by Apgar's counterattack, and spits a murderous threat while struggling on the ground.

Goals in this moment
  • Neutralize Apgar immediately to protect himself and Manua.
  • Intimidate or silence the accuser to prevent reporting or scandal.
  • Preserve the secret and avoid repercussions.
Active beliefs
  • He believes force or threat will deter Apgar from pressing the issue.
  • He believes the private encounter must remain secret to protect his status and relationships.
  • He believes he can physically control the situation even when surprised.
Character traits
passionate reactive physically imposing prideful
Follow William Riker's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

3
Holodeck Investigative Reconstruction (Data's 18‑Hour Casefile — Manua assault reconstruction)

The holodeck investigative reconstruction runs this guest‑quarters scene and is the instrument that Krag freezes. It converts lived action into stoppable, narratable evidence — allowing Krag to suspend time and impose an interpretation on chaotic behavior.

Before: Active and rendering the reconstructed guest‑quarters encounter (running …
After: Program paused/frozen mid‑action under Krag's command, awaiting narration …
Before: Active and rendering the reconstructed guest‑quarters encounter (running through a recorded flashback sequence).
After: Program paused/frozen mid‑action under Krag's command, awaiting narration and sequencing of additional simulations.
Holodeck Two Entry/Exit Hatch

The holodeck doors physically mark the moment of discovery — their opening allows Apgar's abrupt entrance that catalyzes the entire confrontation. The door functions as both literal threshold and dramaturgical trigger for the violent exchange.

Before: Closed/just opening; seam glowing from use as the …
After: Left open following Apgar's entry; remains as part …
Before: Closed/just opening; seam glowing from use as the simulation transitions into the guest‑quarters scene.
After: Left open following Apgar's entry; remains as part of the frozen tableau when Krag halts the program.
Tayna Simulation Four (Holodeck Reconstruction)

Tayna Simulation Four is invoked verbally by Krag as the next evidentiary sequence; it is positioned as the follow‑up testimony intended to corroborate or extend the frozen frame's narrative, transforming the confrontation into a multi‑part prosecutorial mosaic.

Before: Queued and inactive — prepared as one of …
After: Commanded to run next — placed into active …
Before: Queued and inactive — prepared as one of several staged reconstructions in the case file.
After: Commanded to run next — placed into active queue to be executed once the current frozen frame is closed out.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Holodeck — Space Station Guest Quarters (Space Station Simulation)

The holodeck's Space Station Guest Quarters simulates an intimate private room where the affair and subsequent confrontation are replayed; it serves as the staged site where private passion collides with public procedure and where human nuance is frozen into evidentiary tableau.

Atmosphere From warm, intimate and sensual to suddenly charged and violent — the mood flips from …
Function Battleground and evidentiary stage: a private refuge turned forensic exhibit.
Symbolism Symbolizes the fragility of privacy under institutional scrutiny and how intimacy can be weaponized into …
Access Simulated private quarters in a holodeck — not a real residence; access controlled by holodeck …
Warm lamplight and sensual physicality (dress off, passionate kiss) that emphasize intimacy. The sudden hardware sound of the door opening and physical sounds of punches and a body hitting the floor. The instantaneous silence of the program freeze that converts motion into still evidence.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph


Key Dialogue

"APGAR: "I knew I'd find the two of you together. Do you think I didn't notice how you were looking at each other? I'm not the fool you take me for...""
"RIKER: "You're a dead man, Apgar. A dead man.""
"KRAG (O.S.): "Freeze program.""