S1E10
· The Battle

Revealing the Picard Maneuver’s Threat and Tactical Countermeasure

On the Enterprise bridge, the crew grapples with the psychological torment afflicting Picard and Riker, both reliving the traumatic Battle of Maxia. Counselor Troi perceives their rising anger and frustration, anchoring the emotional stakes in past trauma. Beverly probes the nature of the Picard Maneuver—a legendary starship tactic identified by Riker but deemed undefendable by Data. Under immense pressure, Data is tasked to devise a defense against an otherwise unstoppable threat. The crew’s focus intensifies as the Stargazer ominously approaches, while a Ferengi message reveals internal conflict aboard their vessel, signaling a shift in the adversary’s command. Data proposes a novel solution: using the tractor beam to seize the Stargazer by detecting its environmental disturbances rather than directly attacking. This event crystallizes the dual challenge—overcoming Picard’s mental imprisonment and countering the tangible tactical threat—setting the stage for an inventive and high-stakes resolution.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

2

Troi senses mounting anger and frustration in Picard and Riker, triggered by the reliving of the Battle of Maxia, setting the emotional stakes on edge.

uncertainty to rising tension ['Main Bridge of the Enterprise']

The crew identifies the psychological trigger as the infamous 'Picard Maneuver' from the Battle of Maxia, and Beverly asks for details, which Riker presses Data to explain, underscoring the tactical threat they face.

curiosity to urgency ['Main Bridge of the Enterprise']

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

6

Determined and composed, confident in his analytical solution despite the challenge.

Data, calm yet determined, analyzes the impossibility of defending against the Picard Maneuver and then innovatively proposes using the tractor beam aimed at trace gases disturbed by the maneuver to seize the Stargazer, demonstrating his logical prowess under pressure.

Goals in this moment
  • To devise a novel solution countering the Picard Maneuver
  • To support the crew tactically and safeguard the Enterprise
Active beliefs
  • All problems have a logical solution if properly analyzed
  • Innovative use of technology can overcome seemingly impossible threats
Character traits
logical focused innovative resolute
Follow Data's journey

Urgent and slightly exasperated, pressured by the immediacy of the threat and tactical uncertainty.

Commander Riker exhibits urgency and frustration, commanding Data to find a defense against the Picard Maneuver while attempting to manage the escalating tactical threat and responding brusquely to Kazago's untimely communication.

Goals in this moment
  • To find a practical defense against the Picard Maneuver
  • To maintain command presence and control over the unfolding crisis
Active beliefs
  • Innovative tactical solutions are required to counter unusual threats
  • Distractions must be minimized to focus on critical decisions
Character traits
decisive impatient authoritative strategic
Follow William Riker's journey

Inquisitive and slightly anxious, driven by a desire to understand and mitigate the crisis.

Dr. Beverly Crusher, curious and concerned, questions the nature of the Picard Maneuver, seeking clarity about the legendary tactic that now threatens them, reflecting her scientific rigor and emotional investment.

Goals in this moment
  • To comprehend the tactical threat posed by the Picard Maneuver
  • To support the crew's strategic planning with medical and contextual insight
Active beliefs
  • Understanding is key to effective response
  • Medical knowledge can inform tactical decisions
Character traits
curious concerned intelligent supportive
Follow Beverly Crusher's journey

Concerned yet composed, emotionally attuned to the captain and first officer's distress.

Counselor Troi perceptively senses the emotional turmoil gripping Captain Picard and Commander Riker, vocalizing her empathic detection of their anger and frustration as the psychological weight of past trauma resurfaces.

Goals in this moment
  • To alert the crew to the psychological strain affecting leadership
  • To provide emotional insight that aids in managing the captain's mental state
Active beliefs
  • Emotional states can be sensed and understood despite being hidden
  • Awareness of psychological trauma is crucial to crew cohesion and mission success
Character traits
empathetic perceptive calm supportive
Follow Deanna Troi's journey

Steadily focused, engaged with the tactical and emotional stakes.

Geordi La Forge identifies the traumatic Battle of Maxia as the source of Picard and Riker's distress, providing critical context to the mental strain experienced during the crisis.

Goals in this moment
  • To clarify the origin of the captain and first officer's psychological turmoil
  • To support the bridge crew with accurate situational awareness
Active beliefs
  • Understanding past trauma is necessary to address current challenges
  • Clear communication enhances operational effectiveness under pressure
Character traits
focused analytical supportive pragmatic
Follow Geordi La …'s journey

Calm and professional, maintaining composure while delivering critical intelligence.

Kazago, via video link on the Main Viewer, delivers a businesslike and detached report to Riker, informing him of DaiMon Bok's confinement and the internal power shift aboard the Ferengi vessel, signaling a fracture in their command.

Goals in this moment
  • To communicate the Ferengi internal command change to the Enterprise
  • To distance himself and his faction from the escalating Federation conflict
Active beliefs
  • The current conflict is unprofitable and undesirable
  • Clear communication of internal dynamics affects diplomatic and tactical postures
Character traits
businesslike detached informative pragmatic
Follow Kazago's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

3
Enterprise Bridge Main Viewer

The Main Viewer serves as the communication and observation interface on the Enterprise bridge, displaying the Stargazer approaching, then switching to show Kazago on the Ferengi bridge, facilitating tension-filled diplomatic exchange and situational awareness.

Before: Displaying the Stargazer starship image as it approaches …
After: Switching between Stargazer visuals and Kazago's video transmission, …
Before: Displaying the Stargazer starship image as it approaches the Enterprise.
After: Switching between Stargazer visuals and Kazago's video transmission, maintaining command focus.
Picard Maneuver

The Picard Maneuver is referenced repeatedly as the legendary, nearly undefendable starship tactic that the crew must confront and counter. It embodies the tactical threat posed by the approaching Stargazer and triggers both psychological trauma and urgent strategic responses.

Before: Known as a legendary, devastating starship tactic without …
After: Reframed as a tactical problem demanding innovative countermeasures …
Before: Known as a legendary, devastating starship tactic without an established defense.
After: Reframed as a tactical problem demanding innovative countermeasures from the Enterprise crew.
Enterprise Tractor Beam Emitter (Bridge/Engineering Projector)

The miniature tractor beam is proposed by Data as the key tactical tool, newly tasked to lock onto trace gases compressed by the Picard Maneuver, enabling the Enterprise to seize the moving Stargazer instead of attacking directly, representing a shift in defensive strategy.

Before: Operational, standard defensive equipment aboard the Enterprise but …
After: Set as the primary means to counter the …
Before: Operational, standard defensive equipment aboard the Enterprise but not yet deployed against this threat.
After: Set as the primary means to counter the Picard Maneuver by targeting environmental disturbances rather than the vessel itself.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph


Key Dialogue

"TROI: I can now feel anger from our captain, first officer. Frustration over whatever he is re-living..."
"RIKER: The Picard Maneuver! Mister Data, what is the defense against that?"
"DATA: There is no defense, sir."
"RIKER: Then devise one! Fast!"
"DATA: Aim our tractor beam at it, sir! Seize it! This class starship has enough power for that."
"RIKER: In our captain's words... make it so! Set sensors, tractor beam..."