Fabula
S2E7 · Unnatural Selection

The Heart's Fatal Oversight

Dr. Mandel's world collapses as Pulaski's diagnosis reveals their gravest mistake—their protective instincts for the genetically engineered children created a biological weapon now attacking the Enterprise crew. As Mandel reels from the revelation that compassion bred catastrophe, Pulaski's withered hand on her shoulder conveys both professional kinship and the physical cost of their failure. This moment crystallizes the episode's central tension between scientific ambition and ethical responsibility, transforming a medical discovery into a moral reckoning.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

1

Mandel reels, stunned and guilty, lamenting that protective instincts produced a catastrophic oversight; Pulaski closes the moment with a withered hand on Mandel's shoulder, turning intellectual guilt into a raw, intimate reckoning.

shock to sorrow/connection

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

3

Unaware of their biological impact (inferred)

Present only through reference and Mandel's devastated gaze, their very existence serves as the catastrophic mirror reflecting scientific hubris. Their chess game continues obliviously as living proof of good intentions weaponized.

Goals in this moment
  • Continue their engineered existence (inferred)
  • Maintain developmental progress (inferred)
Active beliefs
  • Their environment remains secure (inferred)
  • Their abilities are positive traits (inferred)
Character traits
Biologically dangerous Unwittingly destructive Observed as scientific failure
Follow Children's journey

Professionally devastated with dawning personal culpability

Mandel transitions from initial confusion through scientific recognition to existential crisis, her body language collapsing as she traces the chess players with her gaze - the tangible symbols of her catastrophic ethical miscalculation.

Goals in this moment
  • Seek scientific absolution through explanation
  • Protect the children from further consequences
Active beliefs
  • Their good intentions should mitigate ethical judgment
  • The children remain fundamentally innocent despite biological danger
Character traits
Defensive rationality Protective instinct Scientific guilt Existential shock
Follow Dr. Sara …'s journey

Professionally resolved but personally affected

Pulaski delivers medically definitive bad news while physically deteriorating, her scientific severity tempered by the severity of her own visible condition. She physically connects with Mandel through her withered hand, transforming diagnostic certainty into shared grief.

Goals in this moment
  • Force Mandel to confront scientific reality
  • Establish diagnostic certainty through shared professional understanding
Active beliefs
  • Uncompromising medical truth is necessary regardless of pain
  • Their scientific community must own this failure collectively
Character traits
Clinical precision Unflinching directness Compartmentalized empathy Physical vulnerability
Follow Katherine Pulaski's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

2
Pulaski's Withered Hand

Pulaski's visibly deteriorated hand serves as both scientific evidence and emotional bridge - its paper-thin skin and weakened musculature demonstrate the virus's effects while its placement on Mandel's shoulder transforms physical proof into professional solidarity in failure.

Before: Displaying advanced aging symptoms
After: Employed as symbol of shared consequence
Before: Displaying advanced aging symptoms
After: Employed as symbol of shared consequence
Thelusian Flu Virus

The revealed biological mechanism by which the genetically engineered children's hyper-aggressive immune systems transformed a routine virus into a lethal rapid-aging weapon. Its identification serves as both diagnostic breakthrough and moral indictment.

Before: Present but undiagnosed in Enterprise crew
After: Confirmed as weaponized biological threat
Before: Present but undiagnosed in Enterprise crew
After: Confirmed as weaponized biological threat

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Isolation Chamber - Observation Area

The sterile observation area becomes an impromptu confessional where scientific certainty meets ethical reckoning. Its clinical surfaces amplify the moral weight as diagnostic truth echoes off surfaces designed for objective analysis.

Atmosphere Oppressively sterile with tension reverberating
Function Space for scientific confrontation
Symbolism Unforgiving mirror of scientific consequence
Access Limited to medical personnel (inferred)
Frosted observation windows creating clinical detachment Biometric displays documenting biological proof

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph


Part of Larger Arcs

Key Dialogue

"PULASKI: The first officer of the Lantree had Thelusian flu -- an airborne virus."
"MANDEL: We were so concerned about protecting them -- we overlooked the obvious! The one decision we made with our hearts... turns out to be a mistake."