Fabula
S3E14 · A Matter of Perspective

Frozen Simulation — Manua's Holo-Testimony of Assault

A programmed holographic reconstruction shows ‘Riker’ invading Manua’s private quarters: he closes the door, blocks her exit, makes invasive compliments, forces a garment over her shoulders and initiates unwanted contact while she pleads. Picard interrupts and freezes the program; the real Riker vehemently denies the actions, insisting the image is false, while Manua and Counselor Troi stand by the depiction as her deeply felt truth. This is a narrative turning point — the most incendiary evidence yet, dramatically escalating the legal and personal stakes and crystallizing the central evidentiary conflict Picard must resolve.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

4

Riker invades Manua's personal space, testing her discomfort while complimenting her sanctuary.

comfortable to uneasy ['guest quarters']

Manua deflects Riker's probing questions about her marriage with forced politeness.

uneasy to defensive

Riker physically blocks Manua's exit and insinuates her husband neglects her.

defensive to fearful

Riker makes unwanted physical contact as Manua pleads for him to stop.

fearful to panicked

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

5

Procedurally curious and insistent — he is emotionally restrained, driven by process rather than sympathy.

As Tanugan chief investigator, Krag watches the frozen tableau with professional detachment and, prioritizing evidentiary procedure, orders the program resumed to continue the demonstrative reconstruction.

Goals in this moment
  • To obtain incontrovertible visual evidence to support his extradition case
  • To preserve and exploit the holodeck reconstruction as admissible proof
  • To keep the investigation moving forward without being swayed by interpersonal dynamics
  • To challenge denials with demonstrable simulation
Active beliefs
  • That a frozen holoprogram is a reliable procedural artifact to demonstrate causality
  • That emotional protests from the accused are less relevant than the reconstruction
  • That his jurisdictional mandate compels him to gather and present clear proof
  • That resuming the program will clarify contested moments
Character traits
procedural detached insistent evidence-focused
Follow Krag's journey

Ashamed and pleading during the simulated assault; afterward steady, angry and wounded as she reaffirms the accuracy of the recreation.

Portrayed by the reconstruction as the victim, Manua pleads, resists and later, confronted by Riker's denial, calmly insists the depiction mirrors what happened — her testimony anchors the simulated evidence with emotional conviction.

Goals in this moment
  • To have her version of events accepted as truthful by investigators
  • To seek recognition and perhaps justice for the violation she describes
  • To protect her husband's memory and the factual record of what occurred
  • To resist intimidation or dismissal by the accused
Active beliefs
  • That the holodeck reconstruction accurately reflects her experience
  • That saying the truth is necessary even if it causes pain or scandal
  • That the investigators (and Picard) can use this depiction to find justice
  • That Riker's denials are defensive rather than honest
Character traits
vulnerable resolute emotionally candid defensive of memory
Follow Manua Apgar's journey

Controlled concern: visibly unsettled by the content but determined to preserve evidentiary procedure and fairness toward his officer.

Picard intervenes authoritatively: he interrupts the running reconstruction with the command 'Freeze program,' crosses into the holodeck space, inspects the frozen tableau, and mediates between the enraged Riker and the assembled witnesses while maintaining procedural control.

Goals in this moment
  • To maintain the integrity of the investigation and the holodeck evidence
  • To protect the ship's discipline and to avoid a summary rush to judgment
  • To give Riker an opportunity to respond without the program running
  • To ensure the investigative process remains under Starfleet standards
Active beliefs
  • That holodeck reconstructions are powerful investigative tools but must be handled carefully
  • That due process and command responsibility require him to intervene calmly
  • That his presence and authority can temper the emotional escalation
  • That the truth will emerge through controlled examination rather than immediate verdicts
Character traits
commanding measured procedural protective of crew
Follow Jean-Luc Picard's journey

Righteously indignant on the surface, tightly wound fear and humiliation underneath; angry at being misrepresented and desperate to protect reputation.

Two Rikers are in play: a holographic depiction commits the invasive acts while the real Commander Riker reacts in the present — rising, protesting, denying the actions, confronting Manua, and finally returning to the table as his composure frays.

Goals in this moment
  • To repudiate the holographic depiction and prevent it being taken as literal truth
  • To be believed by Picard and the investigators and preserve his career
  • To understand Manua's motive for testifying or permitting the reconstruction
  • To regain composure and avoid a procedural collapse under accusation
Active beliefs
  • That the holoprogram is an inaccurate or malicious reconstruction and does not reflect his real actions
  • That his honor, command eligibility, and relationships depend on disproving this depiction
  • That Picard and Starfleet process can be persuaded by direct denial and presence
  • That Manua or others may be misremembering or manipulating the record
Character traits
defensive indignant authoritative (real-world comportment) professorial pride
Follow William Riker's journey

Supportive and professionally anxious — she senses the emotional rupture and prioritizes stabilizing Riker and the room.

Troi moves quickly to Riker's side, attempts to calm and seat him, offers quiet, practical comfort and emotional regulation in the immediate fallout of the frozen reconstruction.

Goals in this moment
  • To calm Riker and prevent an uncontrolled reaction
  • To protect Riker emotionally while the investigation proceeds
  • To preserve the integrity of testimony by keeping tempers contained
  • To be a steadying presence for both accuser and accused
Active beliefs
  • That Riker is vulnerable under accusation and needs support
  • That emotional regulation will make it more likely fair process is followed
  • That her presence can influence how others perceive Riker's composure
  • That Manua's testimony should also be treated sensitively
Character traits
empathic supportive practical protective of crew morale
Follow Deanna Troi's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

5
Holodeck Control Panel

The wall-mounted environmental control pad is used in the reconstruction to close and seal the guest-room door, physically blocking Manua's exit; its activation is a key causal beat that the investigators highlight to show constrained agency and intimate proximity.

Before: Idle and mounted on the simulated guest-room wall, …
After: Depicted as activated in the reconstruction (chime and …
Before: Idle and mounted on the simulated guest-room wall, untouched in the running program.
After: Depicted as activated in the reconstruction (chime and door closing); within the frozen program its state is 'engaged' until the simulation resumes.
Alcove Small Table (Captive's Table)

A small alcove table functions as the neutral furniture anchor in the guest quarters; Riker returns to it after his denial, using it as a physical point to recompose, making it the stage for his defensive posture after the program is frozen.

Before: Placed against the wall in the simulated quarter, …
After: Occupied as Riker uses it to sit and …
Before: Placed against the wall in the simulated quarter, holding typical small items and idle.
After: Occupied as Riker uses it to sit and steady himself following the confrontation and denial.
Holodeck Investigative Reconstruction (Data's 18‑Hour Casefile — Manua assault reconstruction)

The Investigative Reconstruction holoprogram projects the Tanuga Four guest quarters at full scale and stages the disputed interaction; it renders a holographic 'Riker' performing the invasive acts and is frozen by Picard to serve as demonstrative evidence. Its operation and pause drive the room's emotional and procedural choreography.

Before: Running and actively rendering the simulated guest quarters …
After: Frozen on Picard's command, serving as a paused …
Before: Running and actively rendering the simulated guest quarters and characters as part of Data's compiled casefile.
After: Frozen on Picard's command, serving as a paused piece of evidence until Krag orders it resumed.
Holodeck Two Entry/Exit Hatch

The holodeck doors serve as the aperture that closes to turn a domestic space into a sealed scene; the closing seals the confrontation, making the room feel claustrophobic and evidencing an obstruction of escape in the reconstruction.

Before: Partly open as the holodeck simulation plays out …
After: Shown in the simulation as closed and sealed; …
Before: Partly open as the holodeck simulation plays out and occupants move in and out.
After: Shown in the simulation as closed and sealed; the frozen program preserves the door in closed state.
Manua Apgar's Shoulder Garment

The shoulder garment is the tactile prop slipped over Manua by the holographic 'Riker'; narratively it becomes the intimate, visible token of contact and the physical anchor for the assault allegation in the reconstruction.

Before: Present within the simulated quarters as a loose, …
After: Shown draped over Manua's shoulders in the frozen …
Before: Present within the simulated quarters as a loose, unremarkable garment, not being worn.
After: Shown draped over Manua's shoulders in the frozen tableau and thereafter functions as a pointed piece of evidentiary detail.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Tanuga Four Research Station

The Tanuga Four guest quarters (rendered by the holodeck) function as the intimate, claustrophobic stage for the alleged assault; its small scale, control panel and private door turn a domestic sanctuary into a sealed scene of accusation and memory, making the location itself an evidentiary battleground.

Atmosphere Tense, intimate and claustrophobic — a private space made accusatory by frozen motion and heavy …
Function Stage for private confrontation, physical barrier to escape, and focal site used by investigators to …
Symbolism Represents violated sanctuary: a private refuge converted into a crucible of truth-claims and evidence, symbolizing …
Access In the investigation context it's a contained simulated environment controlled by the holodeck; access is …
Small, cramped room dimensions emphasizing proximity between characters A wall-mounted environmental controls pad and a narrow holodeck door used to seal the room Low domestic lighting contrasted with the clinical pause of a frozen simulation Ambient chime and control sounds when the panel is engaged

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph


Key Dialogue

"PICARD: Freeze program"
"RIKER: This isn't me. I wasn't the one who closed the door... I didn't proposition her... I certainly didn't try to rape her... (turning to Manua) Why are you doing this?"
"MANUA: It's exactly what happened..."