Fabula
S2E9 · The Measure of a Man

Louvois' Return — Old Wounds Reopened

Picard's quiet meal on Starbase 173 is ruptured when Phillipa Louvois, now in uniform and radiating professional control, appears unexpectedly. Their terse, barbed reunion immediately layers personal history over the looming legal battle: old grievances, flirtation turned rivalry, and a thinly veiled antagonism. Louvois' final quip — 'Ain't love wonderful' — lands as both provocation and emotional landmine, unsettling Picard and turning a simple encounter into a set-up that raises the personal stakes beneath the institutional conflict to come.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

7

The Enterprise docks and the high-tech restaurant frames Picard alone at a table; a solitary cup sits before him, projecting quiet routine and personal solitude.

neutral to quiet expectancy ['RESTAURANT', 'Starbase one-seven-three']

Picard's posture tightens as a poised WOMAN in a Starfleet uniform enters, her eyes lock on him and an ironic smile flickers—her presence ruptures the calm and announces a charged reunion.

calm to charged curiosity ['RESTAURANT']

Picard rises and closes the distance with a mordant greeting—he names her Phillipa Louvois, stunned that she's back in uniform, the words edged with their history.

surprise to restrained tension ['passway']

Phillipa snaps back with dry, personal barbs—her retort reframes the reunion as antagonism rather than affection, sharpening the emotional undercurrent between them.

mild amusement to clipped antagonism ['RESTAURANT']

Picard deliberately leans into the old friction—he frames their exchange as 'picking up the threads of old fights,' signaling that their relationship carries unresolved history and mutual provocation.

wryness to nostalgia-tinged tension ['RESTAURANT']

Phillipa delivers a mordant, playful closing line—'Ain't love wonderful'—both defusing and puncturing the moment, leaving tension unresolved as the scene heads to fade.

biting amusement to ironic resignation ['RESTAURANT']

Textual stage direction signals the formal end of the teased confrontation—'FADE OUT' marks the scene's boundary and preserves the unresolved friction for the acts to follow.

sustained tension to narrative pause ['FADE OUT / scene boundary']

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

2

Controlled amusement masking purposeful provocation; she appears confident and slightly ironic, using charm as a strategic tool.

Phillipa enters poised and professional in uniform, scans the room until she locks eyes with Picard, offers an ironic smile, and deploys a deliberately teasing, slightly provocative line that reframes the meeting as both personal and institutional.

Goals in this moment
  • To unsettle Picard subtly and reclaim influence in their dynamic
  • To signal her return to formal Starfleet authority while keeping the encounter ambiguous
Active beliefs
  • Reintroducing personal history can be an effective lever in forthcoming institutional disputes
  • Maintaining professional composure amplifies the sting of personal barbs
Character traits
poised teasingly antagonistic professionally composed intentional
Follow Phillipa Louvois's journey

Surface composure with an undercurrent of surprise and guarded vulnerability; an officer switching instantly from private repose to controlled formality.

Picard sits alone, cradling a private meal, then straightens and rises when he recognizes Phillipa; he approaches with a thin edge in his voice and trades barbed, familiar lines that conceal a deeper unsettlement.

Goals in this moment
  • To manage the encounter with decorum and emotional control
  • To test Phillipa's intentions and re-establish boundaries after an unexpected reunion
Active beliefs
  • Personal history with Phillipa matters and complicates professional interactions
  • Appearances and protocol must be maintained even when personal emotions are provoked
Character traits
guarded ceremonially formal wry internally conflicted
Follow Jean-Luc Picard's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

3
Captain Picard's Cup of Coffee

Picard's cup anchors the scene's intimacy and solitude; it visually marks his private moment and the abruptness of its rupture when Louvois arrives, underscoring the shift from quiet reflection to charged exchange.

Before: On the table before Picard, half-consumed, signifying a …
After: Remains on the table, unattended as Picard rises …
Before: On the table before Picard, half-consumed, signifying a solitary, leisurely meal.
After: Remains on the table, unattended as Picard rises to approach Phillipa; its role shifts from prop of comfort to emblem of interrupted solitude.
Phillipa Louvois' Starfleet Uniform

Phillipa's Starfleet uniform is a narrative object: it announces institutional authority, contrasts with their past intimacy, and sharpens her provocation. The uniform converts personal history into an encounter framed by rank and allegiance.

Before: Worn by Phillipa as she enters the restaurant, …
After: Remains worn and functions as an active signifier …
Before: Worn by Phillipa as she enters the restaurant, pristine and authoritative, immediately noticeable to Picard.
After: Remains worn and functions as an active signifier throughout the exchange, amplifying the duel between personal history and professional identity.
Table at Starbase 173 Restaurant

The table serves as the physical stage for Picard's solitary posture and the initial barrier between him and Phillipa; its small, public footprint converts a private dinner into a visible encounter that other patrons could witness, increasing the social pressure of the exchange.

Before: Set for a single diner: small, scuffed surface …
After: Still set but now part of the public …
Before: Set for a single diner: small, scuffed surface with a cup and place setting, marking Picard's solitary presence.
After: Still set but now part of the public tableau of confrontation as Picard leaves it to approach Phillipa, converting the table from refuge to visible stage.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Starbase 173

The Starbase 173 restaurant provides a publicly neutral, quietly high-tech setting where private and institutional worlds collide. It allows for a casual meal yet is implicitly monitored space, making the reunion both ordinary and liable to become an official matter.

Atmosphere Calm, low-key, quietly formal with the hum of Starbase activity in the background; intimacy laced …
Function Meeting point for an unplanned, charged reunion that shifts the scene from private reflection to …
Symbolism Represents the collision of Picard's private life with Starfleet's institutional world; a neutral surface where …
Access Open to public patrons of the starbase but implicitly monitored; not a restricted briefing room, …
High-tech restaurant design and muted lighting Distant mechanical thrum of docking rings creating an institutional backdrop Single place setting on a dark laminated table with a cup A passway/patron flow where Phillipa enters and approaches Picard

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph


Key Dialogue

"PICARD: My God, if it isn't Phillipa Louvois, back in uniform."
"PHILLIPA: Don't gloat, Picard. It's almost more irritating then when you're being self-righteous."
"PHILLIPA: Ain't love wonderful."