Fabula
Season 2 · Episode 7
S2E7
Ethical Dread
View Graph

Star Trek: The Next Generation - Unnatural Selection

When the Enterprise encounters a derelict ship with its crew aged to death, Captain Picard must race against time to stop a deadly genetic contagion while navigating tensions with his new chief medical officer.

The Enterprise investigates the USS Lantree, finding its crew rapidly aged to death. Tracing the ship's last stop to a genetic research station, they discover the outbreak stems from engineered children whose hyper-immune systems attack human DNA as foreign pathogens. Dr. Pulaski exposes herself to the contagion to study it, accelerating her own aging process. With the station quarantined, Picard must defy Starfleet protocols and harness unproven transporter technology to filter out the genetic alterations and save Pulaski. The crisis forces the crew to reconcile scientific ambition with ethical responsibility, while cementing Pulaski's place on the Enterprise through her self-sacrifice and Picard's risky leadership. Subplots explore workplace dynamics as Geordi mentors a brilliant but disruptive engineer and Riker's flirtations create professional complications. The resolution demonstrates the franchise's core themes of humanity's potential and perils when manipulating biology.


Events in This Episode

The narrative beats that drive the story

73
Act 0

The Enterprise glides through the void, but beneath the calm, unease stirs. Captain Picard, pacing his quarters, grapples with his new Chief Medical Officer, Dr. Pulaski, whose meticulous competence is undeniable, yet whose broader leadership capabilities remain untested. In Ten-Forward, Commander Riker, ever the flirt, attempts to charm the brilliant but reserved Specialist Trainee Rina, while Geordi La Forge, oblivious, finds common ground with her through their shared passion for engineering. Pulaski, meanwhile, asserts her authority, cornering Riker over a missed medical appointment, a subtle power play that hints at her unyielding nature. The tranquil ship is abruptly shattered by a distress signal, a garbled, desperate plea from the USS Lantree. Picard, instantly on alert, sounds emergency stations. Wesley Crusher, rubbing sleep from his eyes, races to Conn, while Pulaski reports Sickbay readiness. Data identifies the source: a Federation supply ship. The transmission repeats, a chilling echo of dying voices, then silence. Picard's worried expression tightens; the unknown threat looms large, setting a foreboding tone for the unfolding crisis.

Scene 2
Starship Dynamics: Flirtation and Professionalism Collide

In Ten-Forward, Specialist Trainee Rina's technical discourse on warp theory creates divergent reactions—Geordi engages with genuine engineering passion while Riker's flirtations land awkwardly. The scene establishes Rina's intellectual gravitas as …

Galaxy Beyond Ten-Forward Viewport 3 characters
Chemistry Check: Flirtation Versus Genuine Connection

Commander Riker escalates his flirtation with Specialist Trainee Rina by physically taking her empty glass and offering another drink, employing charming dominance. Rina counters with sharp wit about First Officer …

Galaxy Beyond Ten-Forward Viewport 3 characters
Shared Stars and Professional Bonds

Geordi La Forge shifts the dynamic with Specialist Trainee Rina by bonding over their shared reverence for engineering and Starfleet Academy experiences. While Riker's flirtatious advances continue to fall flat—highlighted …

Galaxy Beyond Ten-Forward Viewport 3 characters
Charm Meets Resistance in Ten-Forward

Commander Riker's flirtatious advances toward Specialist Trainee Rina take center stage in Ten-Forward, his performative charm clashing with her professional reserve. His effortless offer to fetch her drink masks a …

Galaxy Beyond Ten-Forward Viewport 3 characters
Pulaski's Unyielding Medical Mandate

Dr. Pulaski confronts Commander Riker in Ten-Forward over his missed medical exam, initially downplaying the Rheinman tissue sample as routine before escalating to a direct order with a veiled threat …

Galaxy Beyond Ten-Forward Viewport 3 characters
Flirtation and Professional Boundaries

In Ten-Forward, Riker engages in flirtatious banter with the new Specialist Trainee Rina, his charming advances met with her cool professional deflection. Meanwhile, Geordi and Rina share a genuine moment …

Galaxy Beyond Ten-Forward Viewport 3 characters
Act 1

The Enterprise closes on the silent USS Lantree, its last desperate transmission replaying a haunting loop. Picard's questions hang unanswered as Troi senses only immense stress. Data pinpoints the Lantree's location and confirms it's a supply ship, armed only defensively, yet still moving at maximum warp despite no life signs. The paradox tightens Picard's jaw: no battle damage, all systems functional, yet utterly devoid of life. A red alert screams through the bridge as Riker raises force fields and arms photon torpedoes, preparing for the worst. Picard makes the grim decision to board. In Engineering, Geordi readies the ship for a delicate maneuver, bringing the Enterprise alongside the Lantree. Riker, with a knowing glance at Rina, jokes about his expendability before beaming over. The away team – Riker, Data, Worf – materializes aboard the derelict Lantree, phasers drawn. The ship is a ghost, its corridors empty. Worf discovers the sickbay, a chilling tableau of death. Every bed holds a body, not victims of violence, but of time itself. Data's tricorder confirms the horrifying truth: the crew, once young, has aged hundreds of years in mere weeks. Captain Taleka, a man of thirty-two, is a withered, toothless husk. Riker, grim-faced, reports back to Picard: the entire crew lost a battle with time, a terrifying new enemy that has already claimed its first victims.

Scene 5
Quarantine Clash

The medical briefing on the Lantree crew's shocking demise—perfect health weeks prior contrasted with their current status as centuries-old corpses—reveals the true horror of the temporal anomaly. Pulaski's insistence that …

Observation Lounge (USS Enterprise-D) 6 characters
Medical Cold War

As Pulaski presents chilling autopsy findings of the perfectly healthy Lantree crew turned ancient corpses, the conference dissolves into tense medical brinkmanship. Troi's probe about Thelusian flu—dismissed by Pulaski as …

Observation Lounge (USS Enterprise-D) 6 characters
Quarantine Proclamation

Dr. Pulaski presents alarming autopsy findings revealing the Lantree crew suffered inexplicable rapid aging despite perfect health records weeks prior. Riker voices urgent safety concerns as Pulaski confirms the unknown …

Observation Lounge (USS Enterprise-D) 6 characters
Clash of Command and Conscience

The Enterprise senior staff grapples with the grim implications of the USS Lantree's rapid-aging catastrophe. Dr. Pulaski's medical report confirms the crew was healthy just weeks prior, deepening the mystery. …

Observation Lounge (USS Enterprise-D) 6 characters
Command Collides with Hippocratic Duty

The shocking autopsy results from the Lantree crew force an agonizing choice—ignore medical quarantine protocol or rush toward potential contamination. Dr. Pulaski digs in with scientific rigor while Picard weighs …

Observation Lounge (USS Enterprise-D) 6 characters
Act 2

Pulaski's autopsies on the Lantree crew yield a baffling conclusion: they died of natural causes, specifically, extreme old age. Picard, incredulous, demands an explanation for an entire crew dying simultaneously. Data's data confirms the crew's youth, deepening the mystery. In the conference lounge, Pulaski, dismissing a harmless flu, insists the contagion remains aboard the Lantree, prompting Picard to order its destruction. Worf executes the auto-destruct, the Lantree vanishing in a blinding flash, a somber end to the haunted vessel. Data identifies the Lantree's last stop: the Darwin Genetic Research Station on Gagarin Four. Pulaski urges a warning, but Picard, his jaw tight, considers quarantine. Their clash highlights their differing priorities: science versus safety. Meanwhile, in Engineering, Geordi mentors Rina, whose brilliance is evident but whose social awkwardness leads to a mishap, nearly damaging equipment. Geordi, recognizing her talent, challenges her attitude, forging a deeper professional bond. Arriving at Gagarin Four, the Enterprise hails Darwin Station. Dr. Mandel, haggard and visibly aged, warns them to stand off, revealing a similar outbreak. She pleads with Pulaski to save the station's "children," a new generation of genetically engineered super-specimens. Picard, prioritizing his crew's lives, refuses to risk them, but Pulaski, driven by scientific curiosity and a deep sense of medical duty, persuades him to bring two children aboard for examination, encased in stasis. The reveal of these "children" as physically mature, telepathic super-specimens leaves the crew stunned. Pulaski, awestruck, sees the future of humanity, while Picard, ever cautious, recognizes Mandel's dangerous vision of manipulating life.

Act 3

Pulaski, her scientific fervor ignited, presses Picard to free the Darwinian children from stasis, convinced their hyper-advanced immune systems make them impervious to disease. Picard, however, remains unyielding, demanding absolute proof of their harmlessness before risking his crew. Their clash intensifies, a battle of wills between scientific imperative and Starfleet's protective protocols. Troi, observing their heated exchanges, notes their striking similarities: two strong personalities, equally stubborn. Pulaski, undeterred, proposes a radical, self-sacrificing experiment: she will enter the containment field with the children, proving their safety by exposing herself. Geordi voices grave concerns about potential forcefield failure, but Pulaski's conviction burns bright. Picard, though deeply uneasy, acknowledges she has met his conditions for a test. Facing a rapidly aging Dr. Mandel on the viewscreen, Pulaski delivers the grim news of the Enterprise's refusal to evacuate the children, the weight of the decision pressing down on her. Desperate for a fail-safe environment, Pulaski consults Geordi and Rina, who suggest the shuttlecraft as the only truly independent, isolated space. With Picard's reluctant approval, Pulaski prepares for her perilous mission. Riker, attempting to intervene, finds himself summarily relieved of duty by Pulaski, who weaponizes his missed medical appointment to assert her authority, leaving him stunned and powerless. Data, with a quizzical shrug, follows Pulaski into the shuttle. The shuttle launches, drifting away from the Enterprise, a tiny vessel carrying a monumental gamble. Pulaski dissolves the children's styrolite containment, revealing them as curious, telepathic beings. As she begins her self-examination, a sudden, searing pain grips her joints. Alarm flashes across Data's face as Pulaski groans, the initial, terrifying symptoms of the rapid aging disease manifesting within her. The experiment, meant to prove safety, instead confirms the horrific danger, leaving Pulaski trapped and infected, a devastating personal cost for scientific truth.

Act 4

Trapped within the shuttle, Pulaski rapidly succumbs to the accelerated aging, her body betraying her with agonizing arthritic inflammation. She urgently demands the children's return to isolation, recognizing the profound danger they pose. Picard, witnessing her rapid decline, is horrified, his previous caution tragically vindicated. Pulaski, refusing to risk the Enterprise, declares herself under quarantine, separating herself from the ship and accepting her grim fate. She orders a delta-level decontamination of the Sickbay and shuttle bay, a stark testament to the contagion's virulence. Data, observing Pulaski's rapidly deteriorating state, notes her aging body but her unwavering spirit. Picard and Riker, grappling with the ethical dilemma, discuss the inviolability of the chain of command, even in the face of such a crisis. The crew, desperate to save Pulaski, brainstorm solutions. Rina, the brilliant trainee, proposes a revolutionary idea: using the transporter's 'trace' data to filter out the genetic alterations causing the aging. Geordi, impressed by her insight, vouches for her. The plan hinges on finding a pre-infection DNA sample of Pulaski, a seemingly impossible task as Picard learns her transporter trace was purged and she rarely used the device. Meanwhile, on Darwin Station, Pulaski, now significantly aged, confronts Dr. Mandel, who reveals the children's hyper-aggressive immune systems were engineered to genetically destroy any invading pathogen. Pulaski, with a flash of insight, realizes the truth: the children's immune systems are attacking human DNA itself, perceiving it as a foreign pathogen, particularly after exposure to the common Thelusian flu. Mandel is devastated, recognizing their scientific ambition created a biological weapon. Pulaski, her face now deeply wrinkled and hair white, broadcasts her 'final report' to the Enterprise, a poignant, almost defeated message, reinforcing the quarantine and seemingly accepting her end, leaving Picard reeling in despair.

Act 5

In the isolation lab, a visibly aged Pulaski bids a solemn farewell to Data, acknowledging his unwavering support. Data, with a heavy heart, beams back to the Enterprise, leaving Pulaski and Mandel to their seemingly inevitable fate. The shuttlecraft, carrying Pulaski, then explodes, a devastating act of self-sacrifice that plunges Picard into a maelstrom of grief and anger. But Picard, refusing to accept defeat, seizes on a desperate hope. Data, now safely aboard, confirms his immunity stems from his lack of genetic material, and clarifies the precise, subtle genetic transposition causing the rapid aging. Picard, energized by this new data, charges into Engineering, seeking Rina. He challenges her, asking if a pre-infection DNA sample could filter out the genetic alterations during transport. Rina, with newfound confidence, confirms it's absolutely possible. Picard, recognizing her genius, orders her to make it so. Riker and Data frantically search for Pulaski's original DNA, scouring her quarters, ultimately discovering a single blonde hair on her brush – a precious, life-saving sample. In the Transporter Room, Rina, Geordi, Riker, and Data make last-minute adjustments. Picard, taking personal command of the controls, prepares for the unprecedented, high-stakes transport, knowing that failure means Pulaski's final, irreversible dispersal. The first attempt shows Pulaski still aged, a terrifying moment of doubt, but then, with a final surge of energy, her form coalesces, restored to her youthful self. Pulaski, reborn, exchanges a look of profound admiration with Picard. Riker, ready to face his overdue medical exam, finds Pulaski, with a knowing smile, postponing it. The Rina/Geordi subplot concludes with a tender, romantic moment, cementing their connection. The Enterprise, with Pulaski safely aboard and the crisis averted, sets course for Star Station India, leaving Gagarin Four behind, the crew having faced humanity's potential and perils in manipulating biology, and Pulaski's place on the ship, and in Picard's esteem, firmly secured.