S1E3
Tragic
Based on Benoit Blanc
Written by Rian Johnson
View Graph

WAKE UP DEAD MAN

When a priest is framed for the murder of a polarizing Monsignor, he enlists the help of famed detective Benoit Blanc to unearth a conspiracy involving a hidden fortune, a dark secret, and a flock of wicked wolves.

Father Jud Duplenticy, a former boxer with a troubled past, is sent to a small parish in Chimney Rock to assist the controversial Monsignor Jefferson Wicks. Jud quickly finds himself at odds with Wicks's fiery sermons and manipulative methods, as Wicks attacks newcomers and drives people away, testing the tolerances and hardening his core followers by complicity. Jud attempts to offer balance, starting a prayer group, but fails when the flock sides with Wicks.

During Holy Week, the tension escalates. After Wicks punches Jud in the stomach, Jud prepares to fight back, but Wicks is always one step ahead. On Good Friday, Wicks is found dead in the church storage closet, a devil head knife in his back. Jud, who argued with Wicks, had possession of the murder weapon, and was alone with Wicks before his death, becomes the prime suspect. Desperate to clear his name, Jud seeks the help of renowned detective Benoit Blanc, who arrives to solve the impossible locked-room mystery and quickly determines he is dealing with the theatrical.

Blanc begins investigating the members of Wicks's inner circle of congregants: Vera Draven, a lawyer, and her adopted son Cy; Doctor Nat Sharp, reeling from his wife leaving him; Lee Ross, a washed-up science fiction author, and Simone Vivane, a new-age cellist seeking healing. Blanc employs his deductive methods, examining the crime scene, murder weapon, and interviewing the suspects. He learns that Wicks planned to close the church and had tormented each member of his flock, creating multiple motives for murder. The investigation takes a turn towards the bizarre when the townspeople claim Wicks is risen.

As the investigation continues, Jud is shown in flashbacks to have had his own secret: spiking Wicks's flask with tranquilizers. When the flask goes missing, and Blanc declares that he can't solve the case, Jud tries to confess being party to the events that led to Wicks's death. However, in a surprise turnaround, Blanc reveals that there was a partner to the events that took his life. He identifies Dr Nat as the killer of the late Monsignor. Before the police can make the arrest, Dr Nat goes into hiding and it is revealed a second body has surfaced. Now the chase focuses on Dr Nat when it becomes apparent another member of the inner flock has helped him with the events that took place.

As it turns out it was Martha! Marth explains that she wanted to use Dr Nat to kill Wick and make it seem there was a message sent from Satan himself. Wick's would remain in history the holy priest that was sent to die by the hands of the wicked but she never accounted for all the events. After helping in the murder of Week's, Dr Nat went on to take the jewelry the Priest kept on himself for 80 years and he was discovered. A conflict ensues and ultimately Wick's ends up poisoning and killing Dr Nat. As Martha explains that her plan had gone sour, she kills her self explaining her sins to father jud in her dying breath.

The case concludes with Jud absolving Martha as she dies. Jud becomes the new priest in town, but struggles with the weight of the events and his own past. Later, a new couple enters Our Lady of Perpetual Grace and Father Jud welcomes them in.


Events in This Episode

The narrative beats that drive the story

275
Act 1

The narrative introduces Jud Duplenticy, a priest with a troubled past as a boxer, sent to Chimney Rock after an incident involving a physical altercation with a Deacon. He arrives at Our Lady of Perpetual Fortitude, a church with a dark history, to assist the manipulative Monsignor Jefferson Wicks. Jud quickly finds himself at odds with Wicks's fiery sermons and methods, which involve attacking newcomers and hardening his core followers through complicity. Martha Delacroix, Wicks's severe assistant, recounts the church's founding by Prentice, Wicks's grandfather, and the legend of the “harlot whore,” Grace, and the lost family fortune, “Eve’s Apple,” establishing a deep-seated mystery and potential motives. Jud meets the core flock members—Vera Draven, Cy Draven, Doctor Nat Sharp, Lee Ross, and Simone Vivane—each with their own struggles and reasons for loyalty to Wicks. Jud attempts to offer a counterbalance by starting a prayer group, but the flock, fearful of Wicks, rejects his efforts, demonstrating Wicks's powerful control. The tension escalates during Holy Week. On Palm Sunday, Jud confronts Wicks, exposing his physical impotence and criticizing his destructive leadership. Wicks retaliates by punching Jud and later holding a meeting where he turns the flock against Jud, declaring open war. On Good Friday, Wicks is found dead in the church storage closet, impaled by a devil head knife. Jud, who had argued with Wicks and possessed a similar devil head ornament, becomes the prime suspect. Renowned detective Benoit Blanc arrives, immediately sensing the theatricality of the impossible locked-room mystery and initiating his investigation.

Act 2

Blanc's investigation into Wicks's murder begins, focusing on the impossible locked-room mystery. He examines the crime scene, the murder weapon (the devil head knife), and interviews the flock, quickly noting their connection to a book club focused on "locked door" mysteries. Samson's VCR recording of a baseball game reveals a burst of RF interference at the exact moment of Wicks's collapse, suggesting a remote trigger, but Wicks was already on the ground, seemingly dead. Blanc, appearing stumped, pushes Jud to write his account of the events leading up to the murder. Jud's narrative reveals his own secret: he spiked Wicks's flask with tranquilizers and, after the murder, hid the flask to protect Wicks's image, inadvertently becoming an accomplice. The flask's subsequent disappearance raises new questions and implicates a deeper plot. The mystery deepens further when the crypt is found open and Wicks's body is missing, leading to townspeople claiming he has risen from the dead. Later, a figure resembling Wicks emerges from the crypt, tackling Samson. Jud intervenes, and when he regains consciousness, he finds Samson dead with a sickle in his chest, believing he committed the murder. Jud flees, tormented by guilt. Blanc, however, discovers Doctor Nat Sharp and Wicks's bodies in Nat's basement, Wicks's body partially dissolved in acid, and Nat wearing his wedding ring, confirming Nat as Wicks's killer. Jud, still believing he killed Samson, prepares to confess. Blanc, in a public display, declares he "cannot solve this case," a calculated move designed to elicit a confession from the true mastermind, setting the stage for the final revelations.

Act 3

Moved by Blanc's strategic display of "grace," Martha Delacroix confesses to Jud, revealing the intricate conspiracy. She admits her lifelong secret: Prentice, Wicks's grandfather, swallowed a massive diamond, "Eve's Apple," before his death, to keep it from his "harlot whore" daughter, Grace. Martha, who witnessed this, harbored a deep hatred for Grace and dedicated her life to protecting the church and Prentice's secret. When she learned Wicks intended to open the crypt and retrieve the diamond for his own greedy ambitions with Cy, she devised a plan. Martha conspired with Doctor Nat Sharp, a desperate man, to stage Wicks's death as a holy miracle, retrieve the diamond, and frame Jud. She planted the tranquilized flask and the rigged devil head on Wicks. Samson, who loved Martha, was to retrieve the diamond from Prentice's coffin within the crypt. However, the plan unravelled due to Jud's unexpected presence and Nat's overwhelming greed. Nat, tempted by "Eve's Apple," killed Samson to secure the diamond and framed Jud. Martha, realizing Nat's betrayal and the corruption of her "miracle," poisoned Nat with pentobarbital, ensuring he would die and the crime scene would tell a story of divine vengeance. In her final act, Martha reveals she also ingested the poison. She confesses her sins, including her lifelong hatred for Grace, and receives absolution from Jud before dying in his arms. The diamond, "Eve's Apple," falls from her hand, unseen by Geraldine. The narrative concludes one year later, with the church, now "Our Lady of Perpetual Grace," reopened under Father Jud's leadership. The diamond is subtly hidden within the new crucifix Jud carved, symbolizing his transformation and the enduring presence of both sin and grace. The remaining flock members have scattered, some finding their own versions of "miracles" or new paths, while Cy remains obsessed with the lost fortune.