TARDIS Malfunction and Susan’s Collapse
Plot Beats
The narrative micro-steps within this event
Barbara awakens in the darkened TARDIS to find the Doctor injured, Ian disoriented, and Susan dazed, all suffering from memory loss and confusion. Initial concern shifts to alarm as they struggle to understand their condition and surroundings.
As Susan attempts to fetch water to tend to the Doctor's wound, she experiences a sharp pain and briefly loses recognition of Ian. The discovery that the liquid dispenser is empty adds to the growing sense of unease.
Who Was There
Characters present in this moment
Feigned calm masking deep anxiety; determined to maintain order amid chaos, but increasingly unsettled by the irrational.
Barbara is the first to regain consciousness and takes immediate charge, assessing Susan’s disorientation and neck pain with pragmatic urgency. She directs Susan to fetch water and bandages for the Doctor’s head wound, her voice steady despite the chaos. When Susan collapses after touching the console, Barbara’s concern deepens, and she insists on examining the Doctor’s injury, only to find no visible wound—heightening the mystery. Her attempts to rationalize the TARDIS’s malfunction ('The doors must have been forced open when we crashed') reveal her growing anxiety, as she struggles to reconcile the irrational with her need for control. She remains the emotional anchor of the group, though her own fear is palpable beneath her composed exterior.
- • Assess and stabilize the crew’s physical and mental states, prioritizing medical care for the Doctor and Susan.
- • Rationalize the TARDIS’s malfunction to alleviate paranoia, even as the evidence defies logic.
- • The TARDIS’s malfunction must have a logical, mechanical explanation, despite the mounting evidence of something supernatural.
- • Her role as the group’s emotional and practical anchor is critical to their survival, even if she is as frightened as the others.
Dizzy and cautious, transitioning from skepticism to unease as the TARDIS’s behavior defies explanation. His pragmatic nature is tested, but he remains focused on practical solutions, even as the threat becomes clearer.
Ian recovers from dizziness and immediately assesses the Doctor’s condition, his pragmatic nature kicking in despite his own disorientation. He helps Barbara tend to Susan and investigates the TARDIS doors, which open and close erratically. His attempt to approach the doors is met with them slamming shut in his face, a clear sign that the TARDIS is not behaving normally. He carries Susan away after her collapse, his actions driven by a mix of caution and concern. His dialogue reveals his skepticism ('Perhaps he did it') but also his growing unease as the irrational becomes undeniable. He serves as the voice of reason, even as the situation defies logic.
- • Determine the cause of the TARDIS’s malfunction through logical deduction, even as the evidence suggests something beyond mechanics.
- • Protect the crew, particularly Susan, from both the physical dangers of the malfunction and the psychological toll of the unknown.
- • The TARDIS’s malfunction must have a mechanical explanation, though the evidence is mounting against this belief.
- • His role as the group’s skeptic is important, as it balances the growing paranoia and fear of the others.
Delirious and distressed, oscillating between confusion and a sense of impending doom. His vulnerability is palpable, and his usual brusque demeanor is replaced by a fragile, almost childlike state.
The Doctor regains consciousness injured and delirious, muttering incoherently about 'not being able to take Susan back.' His physical vulnerability—both the head wound and the neck pain—contrasts sharply with his usual authority. He is disoriented, his speech fragmented, and his ability to lead compromised. Barbara’s examination reveals no visible wound, suggesting the injury may be psychological or supernatural in nature. His mutterings hint at a deeper conflict, possibly tied to Susan’s presence on the TARDIS, but his delirium prevents clear communication. His role as the group’s protector is undermined, leaving the crew to navigate the crisis without his guidance.
- • Regain enough clarity to communicate the threat to the crew, despite his physical and mental state.
- • Protect Susan, even if he cannot articulate why or from what.
- • The TARDIS’s malfunction is tied to Susan in a way he cannot yet explain, but he senses it is his responsibility to fix.
- • His usual methods of problem-solving are ineffective here, forcing him to rely on the crew’s instincts.
Objects Involved
Significant items in this scene
The TARDIS doors are a critical barrier that malfunction in a way that defies logic, amplifying the crew’s paranoia. They swing open and shut on their own, cycling erratically inside the console room. Susan declares this behavior impossible, as the doors respond only to deliberate commands. The doors close abruptly in front of Ian as he approaches, then reopen moments later, as if taunting the crew. This autonomous motion underscores the TARDIS’s breakdown, leaving the crew feeling exposed and vulnerable. The doors’ behavior is a tangible manifestation of the unseen force at work, turning a mundane feature of the ship into a source of dread and confusion.
The TARDIS water dispenser is a critical resource that fails at a pivotal moment. Susan reaches for it to fetch liquid for the Doctor’s wound but finds it empty, a stark indication of the ship’s broader malfunction. The failure of this integrated fixture underscores the crew’s vulnerability, as even basic medical supplies are unavailable. The empty dispenser serves as a tangible clue that the TARDIS is not just malfunctioning mechanically but is actively depriving the crew of essential resources, amplifying their sense of helplessness and foreshadowing further systemic failures.
Susan’s ointment bandage is a medical tool that becomes a symbol of her knowledge and the crew’s desperate attempts to cope with the crisis. She cuts a length of the bandage and applies it directly to the Doctor’s head wound, demonstrating her familiarity with advanced medical techniques. The bandage’s colored ointment disappears as it heals the injury, showcasing its advanced properties. Barbara and Ian observe this process with a mix of awe and concern, as it highlights Susan’s unique role in the group. The bandage serves as a temporary solution to the Doctor’s injury but also underscores the crew’s reliance on Susan’s expertise amid the chaos.
The TARDIS doors are a critical barrier that malfunction in a way that defies logic, amplifying the crew’s paranoia. They swing open and shut on their own, cycling erratically inside the console room. Susan declares this behavior impossible, as the doors respond only to deliberate commands. The doors close abruptly in front of Ian as he approaches, then reopen moments later, as if taunting the crew. This autonomous motion underscores the TARDIS’s breakdown, leaving the crew feeling exposed and vulnerable. The doors’ behavior is a tangible manifestation of the unseen force at work, turning a mundane feature of the ship into a source of dread and confusion.
Location Details
Places and their significance in this event
The TARDIS console room is the epicenter of the malfunction, where the crew sprawls amid chaos. The Doctor lies on the floor, Ian slumps in a chair, and Susan drapes over the console, all disoriented and injured. The lights flicker during violent lurches, and the doors cycle open and shut on their own, creating a disorienting and hostile environment. Susan’s attempt to operate the console results in her collapse, while Barbara tends to the injured crew. The room, once a control hub, now feels like a battleground, where the crew’s survival hinges on uncovering the source of the malfunction. The atmosphere is one of creeping dread, as the TARDIS’s instability mirrors the crew’s mounting fear and confusion.
The TARDIS medical storage room is a compact adjacent compartment off the console room, where Susan ducks in to grab bandages and ointment amid the ship’s violent lurches. The shelves hold medical supplies ready for crises, their contents gleaming under dim, flickering lights. The space hums with the TARDIS’s unstable energy, offering quick relief for neck pains and injuries tied to the malfunction. Its tight confines amplify the crew’s desperation as doors cycle wildly nearby, serving as a temporary refuge amid the chaos. The medical storage room symbolizes the crew’s reliance on Susan’s knowledge and the TARDIS’s failing systems, as even basic care becomes a struggle.
Narrative Connections
How this event relates to others in the story
Within this episode
"Susan's initial pain and disorientation escalates into witnessing the impossible: the TARDIS doors opening on their own. This impossible event deepens the mystery and highlights the ship's malfunction."
TARDIS doors malfunction as Susan collapsesAcross episodes
"Susan's insistence on warning the Thals (Episode 8) is mirrored by her later concern for the TARDIS crew's safety (Episode 12), where she warns of an internal threat."
Susan forces the group to intervene"Susan adopts the Thal cape as a symbol of camaraderie with the Thals in Ep 11, and it becomes part of her attire as she collapses in distress in Ep 12."
Parting with the Thals"The violent destabilization of the TARDIS mid-flight (Episode 11) is the immediate cause of the disorientation, memory loss, and physical symptoms experienced by the Doctor and companions in Episode 12."
TARDIS violently destabilized under attack"The Daleks’ relentless countdown in Episode 11 (radiation countdown) creates a sense of escalating threat that carries into Episode 12, where the TARDIS’s malfunction displaces that tension internally, as the Doctor’s earlier desperation (gambling the TARDIS) manifests in chaos."
Doctor’s Plea Fails as Daleks Begin Countdown"Barbara's urgent advocacy for rescuing the Doctor and Susan in The Rescue (cand_evt_scene_a45a91924f174c31_02) is mirrored by her immediate protective role upon regaining consciousness in The Edge of Destruction (cand_evt_scene_c52b263cb480581_01). She tends to Susan first, continuing her commitment to the Doctor's safety even when separated."
Barbara trapped in Dalek lift"The Daleks' genocidal plan and Susan's physical restraint in the control room (Episode 11) seeds anxiety and captivity trauma that resurfaces in her paranoia and neck pain inside the TARDIS (Episode 12)."
Doctor condemns Dalek genocide plan"Barbara's physical rescue from the Dalek corridor (Episode 11) foreshadows her role as the immediate responder to crisis in the TARDIS (Episode 12), where she is the first to regain consciousness and take charge."
Companions risk lives to free Barbara"Susan's visible anxiety and physical stress during the Dalek crisis (Ep 11) carry forward into the TARDIS malfunction (Ep 12), where she awakens with severe neck pain and disorientation."
Doctor bargains with Daleks as Thals attack"Barbara’s advocacy for intervention in Episode 8 (insisting the Thals are their concern due to the life-saving drug) foreshadows her later assertive role in Episode 12, where she defends herself and challenges the Doctor’s accusations."
Ian Volunteers for Solo Thal Warning Mission"Susan's defiant advocacy for intervention in Episode 8 (warning the Thals) mirrors her persistent concern for others in Episode 12, where she immediately tends to the crew despite her own physical distress."
Susan forces the group to intervene"The Doctor's dismissive rejection of Thal technology and his detachment from their problems ('throw it away') foreshadows his emotional and cognitive detachment in the TARDIS malfunction, where he struggles to understand or fix the crisis, alienating his companions."
The Doctor Rejects Thal Technology"Barbara’s farewell to Ganatus—kissing him on the lips—underscores her emotional growth and openness to connection. This prepares her psychological resilience and relational capacity during the TARDIS crisis, where she becomes the stabilizer."
Parting with the Thals"The Doctor's horrified plea to stop the Daleks' genocide ('Stop it, please', Episode 11) mirrors his desperate, ineffective cries to halt the TARDIS's malfunction ('I can't take you back, Susan', Episode 12), both representing his inability to control overwhelming threats."
Doctor’s Plea Fails as Daleks Begin Countdown"The horror of the Doctor witnessing a Thal infiltrator being executed ('forty six, forty five') resonates emotionally with the TARDIS crew's shared disorientation and helplessness in Episode 12 as they wake harmed and uncertain."
Daleks Accelerate Genocide as Thals Breach City"Doctor’s dismissal of Thal technology as 'useless' (Ep 11) echoes in the TARDIS malfunction (Ep 12), where unreliable technology (the ship) is a source of betrayal."
The Doctor Rejects Thal Technology"The Doctor’s rejection of Thal technology and his promise to return for future generations (Episode 11) echoes in Susan’s distressed abandonment of Thal culture when she adopts the TARDIS’s erratic systems (Episode 12). Both scenes reflect a tension between skepticism and acceptance of external guidance."
Parting with the Thals"The Doctor's refusal to intervene to help the Thals (despite Barbara's moral argument about their debt) directly parallels his later reflexive distrust and accusations against Ian and Barbara in the TARDIS malfunction. Both moments show his rigid adherence to non-interference (or control) under threat, escalating into unjust accusations."
Susan forces the group to intervene"Barbara's deduction in the Dalek corridors ('We must find the control room') reflects the urgency and high-stakes thinking that later defines her crisis management in the TARDIS malfunction. Both scenes show Barbara leading under pressure."
Dalek Patrol Announces Thal Invasion"The trauma of Antodus’ sacrifice and Ganatus’ despair (Episode 11) escalates into the internal trauma of the TARDIS crew—where physical disorientation and memory loss reflect a deeper existential and psychological unraveling."
Rockfall traps group in tunnel"The Doctor's desperate negotiation with the Daleks (attempting to stall genocide) escalates into the TARDIS's internal crisis, where his bargaining chips fail and trust erodes."
Doctor bargains with Daleks as Thals attack"The group's moral dilemma over intervening in Episode 8 (warning the Thals) parallels the moral dilemma in Episode 12 (trusting Ian and Barbara despite the Doctor's accusations)."
Ian Volunteers for Solo Thal Warning Mission"Both events feature Barbara taking immediate action to save others before herself: risking her life to free herself in The Rescue (cand_evt_scene_472d520228317e77_01), and tending to Susan and the Doctor despite her own disorientation in The Edge of Destruction (cand_evt_scene_c52b263cb480581_01). This reflects Barbara's consistent heroic selflessness."
Companions risk lives to free Barbara"The temporal paradox in 'The Day of Darkness' echoes the internal threat and instability of 'The Edge of Destruction', where the TARDIS itself seemed under siege from an unseen force."
TARDIS registers impossible temporal paradox"The TARDIS's malfunction in Episode 12 is directly followed by a temporal paradox in Episode 30, suggesting lingering instability from the earlier event."
TARDIS registers impossible temporal paradox"The Doctor's paranoia and fear for his companions, first seen in his irrational accusation of Ian and Barbara in The Edge of Destruction, resurfaces in The Day of Darkness as his desperation to save Ian is misread as weakness by Ixta."
Doctor’s Desperation Misread as Weakness"Susan’s initial disorientation and neck pain (Episode 12) foreshadows her role as the Doctor’s defender when he accuses Ian and Barbara of sabotage (Episode 13). Her fierce loyalty to her grandfather, despite the strain, remains consistent."
Doctor accuses companions of sabotage"The Doctor's initial disorientation and paranoia in Episode 12 escalates into violent accusations of sabotage in Episode 13, marking a critical deterioration in his trust of companions."
Doctor accuses companions of sabotage"The shared physical trauma of neck pain (Episode 12) escalates into a systemic crisis in the TARDIS (Episode 13), where the malfunction threatens to destroy the ship. The Doctor's initial accusations reflect his inability to reconcile the shared symptoms with their loyalty."
Ian saves Barbara from electrocution"The Doctor's desperate pleas in 'The Day of Darkness' mirror his earlier disorientation in 'The Edge of Destruction', where he accuses his companions of sabotage, showing an erosion of trust in his crew."
Doctor’s Desperation Misread as Weakness"Both episodes feature the TARDIS and its companions experiencing instability that reflects the Doctor’s internal conflict, whether through malfunction (Episode 12) or temporal paradox (Episode 30)."
TARDIS registers impossible temporal paradoxThemes This Exemplifies
Thematic resonance and meaning
Part of Larger Arcs
Key Dialogue
"SUSAN: "My neck hurts too. It's going away now. That's better. I couldn't think where I was""
"SUSAN: "No. No, there's something here. Inside the ship.""
"DOCTOR: "I can't take you back, Susan. I can't.""