Doctor confronts Tegana with Barbara’s handkerchief
Plot Beats
The narrative micro-steps within this event
Susan claims to see the eyes in the cave move, but the Doctor dismisses it as her imagination. Ping-Cho then sees Tegana arrive, creating a tense encounter as the Doctor attempts to deflect his suspicions regarding Barbara's whereabouts.
The Doctor presents Tegana with Barbara's handkerchief, found in a passageway, attempting to reveal Tegana's presence in the cave. Tegana deflects, warning of evil spirits and feigning ignorance about the handkerchief's origins, further fueling suspicion.
Who Was There
Characters present in this moment
Overwhelmed with relief but still shaken, her emotional state is a mix of gratitude for her rescue and lingering dread from the near-execution—she is physically and psychologically fragile in this moment.
Barbara is discovered bound and moments from execution in the hidden chamber, her trauma evident in her fragmented recounting of the Mongols’ dice ritual. Her rescue by Ian and Polo is abrupt, leaving her in a state of shock and relief. Barbara’s physical and emotional state is fragile, her description of the execution process (‘They played dice to see who’d kill me’) underscoring the arbitrary brutality she faced. Her role in this event is passive but thematically crucial, as her ordeal exposes the Mongols’ true nature and Tegana’s complicity. Barbara’s relief is tinged with lingering fear, and her trust in the group is reinforced by their timely intervention.
- • Survive the execution
- • Reunite with the group
- • Tegana and the Mongols are directly responsible for her capture and intended execution
- • The group’s trust in Tegana is misplaced and dangerous
Determined and alert, with a mix of adrenaline-fueled urgency and relief upon finding Barbara alive—though his distrust of Tegana deepens with each deception uncovered.
Ian arrives mid-confrontation, immediately validating Susan’s claim about the moving quartz eyes and taking charge of the investigation. His discovery of the hidden door—triggered by his logical deduction that the eyes are set into the rock from behind—is the catalyst for Barbara’s rescue. Ian physically unties Barbara after Polo overpowers the Mongol guard, offering her reassurance and protection. His actions are methodical, brave, and protective, embodying his role as the group’s de facto security and mediator. Ian’s skepticism of Tegana’s supernatural claims is palpable, and his focus on tangible evidence (the handkerchief, the door mechanism) underscores his pragmatic approach to crises.
- • Prove Susan’s observations about the moving eyes are correct
- • Locate and rescue Barbara from the cave
- • Tegana’s warnings about spirits are a smokescreen for his own deceit
- • The cave’s secrets can be uncovered through logical investigation, not superstition
Focused and resolute, with a simmering undercurrent of anger at the Mongols’ betrayal—though his outward demeanor remains controlled and commanding.
Marco Polo arrives just as Ian discovers the hidden door, his authoritative presence immediately shifting the power dynamic. Without hesitation, he swings the door open—revealing Barbara bound and moments from execution—and physically overpowers the Mongol guard poised to kill her. His actions are swift, decisive, and protective, embodying his role as both caravan leader and unexpected savior. Polo’s intervention is the turning point of the event, saving Barbara and exposing the Mongols’ brutality, though his brief involvement leaves unanswered questions about his own suspicions of Tegana.
- • Rescue Barbara from imminent execution
- • Assert his authority over the Mongols in the cave
- • Tegana’s warnings about spirits are a distraction from real threats (e.g., Mongol betrayal)
- • His duty as caravan leader extends to protecting all under his care, regardless of their origins
Cold and focused, his emotions are subsumed by his duty to carry out the execution—there is no hesitation, only the anticipation of violence.
The Mongol guard is poised to execute Barbara when Polo intervenes, overpowering him moments before the blade falls. His presence is brief but critical, embodying the brutal efficiency of Tegana’s faction. The guard’s hostility is evident in his readiness to kill, and his defeat at Polo’s hands is swift and decisive. His role in the event is purely antagonistic, serving as a physical manifestation of the Mongols’ threat to Barbara and, by extension, the group. The guard’s execution dice ritual adds a layer of arbitrary cruelty to the scene, reinforcing the Mongols’ sadistic nature.
- • Carry out Barbara’s execution as ordered
- • Assert the Mongols’ authority over the cave
- • Barbara is a legitimate target (as per Tegana’s orders)
- • The dice ritual is a fair and binding method for selecting the executioner
Anxious but resolute, her fear of the cave’s supernatural warnings battling her determination to prove she’s right and save Barbara—her emotional state is a mix of vulnerability and defiance.
Susan insists she saw the quartz eyes move, defending her observation against the Doctor’s dismissal with quiet determination. She guides Ian to the specific face with the moving eyes, her frustration growing as the Doctor and Tegana downplay her claims. Susan’s role in this event is pivotal: her insistence on the truth (despite being dismissed) leads Ian to the hidden door and, ultimately, to Barbara’s rescue. Her emotional state is a mix of fear (of the cave’s eerie atmosphere) and defiance (against the Doctor’s skepticism), but her loyalty to Barbara and the group drives her to speak up. Susan’s youthful curiosity is tempered by the urgency of the moment, and her confirmation of the handkerchief’s location to Tegana adds to the mounting evidence against him.
- • Prove the quartz eyes are moving (and thus, the cave has secrets)
- • Help locate Barbara before it’s too late
- • Her observations are valid, even if the Doctor doesn’t believe her
- • Tegana’s warnings about spirits are a distraction from the real danger (the Mongols)
Calculating and uneasy, masking his guilt with performative supernatural dread—his invocation of Hashashin spirits is a desperate attempt to redirect suspicion away from his faction’s actions.
Tegana arrives unexpectedly, his demeanor shifting from feigned concern to ominous warning as he deflects the Doctor’s accusation about Barbara’s handkerchief. He invokes the ‘great spirits of Hashashin,’ performing a ritualistic invocation to dissuade the group from investigating further. His body language is tense, his voice low and commanding, as he attempts to manipulate the group into leaving the cave. Tegana’s abrupt departure after the invocation leaves no room for rebuttal, reinforcing his role as a shadowy, untrustworthy figure. His supernatural claims are a thin veil for his involvement in Barbara’s capture and the Mongols’ execution plot.
- • Prevent the group from discovering Barbara’s capture or the hidden chamber
- • Deflect blame onto supernatural forces to avoid exposure
- • The group’s skepticism (especially the Doctor’s) makes them vulnerable to manipulation through fear
- • His faction’s plans (seizing the TARDIS, executing Barbara) must be protected at all costs
Irritated and dismissive of Tegana’s supernatural claims, but his underlying concern for Barbara’s safety tempers his usual brusque demeanor—though he remains unconvinced of the cave’s ‘haunted’ nature until proven otherwise.
The Doctor remains skeptical of Susan’s claims about the moving quartz eyes, dismissing them as imagination and focusing instead on the tangible evidence of Barbara’s handkerchief. His confrontation with Tegana is marked by blunt skepticism, particularly when Tegana invokes supernatural warnings. The Doctor’s refusal to entertain the idea of ghosts or spirits underscores his scientific worldview, though his discovery of the handkerchief forces him to acknowledge that Barbara was indeed in the cave. His role in this event is reactive—challenging Tegana’s claims but ultimately deferring to Ian’s logical deductions and Polo’s decisive action. The Doctor’s emotional range is limited, but his frustration with Tegana’s evasiveness is palpable.
- • Find concrete evidence of Barbara’s whereabouts (beyond Tegana’s denials)
- • Challenge Tegana’s credibility and expose his deceit
- • Supernatural explanations are lazy and unscientific
- • Tegana is hiding something, but the truth can be uncovered through investigation
Deeply unsettled, her fear of the cave’s supernatural warnings amplifying the group’s tension—she is a passive participant, but her emotional state underscores the stakes of the environment.
Ping-Cho supports Susan’s claim about the moving eyes, her fear of the cave’s supernatural dangers aligning with Tegana’s warnings. She remains on the periphery of the action, her role largely observational, but her presence reinforces the group’s unease about the cave. Ping-Cho’s fear is palpable, and she does not actively participate in the discovery of the hidden door or Barbara’s rescue, though her earlier bond with Susan adds emotional weight to the scene. Her participation is secondary but thematically significant, as her fear mirrors the group’s growing distrust of Tegana and the cave’s unknown threats.
- • Avoid angering the ‘spirits’ (as Tegana warns)
- • Support Susan’s claims to validate her own fears
- • The cave is haunted, and Tegana’s warnings should be heeded
- • Susan’s observations are trustworthy, even if the Doctor doubts them
Objects Involved
Significant items in this scene
The quartz eyes in the cave faces are the initial mystery of the event, with Susan insisting they move while the Doctor dismisses her claim as imagination. Ian’s investigation reveals that the eyes are set into the rock from behind, indicating a hidden mechanism or chamber. This discovery is the key to uncovering the hidden door and, ultimately, rescuing Barbara. The quartz eyes function as both a literal and symbolic clue: literally, they hint at the cave’s hidden structure, while symbolically, they represent the unseen dangers lurking beneath the surface. Tegana’s invocation of the ‘great spirits of Hashashin’ ties the eyes to his supernatural warnings, but Ian’s logical deduction exposes them as a man-made deception.
Barbara’s handkerchief serves as the first tangible proof that she was in the cave, directly contradicting Tegana’s claims that she had never entered. The Doctor produces it as evidence during his confrontation with Tegana, and Susan confirms its location in the passageway. The handkerchief’s role is dual: it exposes Tegana’s lie and validates Susan’s observations about the cave’s secrets. Its discovery is the catalyst for the group’s deeper investigation, leading to the hidden door and Barbara’s rescue. The handkerchief is a small but critical object, symbolizing the group’s determination to uncover the truth despite Tegana’s obfuscation.
The quartz eyes in the cave faces are the initial mystery of the event, with Susan insisting they move while the Doctor dismisses her claim as imagination. Ian’s investigation reveals that the eyes are set into the rock from behind, indicating a hidden mechanism or chamber. This discovery is the key to uncovering the hidden door and, ultimately, rescuing Barbara. The quartz eyes function as both a literal and symbolic clue: literally, they hint at the cave’s hidden structure, while symbolically, they represent the unseen dangers lurking beneath the surface. Tegana’s invocation of the ‘great spirits of Hashashin’ ties the eyes to his supernatural warnings, but Ian’s logical deduction exposes them as a man-made deception.
The hidden door behind the rock face is the physical manifestation of the cave’s secrets, concealing the chamber where Barbara is held captive. Ian discovers the door after noticing the quartz eyes’ movement and the crack in the rock face, and Polo swings it open without further effort from the group. The door’s revelation is the turning point of the event, exposing the Mongols’ execution plot and allowing for Barbara’s rescue. Its discovery underscores the cave’s dual nature: a place of both supernatural dread (as Tegana claims) and very real, human-made danger. The door’s sudden appearance also highlights Polo’s authority, as he is the one who physically opens it, reinforcing his role as the group’s protector.
The Mongols’ execution dice are a brutal symbol of their arbitrary cruelty, used to randomly select Barbara’s executioner. The clatter of the dice echoes through the chamber as the winner steps forward, blade in hand, reinforcing the Mongols’ sadistic nature. The dice serve as a narrative device to heighten the tension of Barbara’s near-execution, emphasizing the randomness and inevitability of her fate if not rescued. Their presence also underscores the Mongols’ cultural practices, blending ritual with violence. The dice are discarded or forgotten after Polo’s intervention, their role fulfilled in the scene’s climax.
Location Details
Places and their significance in this event
The Cave of 500 Eyes is the primary setting for this event, its eerie atmosphere amplifying the tension and distrust among the group. The cave’s carved quartz eyes, damp stone, and flickering torchlight create a sense of unease, which Tegana exploits with his warnings about evil spirits. The cave functions as both a physical obstacle (with its hidden chambers and doors) and a psychological battleground, where the group’s skepticism clashes with their growing fear. The cave’s layout—connecting passageways, the outer area where the handkerchief is found, and the inner chamber where Barbara is held—drives the event’s progression, as each discovery (the handkerchief, the moving eyes, the hidden door) brings the group closer to the truth. The cave’s symbolic role is that of a liminal space, where supernatural fears and real dangers intertwine.
The inner chamber is the climax of the event, a cramped and claustrophobic space where Barbara is bound and moments from execution. The chamber is accessed through the hidden door, its revelation a shock to the group. The Mongols’ dice ritual takes place here, the air thick with the tension of impending violence. The chamber’s role is to serve as the Mongols’ execution site, a place of arbitrary cruelty where Barbara’s fate hangs in the balance. Polo’s intervention here is the turning point, as he overpowers the Mongol guard and rescues Barbara. The chamber’s atmosphere is one of dread and urgency, its small size amplifying the stakes of the confrontation.
Organizations Involved
Institutional presence and influence
Tegana’s faction of Mongols is the antagonistic force in this event, responsible for Barbara’s capture, the execution plot, and the use of the cave as a hiding place. Their actions are driven by Tegana’s orders, and their presence in the hidden chamber—where they play dice to select Barbara’s executioner—embodies their brutal efficiency. The faction’s involvement is indirect but critical, as their plot is uncovered through the group’s investigation. The Mongols’ sadistic ritual (the dice game) and their readiness to kill on command highlight their role as Tegana’s enforcers, willing to carry out his deceitful schemes. Their defeat at Polo’s hands exposes their vulnerability and reinforces the group’s growing distrust of Tegana.
The Hashashin are invoked by Tegana as a supernatural threat, serving as a smokescreen for his faction’s real activities. Tegana’s ritualistic invocation of the ‘great spirits of Hashashin’ is performative, designed to frighten the group into leaving the cave and avoiding further investigation. The Hashashin’s role in this event is purely symbolic, representing the group’s fear of the unknown and Tegana’s manipulation of superstition. Their ‘presence’ is fabricated, used to deflect suspicion from the Mongols’ execution plot. The invocation fails to deter the group, however, as Ian’s logical deductions and Polo’s intervention expose the cave’s true dangers.
Narrative Connections
How this event relates to others in the story
Within this episode
"Polo confirms he knows where the cave is, and the narrative follows with the group reaching the cave."
Polo confirms the cave’s location"The events at the cave, specifically Barbara's pursuit of Tegana, lead directly to Tegana sowing distrust between Polo and the travelers upon their return."
Tegana manipulates Polo against the travelers"The Doctor's attempt to expose Tegana leads to further distrust and Barbara's accusation, reflecting Tegana's manipulative nature."
Polo Betrays the Travelers to TeganaAcross episodes
"Barbara's skepticism about Tegana's bandit story in E16 is validated when the Doctor uses Barbara's handkerchief to confront Tegana in the Cave of Five Hundred Eyes in E17."
Polo Confiscates the TARDIS Key"In Episode 16, Susan suggests the Cave of Five Hundred Eyes as Barbara’s possible location; in Episode 17, the group arrives at the cave just in time to rescue Barbara and confront Tegana, validating her suspicion."
Doctor defies Polo to seek Cave"Tegana’s secret alliance with Malik revealed in the Cave of Five Hundred Eyes in Episode 16 is directly echoed when the travelers enter the same cave in Episode 17 and discover its hidden, conspiratorial nature."
Tegana reveals Noghai’s plot to Malik"Ping-Cho’s telling of the Hashashin legend in Episode 16 (about deception, paradise, and assassins) directly reflects the real danger posed by Tegana, who uses lies and manipulation (like the Hashashins) to control others."
Ping-Cho’s Hashashin tale reveals hidden threats"Polo’s authoritarian exclusion of the Doctor in Episode 16 (denying him the right to search for Barbara) is mirrored when he excludes the Doctor again under Tegana’s influence in Episode 17, reinforcing Polo’s fractured leadership."
Polo’s fractured leadership and search party"Barbara's eavesdropping and discovery in the Cave of Five Hundred Eyes (Episode 16) is mirrored when the group later confronts her in the hidden chamber of the same cave (Episode 17)."
Barbara’s eavesdropping exposes the plot"Polo's desperate reliance on Tegana in the desert sets up the entire conflict with Tegana, culminating in the confrontation in the Cave of Five Hundred Eyes where Barbara is captured."
Polo’s Desperate Gamble on Tegana"Barbara and Ian's immediate suspicion of Tegana's alibi at the oasis directly drives their investigation into the Cave of Five Hundred Eyes, where they encounter evidence of his duplicity."
Tegana’s Inconsistent Alibi and Polo’s Blind Trust"The Doctor’s defiance against Polo’s orders in Episode 16 (searching for Barbara despite being told to stay behind) directly leads to his confrontation with Tegana in the Cave of Five Hundred Eyes."
Doctor quietly defies Polo’s order"The Doctor's discovery of the Cave of Five Hundred Eyes' location from Chenchu in E16 directly leads to the confrontation with Tegana in the cave in E17."
Doctor learns cave location from spy"The Doctor’s nighttime interrogation of Chenchu about the cave’s location in Episode 16 leads directly to the confrontation in the cave in Episode 17."
Doctor defies Polo to seek Cave"Barbara’s suspicion of Tegana during the water shortage escalates into her pursuit of him to the Cave of Five Hundred Eyes, where she is captured."
Polo Confiscates the TARDIS Key"Barbara's skepticism of Tegana's bandit alibi, rooted in her observation of absent campfire remnants, directly precedes her pursuit of Tegana to the cave in Episode 17, where she uncovers Tegana's treachery."
Tegana’s Inconsistent Alibi and Polo’s Blind Trust"The Doctor's defiance of Polo’s orders in Episode 16 leads to the group’s nighttime mission into the Cave of Five Hundred Eyes in Episode 17."
Doctor quietly defies Polo’s order"Barbara’s private warning to Ian about Tegana’s suspicious behavior directly motivates her pursuit of him to the Cave of Five Hundred Eyes."
Barbara’s Unheeded Warning to Ian"The Doctor’s decisive action in interrogating Chenchu in Episode 16 reflects his continued proactive role in seeking answers in Episode 17."
Doctor learns cave location from spy"Polo's growing despair and reliance on Tegana in the desert (E16) directly escalates into Tegana's deceptive manipulation in the Cave of Five Hundred Eyes (E17), where Polo's trust in Tegana is further challenged."
Polo’s Desperate Gamble on Tegana"Polo's fractured leadership and exclusion of the Doctor (Episode 16) escalates into the Doctor and Ian taking direct action, including confronting Tegana in the Cave of Five Hundred Eyes (Episode 17)."
Polo’s fractured leadership and search party"Polo's confiscation of the TARDIS key and public humiliation of the Doctor (Episode 16) escalates into a direct confrontation where the Doctor uses the same key to rescue Barbara (Episode 17)."
Polo Confiscates the TARDIS Key"Barbara and Ian's suspicion of Tegana's alibi in Episode 16 (lack of campfire evidence) escalates in Episode 17 when they discover concrete proof of his deception (Barbara's handkerchief in the cave)."
Tegana’s Inconsistent Alibi and Polo’s Blind Trust"The Doctor's quiet defiance of Polo's order to stay behind (Episode 16) directly leads to his later confrontations with Tegana in the Cave of Five Hundred Eyes (Episode 17), where he takes direct action to rescue Barbara."
Doctor quietly defies Polo’s order"Ping-Cho’s storytelling about the Hashashins’ deception foreshadows the real-world deception Tegana employs against Marco Polo and the travelers."
Ping-Cho’s Hashashin tale reveals hidden threats"Polo’s distrust of the Doctor’s explanation of condensation water in Episode 16 parallels his later distrust of Susan’s observation about the moving quartz eyes in the Cave of Five Hundred Eyes in Episode 17, both showing his rigid skepticism."
Polo Demands Proof of Water’s Safety"Susan's curiosity about the Hashashin in Episode 16 mirrors the Doctor's investigation of the same sect in Episode 17. Both scenes involve Susan and the Doctor confronting the legend of the Hashashin, with the Doctor dismissing supernatural claims (moving quartz eyes) which Susan initially insists she saw."
Doctor reveals Hashashin knowledge"The Doctor's confrontation of Tegana using Barbara's handkerchief in Episode 17 plants the seed of suspicion that lingers into Episode 18, where Barbara and Ian recognize the bandit threat based on her prior knowledge."
Ian discovers dead guard and warns Marco"Tegana's manipulation and framing of Barbara in the cave (Episode 17) fuels the Doctor's persistent suspicions of Tegana's true nature (Episode 18)."
Tegana’s veiled threat and the Doctor’s suspicions"The Doctor's confrontation with Tegana using Barbara's handkerchief as proof of her presence in the cave is mirrored when Ian lifts the bandit threat via bamboo deception, showing how mistrust escalates into larger deceptions."
Ian proposes bamboo trap diversion"The consequences of the Cave of Five Hundred Eyes confrontation—where Ian validates Susan’s claim—lead directly to the failed escape attempt when Ian is questioned by Marco Polo about their reckless plans."
Polo and Ian clash over survival tactics"Both events involve the discovery of a dead body (Barbara bound in the cave, a dead Mongol guard at Polo's tent), underscoring the Doctor's companions as perpetual witnesses to violence."
Ian discovers dead guard and warns MarcoThemes This Exemplifies
Thematic resonance and meaning
Key Dialogue
"DOCTOR: If you must know, sir, we are looking for Miss Wright."
"TEGANA: Well, why would she be in this cave?"
"DOCTOR: I think this is your answer. We found it."
"TEGANA: In the passageway. It is not wise to remain in these caves. They are possessed with evil spirits."
"DOCTOR: This man thinks this cave is haunted."
"IAN: Susan was right. She did see the eyes move myself. Look. These eyes you see here have been set in from behind. There must be some sort of a room behind this rock face."
"TEGANA: Do not strike them down, great spirits of Hashashin. Depart! The War Lord Tegana entreats you."