Watkins’ Assassination Attempt and Vaughn’s Invulnerability
Plot Beats
The narrative micro-steps within this event
Watkins, filled with hatred, vows to kill Vaughn if given the chance, then Vaughn mocks Watkins by offering him a loaded gun, daring him to shoot and proving Vaughn's invulnerability when Watkins shoots him multiple times at point blank range, Watkins faints and Vaughn orders that work begin immediately on the machine.
Who Was There
Characters present in this moment
A rollercoaster of terror, defiance, and despair—culminating in utter submission (his fainting symbolizes the death of his resistance)
Watkins arrives with the modified Cerebraton Mentor machine, protesting its lethal capabilities. Vaughn subjects him to the machine’s torture, inducing excruciating fear. Despite his defiance, Watkins is broken when Vaughn hands him a loaded pistol—only for the bullets to pass harmlessly through Vaughn’s body. Watkins faints, his resistance shattered, and he is forced into submission. His emotional state oscillates between terror, defiance, and despair, culminating in his broken plea to kill Vaughn.
- • To protect Isobel (pleads for her freedom)
- • To resist Vaughn’s control (initially defies him, then threatens to kill him)
- • To survive (avoids torture and death by complying)
- • That Vaughn is evil and must be stopped (expressed in his tirade against Vaughn)
- • That he cannot withstand torture (admits this to Vaughn)
- • That his compliance is the only way to ensure Isobel’s safety (implied by his submission)
Cautiously optimistic (about the invasion’s success) but detached (from the moral implications of his actions)
Packer reports UNIT’s successful attack on Cybermen to Vaughn, expressing cautious optimism about the invasion’s progress. He hands Vaughn a loaded pistol during the confrontation with Watkins, acting as a loyal enforcer. His demeanor is detached but obedient, reinforcing Vaughn’s authority. Packer’s role is functional—he facilitates Vaughn’s dominance without question.
- • To ensure the invasion proceeds as planned (by reporting UNIT’s actions to Vaughn)
- • To maintain Vaughn’s authority (by handing him the pistol and following orders)
- • That Vaughn’s strategies will succeed (reflected in his cautious optimism)
- • That his loyalty to Vaughn is the path to power (implied by his unquestioning obedience)
Triumphant and arrogant (reveling in his power over Watkins, laughing as the bullets pass through him)
Vaughn orchestrates the psychological destruction of Watkins by demonstrating the weaponized Cerebraton Mentor machine, subjecting him to excruciating fear. He then hands Watkins a loaded pistol, revealing his invulnerability when the bullets pass harmlessly through his body. Vaughn’s actions are sadistic, megalomaniacal, and calculated, designed to break Watkins’ will and accelerate the production of the machines. His dialogue is laced with Shakespearean flair, emphasizing his theatrical cruelty.
- • To break Watkins’ resistance and force his compliance (by demonstrating the machine’s power and his own invulnerability)
- • To accelerate the production of the weaponized Cerebraton Mentor machines (for his double-cross against the Cybermen)
- • To assert his absolute control over everyone in the room (through fear and domination)
- • That fear is the most effective tool for control (demonstrated by his use of the machine and the pistol)
- • That he is untouchable and invincible (revealed by his laughter as the bullets pass through him)
- • That humanity is weak and can be easily subjugated (reflected in his dismissal of UNIT’s efforts)
Fearful and exploited (off-screen, but her safety is a psychological weapon against Watkins)
Mentioned indirectly by Watkins, who pleads for her freedom. Vaughn dismisses her captivity as a lie, claiming she is 'free' and 'sitting quite comfortably at home.' Her absence and implied vulnerability serve as leverage over Watkins, reinforcing Vaughn’s control over both him and his niece.
- • To be freed from Vaughn’s control (implied by Watkins’ plea)
- • To avoid becoming a tool in Vaughn’s schemes (unspoken, but inferred from Watkins’ desperation)
- • That Vaughn is lying about her freedom (Watkins’ disbelief suggests this)
- • That her safety is contingent on Watkins’ compliance (implied by Vaughn’s taunting)
Indifferent (as a collective force, their emotions are irrelevant; they are tools for Vaughn’s ambition)
Mentioned indirectly through Packer’s report of UNIT’s attack on Cybermen, which Vaughn dismisses as irrelevant. The Cybermen’s impending invasion is framed as inevitable, and Vaughn’s focus is on his double-cross plan using the Cerebraton Mentor machine. Their collective presence looms as a temporary ally, soon to be betrayed.
- • To complete the invasion of Earth (as part of their collective directive)
- • To enforce Cyber-conversion on humanity (implied by their role in the invasion)
- • That their alliance with Vaughn is secure (unaware of his betrayal plan)
- • That humanity is weak and can be easily subjugated (reflected in Vaughn’s confidence)
Detached and obedient (no emotional reaction to the violence, focused solely on following orders)
The guard accompanies Gregory and Watkins to Vaughn’s office, holds Watkins up during the torture, and follows Vaughn’s orders to remove Watkins afterward. He is silent and stoic, acting as a silent enforcer of Vaughn’s will. His presence reinforces the oppressive atmosphere of the office and Vaughn’s absolute control over the situation.
- • To enforce Vaughn’s authority (by restraining Watkins and following orders)
- • To maintain order in the office (by removing Watkins after the confrontation)
- • That Vaughn’s commands must be followed without question (reflected in his unquestioning obedience)
- • That his role is to uphold Vaughn’s power (implied by his actions)
Nervous and fearful (his warnings are half-hearted, and he retreats when Vaughn turns the machine on Watkins)
Gregory assists in bringing Watkins to Vaughn’s office and explains the modifications to the Cerebraton Mentor machine. He warns Vaughn about its dangers but backs away in fear during the confrontation. His role is that of a reluctant technician, caught between his fear of Vaughn and his moral discomfort with the machine’s weaponization. He is physically present but emotionally detached, focusing on survival.
- • To survive (avoids Vaughn’s wrath by complying with his demands)
- • To minimize his role in the machine’s weaponization (warns Vaughn of its dangers, but only weakly)
- • That Vaughn is dangerous and unpredictable (reflected in his fear)
- • That the machine is too dangerous to use (warns Vaughn, but his protest is ineffective)
Objects Involved
Significant items in this scene
The weaponized Cerebraton Mentor machine is the centerpiece of Vaughn’s demonstration of power. Originally designed by Watkins for emotional guidance, it has been modified with 'narrow bandwidth transducers' to make its mind-control effects more directional and lethal. Vaughn uses it to torture Watkins, inducing excruciating fear and pain. The machine’s trumpet-like emitter is pointed directly at Watkins, who collapses in agony. Its role in the event is twofold: as a tool of torture to break Watkins’ resistance and as the key to Vaughn’s double-cross plan against the Cybermen. The machine’s activation marks the moment Watkins’ defiance is shattered, and it becomes clear that Vaughn intends to mass-produce it for his own ends.
The loaded pistol is a symbolic tool in Vaughn’s demonstration of his invulnerability. Packer hands it to Vaughn, who then offers it to Watkins as a final, desperate act of defiance. Watkins fires three point-blank shots, but the bullets pass harmlessly through Vaughn’s body, leaving smoking holes in his shirt. The pistol’s failure to harm Vaughn is a pivotal moment, revealing his supernatural invulnerability and shattering Watkins’ last shred of resistance. The pistol serves as both a literal weapon and a metaphor for the futility of opposing Vaughn’s power. Its role in the event is to underscore Vaughn’s absolute control and the hopelessness of resistance.
The box containing the modified Cerebraton Mentor machine is a transitional object that facilitates the transfer of power from Watkins to Vaughn. Carried by Watkins into Vaughn’s office, it symbolizes the handover of the machine—and by extension, the handover of control over its use. The box is opened to reveal the weaponized device, which Vaughn then uses to torture Watkins. Its role in the event is to set the stage for the demonstration of the machine’s power and the breaking of Watkins’ will. The box is a physical manifestation of the shift from scientific innovation to weaponized domination.
Location Details
Places and their significance in this event
Vaughn’s executive office serves as the power center and battleground for this event, where psychological and physical domination unfold. The dimly lit space is thick with tension, as Vaughn orchestrates the breaking of Watkins’ will. The office’s hidden panel (used by the Cyberman Planner) hints at the larger conspiracy, while the desk and chairs provide a stage for Vaughn’s theatrical cruelty. The atmosphere is oppressive, with the weight of Vaughn’s authority pressing down on everyone present. The office is not just a setting but an active participant in the event, reinforcing Vaughn’s control and the futility of resistance.
Organizations Involved
Institutional presence and influence
The Cybermen (Invasion Force) are mentioned indirectly through Packer’s report of UNIT’s attack on them, which Vaughn dismisses as irrelevant. Their impending invasion is framed as inevitable, and Vaughn’s focus is on his double-cross plan using the weaponized Cerebraton Mentor machine. The Cybermen’s role in this event is as a temporary ally, soon to be betrayed by Vaughn. Their collective presence looms as a force that Vaughn intends to manipulate and ultimately destroy.
UNIT is mentioned indirectly through Packer’s report of their successful attack on Cybermen, which Vaughn dismisses as irrelevant. Their actions are framed as a minor obstacle to the impending invasion, and Vaughn’s confidence in the invasion’s completion suggests that UNIT’s efforts are futile in the face of his and the Cybermen’s plans. UNIT’s role in this event is to highlight the scale of the threat and the futility of conventional resistance against Vaughn’s ambitions.
Narrative Connections
How this event relates to others in the story
Across episodes
"Vaughn's refusal of full cybernetic conversion (Ep 15) is echoed in Ep 16 by his testing of the Cerebraton's psychological torture on Watkins, showing his determination to retain his humanity while wielding inhuman power."
Vaughn’s Fragile Control and Packer’s Doubt"Packer's ruthless order to open fire on Jamie (E14) directly precedes his complicit role in Vaughn's sadistic psychological games and indirect killing of Watkins (E16), showing Packer's escalating loyalty to Vaughn’s violent commands."
Packer orders lethal fire on Jamie"Vaughn’s dismissal of Packer’s concerns about repercussions and assertion of absolute control (Episode 14) is mirrored in his command over Packer to hand him a weapon during Watkins’ interrogation (Episode 16), illustrating Vaughn’s consolidation of power and coercive control over even his closest aides."
Vaughn accelerates invasion timeline"Watkins' initial agitation in Episode 14 over Isobel's safety and Vaughn's threats (e.g., 'If you harmed Isobel...') directly motivates his behavior in Episode 16. His protest against the Cerebraton Mentor being a 'deadly weapon' and his desperate plea about Isobel reflect his ongoing obsession with her safety and resistance to Vaughn's coercion."
Vaughn weaponizes Isobel’s safety"Vaughn's earlier decision to keep Watkins alive for leverage (E14) escalates into his direct weaponization and attempted assassination of Watkins, demonstrating an intensification of his brutality and disregard for ethical boundaries."
Vaughn’s Betrayal and Prisoner Leverage"Vaughn's acceleration of the invasion timeline (Episode 14) escalates into the weaponization and torture scene where Vaughn forces Watkins to confront his own complicity under threat of torture (Episode 16)."
Vaughn accelerates invasion timeline"Zoe and Isobel’s capture (E14) leads directly to their strategic value for Vaughn as hostages (E16), used both as leverage and as justification for his ideological terrorism and psychological control."
Doctor confirms Zoe and Isobel’s capture"Vaughn's sadistic testing of the Cerebraton Mentor on Watkins (Ep16) parallels his psychological domination of Rutlidge (Ep15), both demonstrating Vaughn's use of mind control technology to assert dominance over perceived threats."
Vaughn’s Control Fractures Under Cyber Threat"The assassination attempt scene in Episode 16 (source) parallels the ambush during evacuation in Episode 17—both involve Watkins being targeted and harmed due to Vaughn’s machinations, illustrating the cyclical nature of danger to Watkins."
Ambush during evacuation reveals Vaughn’s betrayal"The confrontation in Vaughn's office involving Watkins and the Cerebraton Mentor (Ep 16) is directly referenced when Packer names Watkins as 'critical' in Ep 17, calling back to the earlier psychological and physical abuse of the Professor."
Doctor’s Uninvited Confrontation"Watkins' assassination attempt and Vaughn's reaction to it are referenced implicitly in the Doctor's challenge to Vaughn's control over the Cybermen, as the Doctor points out that Vaughn's reliance on Watkins is his undoing."
Doctor dismantles Vaughn’s Cyberman control delusion"Watkins' resistant behavior and implied escape in Episode 16 leads directly to his absence in Episode 17, which is explicitly mentioned by Packer as a critical threat ('But what about the Professor? Without him, we can't make any more machines.')."
Vaughn Ignores Warnings and Orders Invasion"Vaughn's sadistic tyranny and dismissiveness toward Packer's warnings in E16 continues into E17, where he smirks at Packer’s concerns about the Doctor’s escape and Watkins' absence."
Vaughn Ignores Warnings and Orders Invasion"Vaughn’s decision to use the Doctor as 'insurance' in Episode 17 is a direct continuation of his strategy of keeping potential threats alive for leverage, first demonstrated in his twisted game with Watkins in Episode 16."
Vaughn’s calculated mercy toward the Doctor"Watkins' traumatic subjection to Vaughn's Cerebraton Mentor in Episode 16 emotionally resonates in Episode 17 through Isobel's protective care of him and the Doctor's acknowledgment of his technical indispensability ('We've got the Professor'), framing Watkins not as a victim but as a linchpin."
UNIT scrambles for missile counterattack"Vaughn's psychological torture of Watkins and his dismissal of UNIT's resistance (E16) escalates into the full-scale Cyberman invasion overwhelming UNIT in E17."
UNIT's Collapse Confirmed"Vaughn’s dismissal of UNIT’s rescue mission in Part 6 (PACKER: But what about the Professor? Without him, we can't make any more machines) directly escalates to the confirmed Cybermen overrun in Part 7 (TURNER: The streets are packed with Cybermen)."
Turner Reveals Cyberman Overrun"Vaughn’s test of the Cerebraton’s power in Episode 16 (psychological domination of Watkins) leads directly to his confrontation with the Doctor in Episode 17, where he again invokes technological control (via Cybernet) to assert dominance."
Vaughn’s calculated mercy toward the Doctor"Vaughn's forced compliance of Watkins through torture (Ep16) symbolically parallels his delusion that he can coerce the Cybermen into obedience (Ep17), both reflecting the theme of failed domination."
Doctor dismantles Vaughn’s Cyberman control delusion"Vaughn’s psychological manipulation of Watkins (using the Cerebraton to induce fear/pain) parallels his later interaction with the Doctor over the monitor, where he again asserts control while dismissing threats."
Vaughn’s calculated mercy toward the DoctorThemes This Exemplifies
Thematic resonance and meaning
Part of Larger Arcs
Key Dialogue
"WATKINS: This is madness. That machine is a deadly weapon now."
"VAUGHN: Kill me? Would you? Give me your gun, Packer."
"WATKINS: Vaughn, obviously I can't choose but to work for you. If I refuse, you'll torture me or kill me. I know I can't stand up to torture, and I don't want to die. You're an evil man, Vaughn. You're sadistic. You're a megalomaniac. You're insane. I pity you, but if I get half a chance, I'll kill you."
"VAUGHN: Take it. There you are. Take it. Now you're free to shoot me, Professor. Shoot. Shoot!"