Monitor reveals Smythe’s hidden surveillance
Plot Beats
The narrative micro-steps within this event
Zoe reveals a monitor hidden behind a portrait door, but Carstairs initially sees nothing, creating confusion about its existence.
The Doctor urges Carstairs and Buckingham to concentrate, and Buckingham eventually sees the monitor that was previously invisible to them, confirming its presence, while the purpose remains unknown making Carstairs question.
Zoe explains the monitor's function as a visual telephone, prompting Buckingham to inquire about the identity of the person on the other end, raising anticipation for the revelation of their adversary.
Who Was There
Characters present in this moment
Alert and focused—her discovery of the monitor fuels a sense of purpose, but she remains composed, ensuring the others understand the significance of what they’re seeing.
Zoe acts as the technical expert, swiftly identifying the monitor as a 'visual telephone' and explaining its function to the group. Her action of opening the portrait door is decisive, revealing the device with a mix of alertness and confidence. She bridges the gap between the group’s skepticism and the Doctor’s assertions, her analytical mind cutting through the confusion to provide clarity.
- • To demonstrate the monitor’s existence and function to the group, validating the Doctor’s warnings about Smythe.
- • To ensure Carstairs and Buckingham fully comprehend the implications of the device, fostering their distrust of Smythe.
- • That technology, even advanced or unfamiliar, can be understood and explained to others.
- • That the truth—once revealed—will compel the officers to question their allegiance to Smythe.
Conflicted—his initial confusion gives way to a mix of astonishment and growing distrust of Smythe, though he remains professionally composed. The revelation of the monitor plants seeds of doubt, but he hasn’t yet fully abandoned his military training or loyalty.
Carstairs begins the event in a state of confusion, unable to see the monitor despite Zoe’s revelation. His skepticism is palpable, but the Doctor’s insistence forces him to concentrate, eventually allowing him to perceive the device. His shift from disbelief to conviction is marked by a growing sense of betrayal, as he grapples with the implications of Smythe’s deception. Physically, he remains tense, his revolver still drawn, reflecting his unease in the face of the unknown.
- • To understand the nature of the monitor and its purpose, seeking clarity amid the chaos of the war game.
- • To reconcile his duty to Smythe with the evidence of his superior’s betrayal, a tension that will drive his eventual defection.
- • That there must be a logical explanation for the anomalies in the war game, even if it challenges his understanding of reality.
- • That Smythe, as his commanding officer, deserves his loyalty—though this belief is now being tested by the monitor’s existence.
Unseen but implied to be smug and confident in his control—his absence from the scene underscores his overconfidence, which the Doctor’s group is now poised to exploit.
Smythe is absent from the scene but looms as the unseen antagonist, his presence felt through the monitor he uses to communicate with unseen adversaries. The device’s existence implicates him as the orchestrator of the war game, a puppet master pulling strings from the shadows. His absence heightens the tension, as the group’s discovery of the monitor confirms his role in manipulating the conflict—though he remains unaware of their breakthrough.
- • To maintain his grip on the war game by erasing memories and enforcing secrecy among his subordinates.
- • To use the monitor to coordinate with unseen allies, ensuring his experiments proceed without interference.
- • That his subordinates, including Carstairs and Buckingham, will remain loyal and obedient despite any anomalies.
- • That the Doctor and his companions are mere intruders who can be eliminated or controlled without consequence.
Astonished yet resolute—her initial disbelief gives way to a mix of curiosity and growing anger at Smythe’s deception. She is already predisposed to question authority, and the monitor’s revelation solidifies her resolve to challenge Smythe’s control.
Buckingham mirrors Carstairs’ initial skepticism, unable to see the monitor until the Doctor urges her to concentrate. Her reaction is one of astonishment as the device materializes, and she immediately questions its purpose and what lies on the other end. Her role as a medical officer and her disillusionment with Smythe’s tactics make her particularly receptive to the Doctor’s revelations, her practical nature driving her to seek answers.
- • To understand the full extent of Smythe’s manipulation, particularly how the monitor fits into his larger scheme.
- • To use this new information to further her defiance of Smythe’s authority, aligning herself more closely with the Doctor’s group.
- • That the war game is not what it seems, and Smythe’s actions are morally indefensible.
- • That the Doctor and his companions are trustworthy allies in exposing the truth.
Determined yet measured—his urgency is tempered by a need to ensure the others fully grasp the stakes, masking any underlying frustration with their initial disbelief.
The Doctor takes a commanding yet patient role, guiding Carstairs and Buckingham to perceive the hidden monitor by urging them to 'concentrate.' His sharp logic and authoritative tone cut through their skepticism, revealing the device as a 'visual telephone' and confirming Smythe’s manipulation of the war game. Physically, he stands as the group’s moral and intellectual anchor, his presence reinforcing the group’s unity against Smythe’s deception.
- • To compel Carstairs and Buckingham to see the monitor as proof of Smythe’s betrayal, thereby securing their alliance.
- • To expose the mechanism of Smythe’s control over the war game, reinforcing the Doctor’s role as the group’s strategic leader.
- • That Smythe’s manipulation of time and war is a grave injustice that must be exposed.
- • That Carstairs and Buckingham, as military officers, will prioritize truth and justice over blind loyalty once presented with undeniable evidence.
Objects Involved
Significant items in this scene
Lieutenant Carstairs’ revolver is a constant, if contextual, presence in this event, symbolizing the tension and potential for violence that underpins the group’s interactions. Though not directly used, the revolver remains drawn and ready, reflecting Carstairs’ unease and the high stakes of the moment. Its presence amplifies the caution in the room, serving as a reminder of the military hierarchy and the dangers of defying Smythe. The weapon’s readiness underscores the group’s precarious position, as they teeter between loyalty and rebellion.
The framed portrait in Smythe’s room serves as the concealment mechanism for the monitor, swinging aside to reveal the device. Zoe’s action of opening the portrait door is the catalyst for the event, exposing the monitor to the group. The portrait’s hinged mechanism integrates seamlessly with the wood-paneled walls, symbolizing the hidden layers of deception in Smythe’s operations. Its role is purely functional in this moment—acting as a barrier that, once removed, unlocks the truth about Smythe’s manipulations.
The concealed visual telephone monitor is the linchpin of this event, serving as tangible proof of Smythe’s manipulation of the war game. Initially invisible to Carstairs and Buckingham, the monitor only becomes perceptible after the Doctor urges them to concentrate, revealing its function as a 'visual telephone'—a device that combines audio and video communication. Zoe’s technical insight identifies it as a tool linking Smythe to unseen adversaries, exposing his role as a puppet master. The monitor’s existence shifts the dynamic from suspicion to active defiance, as the officers now have undeniable evidence of Smythe’s betrayal. Its revelation is a turning point, validating the Doctor’s warnings and setting the stage for the group’s resistance.
The wood-paneled walls of Smythe’s room create an atmosphere of military precision and secrecy, reinforcing the theme of hidden truths. They serve as the backdrop for the portrait door and the monitor, their dark, imposing presence mirroring Smythe’s authoritarian control. The panels’ seamless integration with the portrait door highlights the meticulous planning behind Smythe’s operations, as the walls themselves become complicit in concealing his deception. The group’s discovery of the monitor disrupts this illusion of order, exposing the fragility of Smythe’s control.
Narrative Connections
How this event relates to others in the story
Across episodes
"Zoe's discovery of Smythe's hidden monitor behind the portrait in Episode 35 (which she later uses to steal the prison keys) is explicitly referenced and built upon in Episode 36, where the Doctor emphatically reveals the monitor’s existence to Carstairs and Buckingham."
Zoe discovers Smythe’s hidden agenda"Zoe stealing the prison keys from under Smythe’s pillow (Episode 35) directly leads to her discovering the hidden monitor in Smythe’s room (Episode 36), as the keys serve as leverage for accessing Smythe’s private quarters, where the monitor is found."
Zoe steals prison keys from Smythe"The disorientation of landing in No Man's Land (ep. 35) creates the conditions for Zoe's tech-savvy intervention in ep. 36, as the Doctor and his companions must rely on ingenuity to navigate dangers."
TARDIS Lands in No Man’s Land"The Doctor's defiance during the sham trial (Episode 35) leads to his role as the one who reveals hidden truths (hidden surveillance in Episode 36)."
Smythe’s rigged court-martial condemns the Doctor’s team"The Doctor's near-obliviousness to danger in No Man's Land ('Oh my. Oh.') contrasts sharply with Zoe's later discovery of Smythe's hidden surveillance, suggesting escalating manipulation of perception."
TARDIS Lands in No Man’s Land"The Doctor's attempt to appeal to justice in the sham trial (ep. 35) is paralleled by Zoe's discovery of the hidden visual telephone (ep. 36), both uncovering hidden, manipulative truths beneath surface reality."
Smythe’s rigged court-martial condemns the Doctor’s team"The Doctor's group's disorientation in No Man's Land (Episode 35) is paralleled by their uncovering of hidden surveillance technology (Episode 36), both representing unseen threats."
TARDIS Lands in No Man’s Land"The hidden surveillance monitor from Episode 36 (revealed to Buckingham by the Doctor and Zoe) parallels Harper's secret rebellion in Episode 38. Both represent hidden truths and resistance against oppression, foreshadowing Harper's act of rebellion andJamie and Buckingham's eventual escape."
Harper’s Sacrifice for Jamie’s Escape"Buckingham's initial inability to see the monitor (until the Doctor intervenes) mirrors her later situation in E38, where the Union soldiers' interrogation reflects an external imposition of 'reality' she must resist."
Leroy’s Mercy Undone by Von Weich"Zoe’s discovery of Smythe’s hidden surveillance monitor (Part 2) directly leads to the Doctor cutting Smythe’s surveillance feed in the War Room (Part 3), disrupting his control and enabling the story to move forward."
War Chief Reverses Execution Order"Jennifer Buckingham's ability to perceive hidden truths (first seeing Smythe's surveillance monitor in E36) is mirrored in her resilience against fabricated realities in E38, where she resists accusations of being a spy despite the hostile simulation."
Harper’s Sacrifice for Jamie’s Escape"The discovery of Smythe’s hidden surveillance device in Episode 36 foreshadows the Doctor’s insistence that they return to his headquarters—a location central to Smythe’s monitoring—in Episode 37 as a way to find a map covering all time zones."
Doctor reveals temporal displacement to Carstairs"The revelation of Smythe's hidden surveillance in Episode 36 (a visual monitor spying on the British command) parallels the Confederate Lieutenant Harper's hidden resistance role in Episode 38, both exposing systems of deception and the presence of hidden truth beneath fabricated realities."
Harper’s Sacrifice for Jamie’s Escape"The revelation of Smythe's hidden surveillance in E36 parallels Jamie and Buckingham's entrapment in a fabricated Civil War simulation in E38, both exposing layers of deception under military control."
Union soldiers interrogate Jamie and BuckinghamThemes This Exemplifies
Thematic resonance and meaning
Part of Larger Arcs
Key Dialogue
"ZOE: There it is!"
"DOCTOR: What? You mean you can't see that screen?"
"DOCTOR: Look at the wall! Concentrate!"
"BUCKINGHAM: It is there. I can see it!"
"ZOE: Well, it's like a telephone, only you can see people as well as hear them."
"BUCKINGHAM: What's on the other end?"