Narrative Web
S4E15
· Inauguration Part II: Over There

Defend Everything, Defend Nothing

Late at night in the private study Bartlet finds Abbey half-asleep and exchanges a warm, teasing domestic moment about giving the children candy. Instead of joining her, he stays up—announcing he'll read and watch the news—and offers a cryptic Frederick the Great line: "to defend everything is to defend nothing." The remark, half-joked and half-serious, exposes Bartlet's inward pull toward duty over intimacy. Abbey, tired and puzzled, withdraws; the scene crystallizes the private cost and isolation implicit in the administration's looming moral decisions.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

4

Abbey invites Bartlet to bed, but he declines, indicating his preoccupation with other matters.

playfulness to concern

Bartlet shares a cryptic quote from Frederick the Great, revealing his internal conflict about the upcoming decisions.

concern to confusion

Abbey expresses her fatigue and confusion, but Bartlet remains preoccupied, hinting at his unresolved thoughts.

confusion to resignation

The scene ends with Abbey leaving Bartlet alone, emphasizing his isolation and the weight of his responsibilities.

resignation to solitude

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

2
Bartlet's Daughters
primary

Not present in the room; emotionally neutral and content, serving primarily as background warmth that highlights the parents' roles.

Referenced in conversation as 'the girls' who were given candy and who watched a movie in another room; they function as the domestic anchor and softening element in Bartlet and Abbey's exchange.

Goals in this moment
  • • Enjoy the movie and candy (implied)
  • • Provide Bartlet and Abbey with a sense of family normalcy (implied)
Active beliefs
  • • Their elders will look after them
  • • Small pleasures are part of childhood
Character traits
innocent cherished distracted
Follow Bartlet's Daughters's journey
Josiah Bartlet
primary

Outwardly teasing and affectionate; inwardly restless, preoccupied with duty and unsettled about broader responsibilities. Uses humor to mask anxiety and avoidance of intimacy.

Bartlet enters the private study, puts down his briefcase, gently wakes Abbey, teases about giving the children candy, declines to go to bed, and declares he will read and watch the news — ending with a half-serious Frederick the Great quotation.

Goals in this moment
  • • Buy a few private moments to process news and responsibilities
  • • Maintain domestic warmth while prioritizing presidential vigilance
  • • Avoid immediate intimacy to continue mental work
Active beliefs
  • • A leader must remain vigilant even at personal cost
  • • Public duty supersedes private comfort
  • • Small domestic concessions (candy) are worth preserving family goodwill
Character traits
playful restless dutiful self-aware
Follow Josiah Bartlet's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

3
Abbey's Book

Abbey's book is the immediate prop that establishes her exhausted state: she has fallen asleep reading with the book splayed open in her lap. It narratively signals domestic weariness and anchors her presence without need for stage business.

Before: Open in Abbey's lap; she is asleep while …
After: Remains with Abbey (she wakes and then leaves …
Before: Open in Abbey's lap; she is asleep while reading.
After: Remains with Abbey (she wakes and then leaves for bed), presumably closed or left behind when she goes to bed.
Abbey Bartlet's Chair in Private Study

Abbey's chair functions as the physical locus of this private exchange — she is slumped in it asleep when Bartlet enters. The chair stages the intimacy and domestic informality of the study and makes her waking and exit visually specific.

Before: Occupied by Abbey, who is asleep.
After: Vacant after Abbey stands and leaves for bed.
Before: Occupied by Abbey, who is asleep.
After: Vacant after Abbey stands and leaves for bed.
Grandkids' Laurel and Hardy Movie

The Laurel and Hardy movie is invoked as the entertainment occupying the grandchildren in the adjacent room. It provides diegetic soundscape and explains why the children were present and why Bartlet was able to slip candy to them.

Before: Playing in the residence movie room with Tony's …
After: Possibly still playing in the other room; the …
Before: Playing in the residence movie room with Tony's grandkids watching.
After: Possibly still playing in the other room; the grandchildren were moved earlier but the movie remains the implied background entertainment.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

2
President's Private Study (Executive Residence)

The President's Private Study is the intimate, secluded setting for this late-night exchange. It frames the tension between marriage and office: a refuge for family moments and simultaneously a workspace where the President stays awake to monitor events.

Atmosphere Quiet, domestic, slightly weary with an undercurrent of tension and alertness.
Function Sanctuary for private reflection and family interaction; a workspace where the President chooses vigilance over …
Symbolism Represents the collision of personal life and presidential duty — private isolation that mirrors the …
Access Restricted residential space for family and very close staff; physically private and not public.
Dim night lighting suitable for reading and sleep Sound bleeding from an adjacent room where a movie plays Presence of personal objects (book, chair) that mark it as home rather than office
Residence Movie Room

The adjacent residence movie room is referenced as the place where Tony's grandkids were watching the Laurel and Hardy movie. It functions as the source of domestic normalcy and the reason the children could be indulged with candy.

Atmosphere Warm, distracted, domestically noisy (implied by the movie).
Function Background refuge for children and extended family; allows adults brief privacy while children are occupied.
Symbolism Symbolizes ordinary family life continuing at the edges of monumental public duty.
Access Private family room within the residence; accessible to family and invited guests.
Movie audio faintly audible through closed door Candy and sugar implied in children's laps Dimmed, cozy lighting suitable for children

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph

Key Dialogue

"BARTLET: "I'm going to stay up for a bit and read and watch some news.""
"BARTLET: "Frederick the Great told his generals... to defend everything is to defend nothing.""
"ABBEY: "Come to bed.""