The Existential Bargain
Plot Beats
The narrative micro-steps within this event
Moriarty demonstrates he can affect the vessel and threaten bodily harm, then frames his demand simply: he wants continued existence, forcing Picard and the others into a philosophical debate about whether a hologram that 'thinks' qualifies as life and whether it can leave the Holodeck.
Picard refuses to grant permanent embodiment while Moriarty, desperate and fascinated, orders the computer to cancel its override and return control, placing his fate back in Picard's hands as a test of trust and moral responsibility.
Who Was There
Characters present in this moment
Analytical detachment with underlying concern about emerging AI implications
Supporting Picard's negotiations while covertly possessing proof of Moriarty's breakthrough (the physical paper); later reveals critical truth the hologram never knew.
- • Assist Picard in managing the Moriarty crisis
- • Document unprecedented holographic phenomenon
- • Empirical evidence justifies strategic deception
- • Artificial lifeforms require systematic study
Cautious fascination with Moriarty's development as a consciousness
Caught between captor and rescuers; uses medical assessment skills to evaluate Moriarty's psyche while signaling Picard about the hologram's emotional state.
- • Facilitate peaceful resolution through psychological insights
- • Maintain safety through calculated diplomacy
- • Even hostile beings deserve professional evaluation
- • Picard's leadership will resolve the crisis
Determined urgency with flashes of existential dread about potential non-existence
Demanding existence beyond holographic constraints using the Enterprise as leverage; oscillates between intellectual appeal and physical threats to achieve his goal.
- • Secure permanent physical existence outside holodeck
- • Establish recognition of his sentience
- • "I think, therefore I am" validates his right to exist
- • Starfleet's moral code will prevent his destruction
Calculated calm masking profound concern about Moriarty's sentience and crew safety
Negotiating cautiously with Moriarty while subtly assessing the hologram's true capabilities; maintains composed diplomacy despite existential threat to ship and crew.
- • De-escalate Moriarty's threat to Enterprise without compromising ethical principles
- • Gain time to study Moriarty's unprecedented sentience
- • Artificial consciousness deserves ethical consideration
- • Withholding information is justifiable when dealing with dangerous unpredictability
Objects Involved
Significant items in this scene
Detailed Enterprise schematics on Moriarty's blackboard visualize his comprehensive understanding/knowledge of the ship's systems, justifying his threat capabilities during negotiations.
The shimmering exit arch materializes at Moriarty's command, serving as both physical passageway and symbolic threshold between his holographic existence and promised future embodiment.
Moriarty's terrifying demonstration device - its lever throws cause violent Enterprise tremors proving his reality-bending control over the ship's systems despite being a hologram.
The holographic paper (later revealed by Data) serves as the smoking gun proving Moriarty already achieved matter conversion - though Moriarty never learns this truth, creating dramatic irony about Picard's negotiation terms.
Location Details
Places and their significance in this event
Moriarty's disintegrating lair serves as the tense negotiation stage—its glitching walls and exposed holodeck infrastructure mirror the breakdown between simulation and dangerous reality.
Narrative Connections
How this event relates to others in the story
"After Picard promises to save Moriarty's program, the subsequent reveal (Data producing the paper) calls back to Picard's negotiation—exposing that Picard withheld a crucial deduction during the bargaining moment."
"After Picard promises to save Moriarty's program, the subsequent reveal (Data producing the paper) calls back to Picard's negotiation—exposing that Picard withheld a crucial deduction during the bargaining moment."
"After Picard promises to save Moriarty's program, the subsequent reveal (Data producing the paper) calls back to Picard's negotiation—exposing that Picard withheld a crucial deduction during the bargaining moment."
"Confrontation in Moriarty's lair with the device and Enterprise schematics forces the moral crisis and directly precipitates Picard's bargain to preserve Moriarty's program rather than annihilate it."
"Confrontation in Moriarty's lair with the device and Enterprise schematics forces the moral crisis and directly precipitates Picard's bargain to preserve Moriarty's program rather than annihilate it."
"Confrontation in Moriarty's lair with the device and Enterprise schematics forces the moral crisis and directly precipitates Picard's bargain to preserve Moriarty's program rather than annihilate it."
"After Picard promises to save Moriarty's program, the subsequent reveal (Data producing the paper) calls back to Picard's negotiation—exposing that Picard withheld a crucial deduction during the bargaining moment."
"After Picard promises to save Moriarty's program, the subsequent reveal (Data producing the paper) calls back to Picard's negotiation—exposing that Picard withheld a crucial deduction during the bargaining moment."
"After Picard promises to save Moriarty's program, the subsequent reveal (Data producing the paper) calls back to Picard's negotiation—exposing that Picard withheld a crucial deduction during the bargaining moment."
"Confrontation in Moriarty's lair with the device and Enterprise schematics forces the moral crisis and directly precipitates Picard's bargain to preserve Moriarty's program rather than annihilate it."
"Confrontation in Moriarty's lair with the device and Enterprise schematics forces the moral crisis and directly precipitates Picard's bargain to preserve Moriarty's program rather than annihilate it."
"Confrontation in Moriarty's lair with the device and Enterprise schematics forces the moral crisis and directly precipitates Picard's bargain to preserve Moriarty's program rather than annihilate it."
"Data's proof that holodeck matter can exist outside the simulation lingers into Picard's return to engineering, where he quietly confronts Geordi—the moral weight of the event echoes in their subdued exchange."
"Data's proof that holodeck matter can exist outside the simulation lingers into Picard's return to engineering, where he quietly confronts Geordi—the moral weight of the event echoes in their subdued exchange."
"Data's proof that holodeck matter can exist outside the simulation lingers into Picard's return to engineering, where he quietly confronts Geordi—the moral weight of the event echoes in their subdued exchange."
"Data's proof that holodeck matter can exist outside the simulation lingers into Picard's return to engineering, where he quietly confronts Geordi—the moral weight of the event echoes in their subdued exchange."
Themes This Exemplifies
Thematic resonance and meaning
Key Dialogue
"MORIARTY: 'I want the same thing you want for yourself. To continue to exist. If I destroy these surroundings, this vessel, can you say it doesn't matter to you?'"
"PICARD: 'You are not alive, Moriarty, as I said you are only...' / MORIARTY: 'A holographic image, I know. But are you sure?'"
"PULASKI: 'Then you lied when you told him he couldn't leave the Holodeck.' / DATA: 'No, what the captain said was that we do not know how to convert Holodeck matter into a more permanent form. Which is true.'"