Fabula
Conflict Arc
Interpersonal Conflict
View Graph

President Bartlet's character‑driven dilemma and leadership test: confronted publicly and privately (notably by Justice Crouch and later by Harrison's admission), Bartlet must choose between political ease (a safer, pedigreed nominee) and a principled ...

President Bartlet's character‑driven dilemma and leadership test: confronted publicly and privately (notably by Justice Crouch and later by Harrison's admission), Bartlet must choose between political ease (a safer, pedigreed nominee) and a principled nominee whose jurisprudence will protect rights — the executive's moral choice that defines institutional legacy.

15 events in this arc

Events in This Arc

S3E5 · War Crimes
C.J. Details Church Massacre Weapons Under Press Scrutiny

In the White House press room, alive with the ironic backdrop of a football game on TV, C.J. Cregg approaches the podium on a tense Sunday to brief the press …

S3E5 · War Crimes
Charlie's Intrusion Forces Hoynes' Strained Exit

In the tense aftermath of their explosive confrontation over loyalty, leaks, and gun control, Charlie knocks and enters the Oval Office, interrupting to remind President Bartlet of his Briefing Room …

S3E5 · War Crimes
Bartlet and Hoynes' Explosive Gun Control Standoff and Leak Reckoning

In the Oval Office, President Bartlet aggressively debates Vice President Hoynes on concealed carry's illogic post-Texas church shooting, pivoting to accuse him of leaking his MS diagnosis to force a …

S3E6 · Gone Quiet
Leo Uncovers the U.S.S. Portland's Deliberate Silence Off North Korea

Leo storms into the Situation Room with sardonic gallows humor masking his dread, grilling Nancy on the U.S.S. Portland's unannounced radio silence in the Yellow Sea, perilously close to North …

S3E6 · Gone Quiet
Portland Breaks Radio Silence, Evading Destroyer

As Bartlet overrides Albie's cautions and mobilizes rescue efforts en route to the Situation Room, satellite communication suddenly restores contact with the U.S.S. Portland (Whiskey Three). The crew reports their …

S3E6 · Gone Quiet
Bartlet Overrides Albie's Dire Warnings, Orders Rescue as Portland Breaks Silence

In the Oval Office, veteran diplomat Albie Duncan recounts harrowing histories of submarine disasters near North Korea to urge caution against hasty action, but an impatient President Bartlet interrupts abruptly, …

S1E9 · The Short List
Crouch Tests Bartlet: Harrison or Mendoza?

What begins as genial banter between President Bartlet and retiring Justice Joseph Crouch turns into a pointed interrogation of the President's judgment. Crouch bluntly asserts Bartlet has already chosen Harrison …

S1E9 · The Short List
Calling in the Inner Circle — Harrison Admits Authorship

President Bartlet confronts Judge Peyton Cabot Harrison III with an unsigned legal note; Harrison responds with a casual admission. Bartlet deliberately frames the moment with a disarming personal anecdote about …

S1E9 · The Short List
Bartlet Names Mendoza — Let the Good Fight Begin

In the Oval, after a tense vetting exchange that crystallizes Mendoza's constitutional instincts, President Bartlet formally announces Judge Roberto Mendoza as his Supreme Court nominee. Mendoza's uncompromising answer about presidential-ordered …

S3E14 · Hartsfield's Landing
Bartlet's Chess Deflection Shattered by Crisis Call

President Bartlet disembarks Air Force One into a frenzy of flashing cameras and shouting reporters at Andrews Air Force Base. With effortless charisma, he deflects questions about New Delhi by …

S3E14 · Hartsfield's Landing
Chinese Ambassador's CSS-6 Missile Ultimatum

In the tense Mural Room, Nancy firmly asserts Taiwan's geo-strategic value and labels China's militarization reckless, while Leo defends U.S. carrier positions in international waters. The Chinese Ambassador counters with …

S3E14 · Hartsfield's Landing
Leo Abruptly Ends C.J.-Charlie Prank War Clash

C.J. enters her office to confront Charlie over their escalating prank war, taunting him for crazy-gluing her phone in retaliation for her bending schedule rules. Leo interrupts their shouting match, …

S1E22 · What Kind Of Day Has It Been
C.J. Deflects — Confirms Airspace, Cuts Off Briefing

Under an increasingly hostile press pack, C.J. is forced to acknowledge operational facts she had tried to manage: Minneapolis radar tracked Captain Hutchins, Saudi airspace was used with notification on …

S1E22 · What Kind Of Day Has It Been
Tel Aviv Tease and the Ethics of a Lie

In a brisk hallway beat, C.J. punctures tension with a teasing spelling correction to her assistant, establishing a moment of ease before she is pulled into a confrontation. Danny catches …

S1E22 · What Kind Of Day Has It Been
C.J. Owns the Lie; Danny's Credibility Bruised

In a tight hallway confrontation C.J. refuses to apologize for deliberately misleading the press, framing the deception as an operational necessity to protect lives. Danny, wounded in his professional pride, …